Second referendum
#31
(02-26-2019, 08:33 PM)Lillwall\s left foot Wrote: I'm impressed by your perseverance! the"nobody needs to explain themselves" response is pure gold, and i believe official ERG policy ?I'm a lefty liberal remainer meself but work with a Tory Leave voter that I both like and respect.  From a working class background he studied politics and is both intelligent and thoughtful from very much the centre of the  party.   I asked him WHY? he had voted leave...

1.  Democracy! He objected to the non-democratic nature of the EU, particularly the appointment of senior leaders and the influence they have on the governance of our country.
2. He felt more aligned with America and the Commenwealth countries than our European partners.   Felt they should be our long term close trading partners.

He admitted it was unlikely there would be ANY financial gain but hoped for parity in the medium to long term.   He hasn't changed his view but thinks May is utterly clueless and is exasperated at how his party has managed this exit.  

A little insight into one leavers mindset.

Morning Lil, a couple of interesting points raised there (ironically from a remainer as well). For the democracy I would be interested in what influence on our governance he is worried about and how it has impacted on us in reality. Could he give an example of how we have been made worse off by that influence. We do also have the European elections that we don't bother with really but don't let that get in the way of the discussion.

The second one is a bit pie in the sky, it's a bit like me dumping the wife because I fancy the fit bird in at work, after all we have a lot in common, we work together and she has better tits. I haven't asked her directly if we could get together but she's asked me if I wanted a cup of tea (admittedly she asked everyone else at the same time) but that indicates that there is a real possibility of a great future together.

(02-27-2019, 09:40 AM)Pneumann Wrote: One good reason for not having a second referendum is because the world is exactly the same as it was when the leave vote was recorded. The clocks stopped, simply. The second good reason is related to the "never ask an idiot" adage.

More seriously, there is a dead easy way of holding a referendum: go through with the Euro election in the summer, but insist that the candidates are very clearly for or against leave. That would in reality give a second referendum without all the bollocks.

That is not a bad idea Pneumann.
Reply
#32
(02-27-2019, 09:23 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 08:35 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: I sense you are keen on questions, so please allow me a few, what happens to the 17.4 million when they are told their votes are null and void. When the losers referendum is held, what is the criteria, will it be the best of three, best of five. Will we be told " it's only this time your vote won't count, it will every other, honest ". Now that politicians are ignoring a vote and proceeding how they want, isn't that a dictatorship. What are the masses next steps, now they know democracy is denied them, the last time anyone were denied votes in the UK was Northern Ireland, that went well.

No problems Cornish.

The votes aren't null and void, in the same way that any election / referendum votes aren't. The vote to stay in the EEC in 1975 aren't void because we have voted to leave now, circumstances have changed. The votes to elect Theresa May's government won't be null and void at the next election, we have simply seen it was the wrong thing to vote for with the benefit of hindsight.

And let's not get hung up on the 17.4 million, I would say that there are a fair few of those that with hindsight can see it isn't a very good idea in practice rather than the theory. Also there were 16.1 million voters that voted to remain and have watched the car crash of the last couple of years unfolding predictably in amazement.

The argument that we've voted and it must be upheld for democracy doesn't hold water based on a simple fact - people change their mind, and when they can see no benefit to following something through logic would dictate that they stop and turn around.

This really is as simple as that, people voted for leave, it turns out it's a really shit idea and has no benefits, so let's rethink the situation and ask again now that we know more. That is democracy in action - not a denial of democracy.

Now - seeing as I have answered your questions. Can I ask again for you to give me one benefit to the country, the economy, our job prospects, our children's futures, or absolutely anything by leaving.

I'm afraid you haven't, you have just repeated the oft used mantra " you didn't know what you were doing " so we go again, but you know we get it, before the vote anyone voicing concerns on immigration, were racist, anyone with concerns on the EU were little englanders, you don't think any of this comes as a surprise to anyone that voted leave, we are used to being shut up, so we are just now waiting for the ultimate putdown to shut us up. If and when it happens, politicians will never be trusted again, I am confident that remain will win the losers referendum because I know of so many people that voted leave, will never put cross to paper again including me.
Reply
#33
(02-27-2019, 10:51 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 09:23 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 08:35 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: I sense you are keen on questions, so please allow me a few, what happens to the 17.4 million when they are told their votes are null and void. When the losers referendum is held, what is the criteria, will it be the best of three, best of five. Will we be told " it's only this time your vote won't count, it will every other, honest ". Now that politicians are ignoring a vote and proceeding how they want, isn't that a dictatorship. What are the masses next steps, now they know democracy is denied them, the last time anyone were denied votes in the UK was Northern Ireland, that went well.

No problems Cornish.

The votes aren't null and void, in the same way that any election / referendum votes aren't. The vote to stay in the EEC in 1975 aren't void because we have voted to leave now, circumstances have changed. The votes to elect Theresa May's government won't be null and void at the next election, we have simply seen it was the wrong thing to vote for with the benefit of hindsight.

And let's not get hung up on the 17.4 million, I would say that there are a fair few of those that with hindsight can see it isn't a very good idea in practice rather than the theory. Also there were 16.1 million voters that voted to remain and have watched the car crash of the last couple of years unfolding predictably in amazement.

The argument that we've voted and it must be upheld for democracy doesn't hold water based on a simple fact - people change their mind, and when they can see no benefit to following something through logic would dictate that they stop and turn around.

This really is as simple as that, people voted for leave, it turns out it's a really shit idea and has no benefits, so let's rethink the situation and ask again now that we know more. That is democracy in action - not a denial of democracy.

Now - seeing as I have answered your questions. Can I ask again for you to give me one benefit to the country, the economy, our job prospects, our children's futures, or absolutely anything by leaving.

I'm afraid you haven't, you have just repeated the oft used mantra " you didn't know what you were doing " so we go again, but you know we get it, before the vote anyone voicing concerns on immigration, were racist, anyone with concerns on the EU were little englanders, you don't think any of this comes as a surprise to anyone that voted leave, we are used to being shut up, so we are just now waiting for the ultimate putdown to shut us up. If and when it happens, politicians will never be trusted again, I am confident that remain will win the losers referendum because I know of so many people that voted leave, will never put cross to paper again including me.

What negative effect did immigration have on Cornwall?
Reply
#34
(02-27-2019, 10:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 10:51 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 09:23 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 08:35 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: I sense you are keen on questions, so please allow me a few, what happens to the 17.4 million when they are told their votes are null and void. When the losers referendum is held, what is the criteria, will it be the best of three, best of five. Will we be told " it's only this time your vote won't count, it will every other, honest ". Now that politicians are ignoring a vote and proceeding how they want, isn't that a dictatorship. What are the masses next steps, now they know democracy is denied them, the last time anyone were denied votes in the UK was Northern Ireland, that went well.

No problems Cornish.

The votes aren't null and void, in the same way that any election / referendum votes aren't. The vote to stay in the EEC in 1975 aren't void because we have voted to leave now, circumstances have changed. The votes to elect Theresa May's government won't be null and void at the next election, we have simply seen it was the wrong thing to vote for with the benefit of hindsight.

And let's not get hung up on the 17.4 million, I would say that there are a fair few of those that with hindsight can see it isn't a very good idea in practice rather than the theory. Also there were 16.1 million voters that voted to remain and have watched the car crash of the last couple of years unfolding predictably in amazement.

The argument that we've voted and it must be upheld for democracy doesn't hold water based on a simple fact - people change their mind, and when they can see no benefit to following something through logic would dictate that they stop and turn around.

This really is as simple as that, people voted for leave, it turns out it's a really shit idea and has no benefits, so let's rethink the situation and ask again now that we know more. That is democracy in action - not a denial of democracy.

Now - seeing as I have answered your questions. Can I ask again for you to give me one benefit to the country, the economy, our job prospects, our children's futures, or absolutely anything by leaving.

I'm afraid you haven't, you have just repeated the oft used mantra " you didn't know what you were doing " so we go again, but you know we get it, before the vote anyone voicing concerns on immigration, were racist, anyone with concerns on the EU were little englanders, you don't think any of this comes as a surprise to anyone that voted leave, we are used to being shut up, so we are just now waiting for the ultimate putdown to shut us up. If and when it happens, politicians will never be trusted again, I am confident that remain will win the losers referendum because I know of so many people that voted leave, will never put cross to paper again including me.

What negative effect did immigration have on Cornwall?

Yet another one thrown in to the mix, again I hadn't realised the referendum was regionalised, it appears I am learning so much more after the vote.
Reply
#35
(02-27-2019, 10:51 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 09:23 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 08:35 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: I sense you are keen on questions, so please allow me a few, what happens to the 17.4 million when they are told their votes are null and void. When the losers referendum is held, what is the criteria, will it be the best of three, best of five. Will we be told " it's only this time your vote won't count, it will every other, honest ". Now that politicians are ignoring a vote and proceeding how they want, isn't that a dictatorship. What are the masses next steps, now they know democracy is denied them, the last time anyone were denied votes in the UK was Northern Ireland, that went well.

No problems Cornish.

The votes aren't null and void, in the same way that any election / referendum votes aren't. The vote to stay in the EEC in 1975 aren't void because we have voted to leave now, circumstances have changed. The votes to elect Theresa May's government won't be null and void at the next election, we have simply seen it was the wrong thing to vote for with the benefit of hindsight.

And let's not get hung up on the 17.4 million, I would say that there are a fair few of those that with hindsight can see it isn't a very good idea in practice rather than the theory. Also there were 16.1 million voters that voted to remain and have watched the car crash of the last couple of years unfolding predictably in amazement.

The argument that we've voted and it must be upheld for democracy doesn't hold water based on a simple fact - people change their mind, and when they can see no benefit to following something through logic would dictate that they stop and turn around.

This really is as simple as that, people voted for leave, it turns out it's a really shit idea and has no benefits, so let's rethink the situation and ask again now that we know more. That is democracy in action - not a denial of democracy.

Now - seeing as I have answered your questions. Can I ask again for you to give me one benefit to the country, the economy, our job prospects, our children's futures, or absolutely anything by leaving.

I'm afraid you haven't, you have just repeated the oft used mantra " you didn't know what you were doing " so we go again, but you know we get it, before the vote anyone voicing concerns on immigration, were racist, anyone with concerns on the EU were little englanders, you don't think any of this comes as a surprise to anyone that voted leave, we are used to being shut up, so we are just now waiting for the ultimate putdown to shut us up. If and when it happens, politicians will never be trusted again, I am confident that remain will win the losers referendum because I know of so many people that voted leave, will never put cross to paper again including me.

But that simply isn't what I have said. There is a big difference between saying 'we know more now' and 'you didn't know what you were doing' - let's keep this simple, do you agree with that statement? Because we are straying away from my original intention which was to find out the benefits to leaving which we can come back to.

There are some valid points about immigration but as Dekka says, how did that impact on the UK negatively? And then importantly is that EU immigration or world immigration? And no, you are not racist for raising concerns.

I'm still asking what benefits will it bring by leaving the EU, let's put aside the vote as it might not happen. When we leave on the 29th March (in theory) how will we benefit going forward?
Reply
#36
(02-27-2019, 10:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 10:51 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 09:23 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 08:35 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: I sense you are keen on questions, so please allow me a few, what happens to the 17.4 million when they are told their votes are null and void. When the losers referendum is held, what is the criteria, will it be the best of three, best of five. Will we be told " it's only this time your vote won't count, it will every other, honest ". Now that politicians are ignoring a vote and proceeding how they want, isn't that a dictatorship. What are the masses next steps, now they know democracy is denied them, the last time anyone were denied votes in the UK was Northern Ireland, that went well.

No problems Cornish.

The votes aren't null and void, in the same way that any election / referendum votes aren't. The vote to stay in the EEC in 1975 aren't void because we have voted to leave now, circumstances have changed. The votes to elect Theresa May's government won't be null and void at the next election, we have simply seen it was the wrong thing to vote for with the benefit of hindsight.

And let's not get hung up on the 17.4 million, I would say that there are a fair few of those that with hindsight can see it isn't a very good idea in practice rather than the theory. Also there were 16.1 million voters that voted to remain and have watched the car crash of the last couple of years unfolding predictably in amazement.

The argument that we've voted and it must be upheld for democracy doesn't hold water based on a simple fact - people change their mind, and when they can see no benefit to following something through logic would dictate that they stop and turn around.

This really is as simple as that, people voted for leave, it turns out it's a really shit idea and has no benefits, so let's rethink the situation and ask again now that we know more. That is democracy in action - not a denial of democracy.

Now - seeing as I have answered your questions. Can I ask again for you to give me one benefit to the country, the economy, our job prospects, our children's futures, or absolutely anything by leaving.

I'm afraid you haven't, you have just repeated the oft used mantra " you didn't know what you were doing " so we go again, but you know we get it, before the vote anyone voicing concerns on immigration, were racist, anyone with concerns on the EU were little englanders, you don't think any of this comes as a surprise to anyone that voted leave, we are used to being shut up, so we are just now waiting for the ultimate putdown to shut us up. If and when it happens, politicians will never be trusted again, I am confident that remain will win the losers referendum because I know of so many people that voted leave, will never put cross to paper again including me.

What negative effect did immigration have on Cornwall?

Not sure about Cornwall in particular, but I think you will find that many areas that relied on seasonal work have
seen huge challenges in opportunity following the arrival of so many Eastern European folks seeking work. That
is good and bad I suppose. Good if you run a business and want to keep costs down whilst increasing unsocial
hours, bad if your a local dependant on such work to avoid being trapped on Welfare.

It is not the fault of the East Europeans, they just want to better themselves but to believe that comes without
consequences for pay and conditions is delusional.
Reply
#37
(02-27-2019, 12:04 PM)Beano Wrote: Not sure about Cornwall in particular, but I think you will find that many areas that relied on seasonal work have
seen huge challenges in opportunity following the arrival of so many Eastern European folks seeking work. That
is good and bad I suppose. Good if you run a business and want to keep costs down whilst increasing unsocial
hours, bad if your a local dependant on such work to avoid being trapped on Welfare.

It is not the fault of the East Europeans, they just want to better themselves but to believe that comes without
consequences for pay and conditions is delusional.

Thanks Beano - a valid point and a benefit to the UK by coming out of the EU. Areas that rely on seasonal workers will employ more of the local workforce during that season and reduce the welfare costs therefore allowing the government to spend more on something else e.g. the NHS.

This will also have a knock on effect of raising wages for the local workforce as well due to less competition. As you say this will mean the costs of that produce will increase but that is understood and a price worth paying (forgive the pun).

See that was easy - any more benefits?
Reply
#38
(02-27-2019, 12:04 PM)Beano Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 10:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 10:51 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 09:23 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 08:35 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: I sense you are keen on questions, so please allow me a few, what happens to the 17.4 million when they are told their votes are null and void. When the losers referendum is held, what is the criteria, will it be the best of three, best of five. Will we be told " it's only this time your vote won't count, it will every other, honest ". Now that politicians are ignoring a vote and proceeding how they want, isn't that a dictatorship. What are the masses next steps, now they know democracy is denied them, the last time anyone were denied votes in the UK was Northern Ireland, that went well.

No problems Cornish.

The votes aren't null and void, in the same way that any election / referendum votes aren't. The vote to stay in the EEC in 1975 aren't void because we have voted to leave now, circumstances have changed. The votes to elect Theresa May's government won't be null and void at the next election, we have simply seen it was the wrong thing to vote for with the benefit of hindsight.

And let's not get hung up on the 17.4 million, I would say that there are a fair few of those that with hindsight can see it isn't a very good idea in practice rather than the theory. Also there were 16.1 million voters that voted to remain and have watched the car crash of the last couple of years unfolding predictably in amazement.

The argument that we've voted and it must be upheld for democracy doesn't hold water based on a simple fact - people change their mind, and when they can see no benefit to following something through logic would dictate that they stop and turn around.

This really is as simple as that, people voted for leave, it turns out it's a really shit idea and has no benefits, so let's rethink the situation and ask again now that we know more. That is democracy in action - not a denial of democracy.

Now - seeing as I have answered your questions. Can I ask again for you to give me one benefit to the country, the economy, our job prospects, our children's futures, or absolutely anything by leaving.

I'm afraid you haven't, you have just repeated the oft used mantra " you didn't know what you were doing " so we go again, but you know we get it, before the vote anyone voicing concerns on immigration, were racist, anyone with concerns on the EU were little englanders, you don't think any of this comes as a surprise to anyone that voted leave, we are used to being shut up, so we are just now waiting for the ultimate putdown to shut us up. If and when it happens, politicians will never be trusted again, I am confident that remain will win the losers referendum because I know of so many people that voted leave, will never put cross to paper again including me.

What negative effect did immigration have on Cornwall?

Not sure about Cornwall in particular, but I think you will find that many areas that relied on seasonal work have
seen huge challenges in opportunity following the arrival of so many Eastern European folks seeking work. That
is good and bad I suppose. Good if you run a business and want to keep costs down whilst increasing unsocial
hours, bad if your a local dependant on such work to avoid being trapped on Welfare.

It is not the fault of the East Europeans, they just want to better themselves but to believe that comes without
consequences for pay and conditions is delusional.

I asked the question I didn’t give an answer. 

However my observation is most of the jobs that the Eastern European’s do / did are ones UK people won’t do and no amount of carrot or stick from the government would ensure they would. Also why would any company want a employeee who is been forced to work anyway? 

I await the fruit pickers and cleaners from the local sink estate starting work as soon as Brexit actually happens.
Reply
#39
(02-27-2019, 12:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:04 PM)Beano Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 10:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 10:51 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 09:23 AM)baggy1 Wrote: No problems Cornish.

The votes aren't null and void, in the same way that any election / referendum votes aren't. The vote to stay in the EEC in 1975 aren't void because we have voted to leave now, circumstances have changed. The votes to elect Theresa May's government won't be null and void at the next election, we have simply seen it was the wrong thing to vote for with the benefit of hindsight.

And let's not get hung up on the 17.4 million, I would say that there are a fair few of those that with hindsight can see it isn't a very good idea in practice rather than the theory. Also there were 16.1 million voters that voted to remain and have watched the car crash of the last couple of years unfolding predictably in amazement.

The argument that we've voted and it must be upheld for democracy doesn't hold water based on a simple fact - people change their mind, and when they can see no benefit to following something through logic would dictate that they stop and turn around.

This really is as simple as that, people voted for leave, it turns out it's a really shit idea and has no benefits, so let's rethink the situation and ask again now that we know more. That is democracy in action - not a denial of democracy.

Now - seeing as I have answered your questions. Can I ask again for you to give me one benefit to the country, the economy, our job prospects, our children's futures, or absolutely anything by leaving.

I'm afraid you haven't, you have just repeated the oft used mantra " you didn't know what you were doing " so we go again, but you know we get it, before the vote anyone voicing concerns on immigration, were racist, anyone with concerns on the EU were little englanders, you don't think any of this comes as a surprise to anyone that voted leave, we are used to being shut up, so we are just now waiting for the ultimate putdown to shut us up. If and when it happens, politicians will never be trusted again, I am confident that remain will win the losers referendum because I know of so many people that voted leave, will never put cross to paper again including me.

What negative effect did immigration have on Cornwall?

Not sure about Cornwall in particular, but I think you will find that many areas that relied on seasonal work have
seen huge challenges in opportunity following the arrival of so many Eastern European folks seeking work. That
is good and bad I suppose. Good if you run a business and want to keep costs down whilst increasing unsocial
hours, bad if your a local dependant on such work to avoid being trapped on Welfare.

It is not the fault of the East Europeans, they just want to better themselves but to believe that comes without
consequences for pay and conditions is delusional.

I asked the question I didn’t give an answer. 

However my observation is most of the jobs that the Eastern European’s do / did are ones UK people won’t do and no amount of carrot or stick from the government would ensure they would. Also why would any company want a employeee who is been forced to work anyway? 

I await the fruit pickers and cleaners from the local sink estate starting work as soon as Brexit actually happens.

There is alsala situation where we have a skill shortage in engineering. The EU migrants do tend to fill these positions too. So there are benefits as well as what could be described as disadvantages.
Reply
#40
(02-27-2019, 12:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:04 PM)Beano Wrote: Not sure about Cornwall in particular, but I think you will find that many areas that relied on seasonal work have
seen huge challenges in opportunity following the arrival of so many Eastern European folks seeking work. That
is good and bad I suppose. Good if you run a business and want to keep costs down whilst increasing unsocial
hours, bad if your a local dependant on such work to avoid being trapped on Welfare.

It is not the fault of the East Europeans, they just want to better themselves but to believe that comes without
consequences for pay and conditions is delusional.

Thanks Beano - a valid point and a benefit to the UK by coming out of the EU. Areas that rely on seasonal workers will employ more of the local workforce during that season and reduce the welfare costs therefore allowing the government to spend more on something else e.g. the NHS.

This will also have a knock on effect of raising wages for the local workforce as well due to less competition. As you say this will mean the costs of that produce will increase but that is understood and a price worth paying (forgive the pun).

See that was easy - any more benefits?

So benefit number one is that seasonal businesses will need to pay more money to less motivated workers, thus increasing the cost of the product and potentially reducing the quality.   I'd be all for that if I saw huge queues of local workers held back at the gates and if I expected all our leave voting friends to happily swallow the hyper inflated prices that will follow. "I don't mind paying £5 for a bag of spuds, they were picked by local workers".

But then, a decent wage for a decent job helping the local economy grow, spreading profits and reduce benefits.  Who could argue with that.

Fugg,  I wish I lived in the polarized world many seem to now inhabit instead of having to look at both sides of the argument in a reasoned way.....it's bloody hard work!

Ps. What happens to the local workforce out of season?
Pps. If your benefits were impacted for the rest of the year because you have declared a few months seasonal work....would you do it?

Never simple is it.........
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)