Jake
#31
(01-19-2022, 10:40 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 10:26 AM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Yes you're right. Jake has missed all the chances created and been at fault for all the dozens of goals we've conceded

No, but it’s not like he’s creating chances or preventing goals either.

This isn’t scapegoating, I think most know I rarely go in for that, I just cannot see what Livermore offers to this side anymore. He’s completely invisible in the centre of the park.

Lol that made me laugh - like he's lost 5 stone!? 

Maybe that means he's doing his 'job' which is to close down, break up play, shield the back three and give the ball simply to others.  If he's invisible it probably means not a lot is happening/being created in his area because he's doing his job - bit like when the ref is invisible. 

Every team probably needs a similar player in the middle of the park.  Where we are lacking at the moment is creativity mainly from the flanks and creating chances.  He can't do everything. 

Having said all that, I'd replace him with Yokuslu in a heart-beat.
Reply
#32
I have no real issues about this. It's just a contract extension being triggered, it has no real bearing on whether or not he should play; and it guarantees a small fee if he's moved along in the summer. Nothing story really.
Reply
#33
(01-19-2022, 01:02 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 10:40 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 10:26 AM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Yes you're right. Jake has missed all the chances created and been at fault for all the dozens of goals we've conceded

No, but it’s not like he’s creating chances or preventing goals either.

This isn’t scapegoating, I think most know I rarely go in for that, I just cannot see what Livermore offers to this side anymore. He’s completely invisible in the centre of the park.

Lol that made me laugh - like he's lost 5 stone!? 

Maybe that means he's doing his 'job' which is to close down, break up play, shield the back three and give the ball simply to others.  If he's invisible it probably means not a lot is happening/being created in his area because he's doing his job - bit like when the ref is invisible. 

Every team probably needs a similar player in the middle of the park.  Where we are lacking at the moment is creativity mainly from the flanks and creating chances.  He can't do everything. 

Having said all that, I'd replace him with Yokuslu in a heart-beat.

When Mowatt got sent off the other week, nothing really changed with our team. So really the middle two aren't doing an awful lot otherwise you'd have expected to notice one of them wasn't there.
Reply
#34
(01-19-2022, 12:37 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Year extension for Livermore or not, if he’s still our starting midfielder at the start of next season there’s something seriously wrong with our club. Happy to keep him around but he cannot be starting every week anymore. Just not good enough.

We've been saying that for the last 2 or 3 seasons, and yet he's still picked week in week out.

If Val's still manager, I do think Jake can do a job as one of the three centre halves, and will be a good squad player.

I have much less of an issue with this years extension, than if we opt to make Molumby's stay a permanent one.
Reply
#35
(01-19-2022, 01:02 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 10:40 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 10:26 AM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Yes you're right. Jake has missed all the chances created and been at fault for all the dozens of goals we've conceded

No, but it’s not like he’s creating chances or preventing goals either.

This isn’t scapegoating, I think most know I rarely go in for that, I just cannot see what Livermore offers to this side anymore. He’s completely invisible in the centre of the park.

Lol that made me laugh - like he's lost 5 stone!? 

Maybe that means he's doing his 'job' which is to close down, break up play, shield the back three and give the ball simply to others.  If he's invisible it probably means not a lot is happening/being created in his area because he's doing his job - bit like when the ref is invisible. 

Every team probably needs a similar player in the middle of the park.  Where we are lacking at the moment is creativity mainly from the flanks and creating chances.  He can't do everything. 

Having said all that, I'd replace him with Yokuslu in a heart-beat.

He doesn’t do anything.
Reply
#36
He is Mr 6.5/10. Never really lets us down, never really wins you a game.

He's good for a squad place, and the people getting vexxed over him being kept need to give their heads a little bit of a wobble. Yes he shouldn't be our main man next year, but that will based on recruitment.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#37
I said last season , if Livermore is still oafing around this season weve got problems. He offers nothing now and hasnt for a while. The only time I notice him is when hes half hour late for a tackle.
Daint take Big Sam long to see thru it.
As for him getting England caps a while back..well..shows the state England were in.
Altho we dont seem to do the so called Val high press now..I could never get my head around a team that was high press and had Livermore in it.
So...new deal triggered for Jake. Fits in with how its going generally right now.
Reply
#38
(01-19-2022, 01:02 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 10:40 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 10:26 AM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Yes you're right. Jake has missed all the chances created and been at fault for all the dozens of goals we've conceded

No, but it’s not like he’s creating chances or preventing goals either.

This isn’t scapegoating, I think most know I rarely go in for that, I just cannot see what Livermore offers to this side anymore. He’s completely invisible in the centre of the park.

Lol that made me laugh - like he's lost 5 stone!? 

Maybe that means he's doing his 'job' which is to close down, break up play, shield the back three and give the ball simply to others.  If he's invisible it probably means not a lot is happening/being created in his area because he's doing his job - bit like when the ref is invisible. 

Every team probably needs a similar player in the middle of the park.  Where we are lacking at the moment is creativity mainly from the flanks and creating chances.  He can't do everything. 

Having said all that, I'd replace him with Yokuslu in a heart-beat.
If there were a list of things that Livermore wasn't very good at, that would be it.
Maybe closing down he's ok at, but, once he gets there his timing is abysmal. He breaks up our play more than that of the opposition with his inability to turn or move. He doesn't need to shield the back 3 when we are having so much possession, but, if he does it often ends with a clumsy tackle and a free kick in our first third. As for giving the ball simply to others, he rarely plays a pass below waist height. Add to this the fact that he never wins a header and I'm at a loss to what he offers other than giving "110%", whatever that means.
Reply
#39
(01-19-2022, 10:46 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Duffers Wrote:
Jacobthebaggie Wrote:Yes you're right. Jake has missed all the chances created and been at fault for all the dozens of goals we've conceded

No, but it’s not like he’s creating chances or preventing goals either.

This isn’t scapegoating, I think most know I rarely go in for that, I just cannot see what Livermore offers to this side anymore. He’s completely invisible in the centre of the park.

He's played quite well in the last few matches he's played in. Cardiff in particular.He does that scrappy job in the middle, breaking up play etc that never gets any credit. While I get much of the criticism for not creating anything, I think he mostly suffers from there not being an extra body just ahead of him. I also think he would be better suited to playing in the back 3 in this system as we don't appear to need 3 out and out centre backs.
While I get much of the criticism for not creating anything

You're too hard on yourself. Noone's blaming you...
Reply
#40
(01-19-2022, 03:51 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 01:02 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 10:40 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-19-2022, 10:26 AM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Yes you're right. Jake has missed all the chances created and been at fault for all the dozens of goals we've conceded

No, but it’s not like he’s creating chances or preventing goals either.

This isn’t scapegoating, I think most know I rarely go in for that, I just cannot see what Livermore offers to this side anymore. He’s completely invisible in the centre of the park.

Lol that made me laugh - like he's lost 5 stone!? 

Maybe that means he's doing his 'job' which is to close down, break up play, shield the back three and give the ball simply to others.  If he's invisible it probably means not a lot is happening/being created in his area because he's doing his job - bit like when the ref is invisible. 

Every team probably needs a similar player in the middle of the park.  Where we are lacking at the moment is creativity mainly from the flanks and creating chances.  He can't do everything. 

Having said all that, I'd replace him with Yokuslu in a heart-beat.
If there were a list of things that Livermore wasn't very good at, that would be it.
Maybe closing down he's ok at, but, once he gets there his timing is abysmal. He breaks up our play more than that of the opposition with his inability to turn or move. He doesn't need to shield the back 3 when we are having so much possession, but, if he does it often ends with a clumsy tackle and a free kick in our first third. As for giving the ball simply to others, he rarely plays a pass below waist height. Add to this the fact that he never wins a header and I'm at a loss to what he offers other than giving "110%", whatever that means.

Spot on.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: