Manager quandary
#31
(01-31-2022, 02:03 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: On Saturday we saw what Valball really is. After the compromise, and promise, of playing it out and between the lines at times over the last few months, he told the players to stop fucking about and stick to plan A = Get it forward into the oppos third and press and fight for it. Seems simple as.

It worked for ten minutes and again we should have scored BUT as soon as the intensity dropped it was just awful clogging football. Terrible to watch and zero end product.

Now i bought into the project idea initially but now i'm just not sure how much time, and how many players would need to be turned over before we have a team that can at minimum play like Barnsley! Or what would theoretically be Barnsley PLUS with better players?

More importantly I'm not sure I WANT a team that can develop into a better version of Barnsley. Despite the tenuous links i was making myself to other high press managers its obvious that pure Valball is NOT Bielsaball or anything like what Klipperty offers.

I didn't have a lot of time for Dowling, Zahore appeared under his watch ffs. But in removing him they removed some balance/counterargument from within the management team. He wanted Wilder, who is having some success at Boro, and was open in his assessment that Val's footballing philosophy would just not be accepted here.

Val has got a lot right! Putting a system in place throughout the age groups, creating a pathway from the academy to the first team and criticising our recent transfer activity in purchasing mediocre players with no resale value. However, this should be a given for any new manager coming in and it's not enough for us to endure a spell of management that is becoming torturous.

When it doesn't feel like even a win on Saturday would be enough to appease fans you question if it can be retrieved. But who knows in this ridiculous game? Three wins on the bounce and Andy Carroll rampaging through the division........he gets more time from the owners and the fans climb off his back a bit?? That just seems very unlikely as of today.

Apart from getting all levels playing his style I disagree about the pathway etc... Youth has come through every season in the last few years. I don't think Six has bought more through than anyone else? I stand to be corrected though.
Reply
#32
(01-31-2022, 02:15 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 02:03 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: On Saturday we saw what Valball really is. After the compromise, and promise, of playing it out and between the lines at times over the last few months, he told the players to stop fucking about and stick to plan A = Get it forward into the oppos third and press and fight for it.  Seems simple as.

It worked for ten minutes and again we should have scored BUT as soon as the intensity dropped it was just awful clogging football.  Terrible to watch and zero end product.

Now i bought into the project idea initially but now i'm just not sure how much time, and how many players would need to be turned over before we have a team that can at minimum play like Barnsley!  Or what would theoretically be Barnsley PLUS with better players?

More importantly I'm not sure I WANT a team that can develop into a better version of Barnsley.  Despite the tenuous links i was making myself to other high press managers its obvious that pure Valball is NOT Bielsaball or anything like what Klipperty offers.

I didn't have a lot of time for Dowling, Zahore appeared under his watch ffs.  But in removing him they removed some balance/counterargument from within the management team.  He wanted Wilder, who is having some success at Boro, and was open in his assessment that Val's footballing philosophy would just not be accepted here. 

Val has got a lot right!  Putting a system in place throughout the age groups, creating a pathway from the academy to the first team and criticising our recent transfer activity in purchasing mediocre players with no resale value.  However, this should be a given for any new manager coming in and it's not enough for us to endure a spell of management that is becoming torturous.

When it doesn't feel like even a win on Saturday would be enough to appease fans you question if it can be retrieved.  But who knows in this ridiculous game? Three wins on the bounce and Andy Carroll rampaging through the division........he gets more time from the owners and the fans climb off his back a bit?? That just seems very unlikely as of today.

Apart from getting all levels playing his style I disagree about the pathway etc... Youth has come through every season in the last few years. I don't think Six has bought more through than anyone else? I stand to be corrected though.

I'm being a bit generous maybe Smile but if the principle is followed through we should see more kids come through.  However, as I said this really should be a given regardless of who is in charge.
Reply
#33
(01-31-2022, 02:39 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: I'm being a bit generous maybe Smile but if the principle is followed through we should see more kids come through.  However, as I said this really should be a given regardless of who is in charge.

We'll get more kids coming through because we won't have any money to buy anyone in the next few seasons!
Reply
#34
In fairness, the age group sides seem to have taken to Valball far better than the first team.
Reply
#35
(01-31-2022, 02:57 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: In fairness, the age group sides seem to have taken to Valball far better than the first team.

Lower quality opposition and more open minded players who know no better maybe?
Reply
#36
(01-31-2022, 02:57 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: In fairness, the age group sides seem to have taken to Valball far better than the first team.

I wonder why that is.
Reply
#37
Val has possibly played more of the youth but I don't think it's through choice.

It's good that he doesn't exclude them but it's not the same as Bilic putting Ferguson in the first team out of the blue when we had other options available. TGH and Fellows got their opportunities because of lack of other options and TGH happened to grab it with both hands.
Reply
#38
(01-31-2022, 02:58 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Lower quality opposition and more open minded players who know no better maybe?

Quality is relative as our U23s don't possess the same quality as our XI (currently debatable actually). Youngsters keen to impress and be given a chance? A better fit of personnel?

(01-31-2022, 02:59 PM)MrFizz Wrote: I wonder why that is.

Some of the goals our U23s have scored this season have been the absolute epitome of what Val wants to do with the first team.
Reply
#39
(01-31-2022, 03:01 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 02:58 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Lower quality opposition and more open minded players who know no better maybe?

Quality is relative as our U23s don't possess the same quality as our XI (currently debatable actually). Youngsters keen to impress and be given a chance? A better fit of personnel?

(01-31-2022, 02:59 PM)MrFizz Wrote: I wonder why that is.

Some of the goals our U23s have scored this season have been the absolute epitome of what Val wants to do with the first team.

Could it be that 'the kids' are interested in learning/realise that if they cant do what is being asked they'll be gone? Whereas the overpaid/underperforming cockwombles in the first team don't give a stuff, knowing they can sit out their contract and then move for nothing anyway (getting a big bonus as reward)?

Just a thought, loike.
Reply
#40
(01-31-2022, 03:00 PM)Sliced Wrote: Val has possibly played more of the youth but I don't think it's through choice.

It's good that he doesn't exclude them but it's not the same as Bilic putting Ferguson in the first team out of the blue when we had other options available. TGH and Fellows got their opportunities because of lack of other options and TGH happened to grab it with both hands.

Dave played Harper (16 league games), Field (12), Edwards (6), Leko (2)
Slav played O'Shea (16+1), Ferguson (21)
Six has played Fellows (1+3), TGH (6+2), Tulloch (0+1)

(Apps data from Wiki, so may be a little inaccurate), in short most managers seem to bring through 2 / 3 players a season.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)