The ideal manager
#31
There's a bit of big dave-tinted glasses going on here I think. He was almost as culpable as Val of doing the same thing over and over and it not working over and over. Then promising to "pick the bones out of it" after every match. The barnes/gayle combo put a sheen on his time here and I think it was right for him to go. Obviously all this is caveated with the fact he will forever be a club legend and all-round fantastic human being.

When it comes to an ideal manager, I really don't think its that complicated and I don't understand why a lot of them make it so difficult for themselves (he says having never managed so much as an All-Priests 5-a-side over-75s Indoor Challenge!) Big Grin

1. keep players fit and ensure they work 'aaaaaard
2. round pegs in round holes - players playing in their best position and knowing what their role is in that position.
3. set up with attacking intent when playing the bottom side at home and more defensively playing the top side away

That's about it really. I don't really care about formations or 'style' - we played great football under 'defensive' Roy and 'attacking' Mowbray. We seem to attract managers who insist on just doing the same thing every match, like we've got Liverpool/City standard players when we don't. Slav would've been great if he'd met criteria 1. I'd even have stomached Pulis if he'd got anywhere near criteria 3 (5 centre halves on the pitch at home...shudder).

3 centre halves away at Fulham, 2 centre halves at home to Barnsley. I don't think its asking the world.

Obviously I'm in agreement with the majority on here that Roy fit this mould the best by far out of any manager in recent memory.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)