Matt Le Downtherabbithole!
#31
(04-06-2022, 09:47 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I think the point is its ran and directed by a small bunch of people. 

I have to be careful how I say the next bit otherwise people will label me as a denier. 

I think our media is giving us a streamlined version of the truth. Its as if they think we're children and any deviation away from a star wars like good v evil stance will just confuse us. The  problem with this approach is it leaves a gap which conspiracy theorists fill and that causes far more division than the unpalatable truths would have caused. 

There has been evidence of Ukraine shooting Russian prisoners (as reported on the BBC) but it didn't get much coverage.

There's also no doubt that Ukraine had a special regiment in the east which was pro-nazi and glories in nazi imagery. This was well covered and criticised in the media before the war and is still widely available in historical searches. It barely gets mentioned now.

Similarly, there's  also earlier Western reports of discrimination against Russian speakers in Easter Ukraine. Again, that doesn't often get mentioned now.

Do I think Russia should of invaded? Emphatically not. Do I think Putin is dangerous? Yes. Should we help  Ukraine? Absolutely. 

But I still don't think we're being given the whole truth. Not for any nefarious reasons of trying to subvert the truth, more because I think they think we're not 'sophisticated ' enough to handle it.

It is there, Ross Atkins did an article on it a couple of weeks ago. Because of the fast moving news though it does disappear off the front page quickly. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-europe-60853404
Reply
#32
(04-06-2022, 01:11 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(04-06-2022, 09:47 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I think the point is its ran and directed by a small bunch of people. 

I have to be careful how I say the next bit otherwise people will label me as a denier. 

I think our media is giving us a streamlined version of the truth. Its as if they think we're children and any deviation away from a star wars like good v evil stance will just confuse us. The  problem with this approach is it leaves a gap which conspiracy theorists fill and that causes far more division than the unpalatable truths would have caused. 

There has been evidence of Ukraine shooting Russian prisoners (as reported on the BBC) but it didn't get much coverage.

There's also no doubt that Ukraine had a special regiment in the east which was pro-nazi and glories in nazi imagery. This was well covered and criticised in the media before the war and is still widely available in historical searches. It barely gets mentioned now.

Similarly, there's  also earlier Western reports of discrimination against Russian speakers in Easter Ukraine. Again, that doesn't often get mentioned now.

Do I think Russia should of invaded? Emphatically not. Do I think Putin is dangerous? Yes. Should we help  Ukraine? Absolutely. 

But I still don't think we're being given the whole truth. Not for any nefarious reasons of trying to subvert the truth, more because I think they think we're not 'sophisticated ' enough to handle it.

It is there, Ross Atkins did an article on it a couple of weeks ago. Because of the fast moving news though it does disappear off the front page quickly. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-europe-60853404
Reply
#33
Sorry fuzzy, just looked back through the posts and that was yours not spandaus - I was just trying to tidy the quotes not spread fake news  Big Grin
Reply
#34
(04-06-2022, 01:11 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It is there, Ross Atkins did an article on it a couple of weeks ago. Because of the fast moving news though it does disappear off the front page quickly. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-europe-60853404

Your right, it is there. The BBC also reported the following:

The shooting of unarmed Russian prisoners of war. (An obvious war crime, but didn't gain any lasting traction)
The youtubing of russian prisoners for propaganda purposes. (Interestingly, despite admitting it was against the Geneva convention, the report goes on to say how it still might be seen as acceptable.)

But my point was all these are quickly drowned out by the prevailing narrative.

On a tangent, I watched the video and there was some parts which jarred slightly. The main problem is that it, in essence, to demonstrate the lies (which they are) coming from Putin they minimise the very obvious problems in Ukranian society to make it a simplistic good v bad editorial. For example, 'ONLY' 10-15% of the regiment were openly admitting to being Nazis? If that was the British army, quite rightly there would be an outcry. You certainly wouldn't send them to a part of your country that has a separatist movement to 'learn their trade'. Also, blaming the Russians for their existence was quite a convoluted twist of logic. In addition, alluding that people who voted for the Le pen's (however distasteful that family are) are nazis is a stretching of the truth.

This approach gives conspiracy theorists and downright liars room to breathe and grow.

The real truth would have been yes, Ukraine has problems, but that doesn't mean they should be invaded on an obviously false pretext. They do have an elite regiment with a nazi history, but they took the pragmatic option when their back was against the wall and gave them their blessing.


Still, I should say again as it looks like I'm in danger of sounding pro-Russian, Russia should never have invaded, Putin is dangerous and we should help the Ukranians in any way we can.
Reply
#35
(04-06-2022, 02:05 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-06-2022, 01:11 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It is there, Ross Atkins did an article on it a couple of weeks ago. Because of the fast moving news though it does disappear off the front page quickly. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-europe-60853404

Your right, it is there. The BBC also reported the following:

The shooting of unarmed Russian prisoners of war. (An obvious war crime, but didn't gain any obvious traction)
The youtubing of russian prisoners for propaganda purposes. (Interestingly, despite admitting it was against the Geneva convention, the report goes on to say how it still might be seen as acceptable.)

But my point was all these are quickly drowned out by the prevailing narrative.

On a tangent, I watched the video and there was some parts which jarred slightly. The main problem is that it, in essence, to demonstrate the lies (which they are) coming from Putin they minimise the very obvious problems in Ukranian society. Which is kind of what I was talking about. For example,  'ONLY' 10-15% of the regiment were openly admitting to being Nazis? If that was the British army, quite rightly there would be an outcry. You certainly wouldn't send them to a part of your country that has a separatist movement to 'learn their trade'. Also, blaming the Russians for their existence was quite a convoluted twist of logic. In addition, alluding that people who voted for the Le pen's (however distasteful that family are) are nazis is a stretching of the truth.

The real truth would have been yes, Ukraine has problems, but that doesn't mean they should be invaded on an obviously false pretext. They do have an elite regiment with a nazi history, but they took the practical option when their back was against the wall and gave them their blessing.


Still, I should say again as it looks like I'm in danger of sounding pro-Russian, Russia should never have invaded, Putin is dangerous and we should help the Ukranians in any way we can.

No need to protest any further Fuzz. You're one of the most level-headed posters on here and a million miles from a swivel eyed loon.
Reply
#36
(04-06-2022, 02:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Sorry fuzzy, just looked back through the posts and that was yours not spandaus - I was just trying to tidy the quotes not spread fake news  Big Grin

Damn it, I spent ages on that reply as well! Smile
Reply
#37
(04-06-2022, 02:05 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-06-2022, 01:11 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It is there, Ross Atkins did an article on it a couple of weeks ago. Because of the fast moving news though it does disappear off the front page quickly. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-europe-60853404

Your right, it is there. The BBC also reported the following:

The shooting of unarmed Russian prisoners of war. (An obvious war crime, but didn't gain any lasting traction)
The youtubing of russian prisoners for propaganda purposes. (Interestingly, despite admitting it was against the Geneva convention, the report goes on to say how it still might be seen as acceptable.)

But my point was all these are quickly drowned out by the prevailing narrative.

On a tangent, I watched the video and there was some parts which jarred slightly. The main problem is that it, in essence, to demonstrate the lies (which they are) coming from Putin they minimise the very obvious problems in Ukranian society to make it a simplistic good v bad editorial. For example,  'ONLY' 10-15% of the regiment were openly admitting to being Nazis? If that was the British army, quite rightly there would be an outcry. You certainly wouldn't send them to a part of your country that has a separatist movement to 'learn their trade'. Also, blaming the Russians for their existence was quite a convoluted twist of logic. In addition, alluding that people who voted for the Le pen's (however distasteful that family are) are nazis is a stretching of the truth.

This approach gives conspiracy theorists and downright liars room to breathe and grow.

The real truth would have been yes, Ukraine has problems, but that doesn't mean they should be invaded on an obviously false pretext. They do have an elite regiment with a nazi history, but they took the pragmatic option when their back was against the wall and gave them their blessing.


Still, I should say again as it looks like I'm in danger of sounding pro-Russian, Russia should never have invaded, Putin is dangerous and we should help the Ukranians in any way we can.

Not at all, the highlighted text is exactly what should be the news. War is a shitty place to find yourself and within any army you will find some real nasty fuckers that will go well beyond the rules of conduct, that will apply to Russia, Ukraine, Syria, UK and the US and probably every army on the planet.

The simple truth is there should never have been an invasion.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: