Thoughts on Albion at present
#31
(08-19-2022, 07:33 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(08-19-2022, 06:57 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: As I am trying to work off the same metrics as the those support brice. I will disregard half of last season. 4 league games so far...

1 good performance v Watford
1.5 absolutely shockers v Cardiff and first half at Boro
1.5 'meh' performances v Blackburn and Boro second half

I was really encouraged by the Watford game and it foolishly gave me a sense of hope which made me give Bruce more time in my head. But as has been discussed on this bored and is echoed by my best Pal and BIL who are both villa fans. You get sucked in by the occasional performance coupled with Bruce's affable and likeable personality. Only to get stuck into the never ending cycle of disappointment > anger > apathy > hope.

Frankly, Bruce has always been the same, his teams are four (most the time) with little in the way of identity, little in the way of personality and little in the way of excitement.

Bruce must be on the verge of getting the nudge, and any less than 2 wins from 3, combined with consistent levels of performance with clear patterns of play should do it.

Bruce has managed 6 wins from 21 games. The players on the field against Cardiff were 10 of the 11 who finished the final game last season.
He really has achieved nothing in 8 months.
He may as well stay, as nobody can change anything with Lai in charge.

Or with this group of players, that we can't off-load.
Reply
#32
A lot of sense from both sides, for and against keeping/paroling Bruce.
The cents coming from Lai will be on promotion as a virtual guarantee, not “there or thereabouts. One more game without a decent performance and…

This is not what I want, but what I feel our reverse Croesus owner will do.

Lastly, Bruce is able enough but just not lucky. Under Hodgsen (ffs) a goal always turned up. Under Bruce, it’s an injury that turns up.
Reply
#33
Bruce has been very unlucky in recent years then. At vile and Newcastle. Looked what he had at vile and didn’t take them up.
It’s his ability in the modern game not bad luck holding you back I reckon
Reply
#34
(08-20-2022, 05:55 AM)Babel Wrote: A lot of sense from both sides, for and against keeping/paroling Bruce.
The cents coming from Lai will be on promotion as a virtual guarantee, not “there or thereabouts. One more game without a decent performance and…

This is not what I want, but what I feel our reverse Croesus owner will do.

Lastly, Bruce is able enough but just not lucky. Under Hodgsen (ffs) a goal always turned up. Under Bruce, it’s an injury that turns up.

Also helped that Hodgson knew his best players. I’m not convinced Bruce has a clue what his strongest starting lineup is, which after this length of time is pretty amateur
Reply
#35
(08-20-2022, 09:27 AM)BaggieBaggieBromBrom Wrote:
(08-20-2022, 05:55 AM)Babel Wrote: A lot of sense from both sides, for and against keeping/paroling Bruce.
The cents coming from Lai will be on promotion as a virtual guarantee, not “there or thereabouts. One more game without a decent performance and…

This is not what I want, but what I feel our reverse Croesus owner will do.

Lastly, Bruce is able enough but just not lucky. Under Hodgsen (ffs) a goal always turned up. Under Bruce, it’s an injury that turns up.

Also helped that Hodgson knew his best players. I’m not convinced Bruce has a clue what his strongest starting lineup is, which after this length of time is pretty amateur
He's consistent in his team selection, which means that he does know his strongest selection. Whether you or I agree with it is a different matter.
And he can only select from the players available. Hardly his fault. He has to manage what he's got , obviously.
Reply
#36
(08-19-2022, 09:07 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-19-2022, 07:33 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(08-19-2022, 06:57 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: As I am trying to work off the same metrics as the those support brice. I will disregard half of last season. 4 league games so far...

1 good performance v Watford
1.5 absolutely shockers v Cardiff and first half at Boro
1.5 'meh' performances v Blackburn and Boro second half

I was really encouraged by the Watford game and it foolishly gave me a sense of hope which made me give Bruce more time in my head. But as has been discussed on this bored and is echoed by my best Pal and BIL who are both villa fans. You get sucked in by the occasional performance coupled with Bruce's affable and likeable personality. Only to get stuck into the never ending cycle of disappointment > anger > apathy > hope.

Frankly, Bruce has always been the same, his teams are four (most the time) with little in the way of identity, little in the way of personality and little in the way of excitement.

Bruce must be on the verge of getting the nudge, and any less than 2 wins from 3, combined with consistent levels of performance with clear patterns of play should do it.

Bruce has managed 6 wins from 21 games. The players on the field against Cardiff were 10 of the 11 who finished the final game last season.
He really has achieved nothing in 8 months.
He may as well stay, as nobody can change anything with Lai in charge.

Or with this group of players, that we can't off-load.
This is my thinking too, Bruce may not be the answer but who is given that most of this lot have seen off 5 or 6 managers with different philosophies and we are fast becoming an impatient club ,who with any real ambition would want to come here knowing its odds on it will end in tears and with a tarnished reputation after failing with this bunch of feckless fuggers, no matter how good they appear to be on paper!
 Unfortunately until we can get rid of the core of this bunch and replace with players who have drive ,hunger,ambition and a point to prove i cant see any manger staying more than a season at best before the wheels come yet again, and until this useless bunch who own us fugg off it aint going to get better anytime soon as far as i can see.
Reply
#37
I think what it boils down to is that it takes a number of factors to succeed.

Bruce I think has more than the ability to see what’s wrong, identify areas of weakness, attempt to solve them. I think he has enough experience to be trusted to fill those gaps also, perhaps moreso than recent candidates of lesser experience. I also don’t think he has quite the shadiness aspect of his last English predecessor; despite being a less-decorated coach.

Where it falls down is that I don’t think he’s convincing enough in what he gets out of them. Whilst we (finally all thankfully, in the main) seem to recognise the scale of the challenge, where we’re still unconvinced - after several months now - is how much improvement has been actually achieved. Not a lot according to the stats, and not a vast amount in terms of spectacle either. There are improvements but in each of the three games we’ve played there have been clear deficiencies on the pitch. Spotting them is great, Steve, how are you going to fix them? It’s now been 8 months and you’re still finding more. Which helps you somewhat.

I also think another thing working against Steve Bruce, is that sadly he’s Steve Bruce. I think many had made their minds up about the appointment from the start, which although may well prove correct is an easy (rather than a clever) thing to do. Most managers fail; it’s safe and easy territory being critical of the manager. And this one has been around so long he’s become the TCM+1 channel to a lot of folks who are demanding Sky Box Office performances. When we don’t and haven’t had the cast available for a few years, not helped by selling your one talisman for a shady ‘£17m’. It’s amazing how the rest fell into the sand.
Reply
#38
(08-20-2022, 09:35 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(08-20-2022, 09:27 AM)BaggieBaggieBromBrom Wrote:
(08-20-2022, 05:55 AM)Babel Wrote: A lot of sense from both sides, for and against keeping/paroling Bruce.
The cents coming from Lai will be on promotion as a virtual guarantee, not “there or thereabouts. One more game without a decent performance and…

This is not what I want, but what I feel our reverse Croesus owner will do.

Lastly, Bruce is able enough but just not lucky. Under Hodgsen (ffs) a goal always turned up. Under Bruce, it’s an injury that turns up.

Also helped that Hodgson knew his best players. I’m not convinced Bruce has a clue what his strongest starting lineup is, which after this length of time is pretty amateur
He's consistent in his team selection, which means that he does know his strongest selection. Whether you or I agree with it is a different matter.
And he can only select from the players available. Hardly his fault. He has to manage what he's got , obviously.
This is true. He is consistent enough, but personally I think he appears clueless at times as a result of this consistency.
Reply
#39
A goal scorer would make a massive difference.
If we could go a goal up in games we would have something to hold onto and build from.
I know the performances have been a bit up and down but I think by and large the effort has been there.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)