Squad 22/23, the evolution.
#31
(01-11-2022, 04:56 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'm puzzled at how many don't rate Clarke. He is way better than anything else we have (not including O,Shea as he is out).

I think my doubts about him are partly a reaction to the hyperbole when he first arrived. He was unfit and injury prone but some declared him far and away our best defender at the time. Whoever said he was "slower than Bartley" wasn't really exaggerating. We've rarely seen him play anywhere except left side of the three, never seen him in a pair. He is just as likely as Barts or Ajayi to get caught out of position, and has been at the scene of the odd defensive catastrophe. No way would he survive in the Premier League. So if Clarke isn't our player (and if O'Shea returns to his best), I'm not rushing to make his move permanent.

I'm puzzled at how many don't rate Kipre. He's been improving steadily.
Reply
#32
Put very simply we need more goals in this squad.

When we sign players we need to be aware of their goal scoring record.

We have some good players at this level, but there aren't too many of them who know how to out the ball in the back of the net.

This weekend, presuming we play 343, it is unlikely that anyone who plays in the midfield 4 will have scored a league goal this season. Given we are over half way through the season, that's not good enough for a side seeking promotion.
Reply
#33
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:I'm puzzled at how many don't rate Clarke. He is way better than anything else we have (not including O,Shea as he is out).

I think my doubts about him are partly a reaction to the hyperbole when he first arrived. He was unfit and injury prone but some declared him far and away our best defender at the time. Whoever said he was "slower than Bartley" wasn't really exaggerating. We've rarely seen him play anywhere except left side of the three, never seen him in a pair. He is just as likely as Barts or Ajayi to get caught out of position, and has been at the scene of the odd defensive catastrophe. No way would he survive in the Premier League. So if Clarke isn't our player (and if O'Shea returns to his best), I'm not rushing to make his move permanent.

I'm puzzled at how many don't rate Kipre. He's been improving steadily.

Oh I do. But the same applies, we've not seen him in a 2 either. Anyway, it isn't an area we need to worry about yet although I'd suggest O'Shea replace Bartley for me.
Reply
#34
I've hardly been blowed away by Clarke personally. He's been decent but nothing more. He's a fully committed centre half, but not a patch on Jonas for example, who was similar in commitment terms.

There's a reason why Brighton keep loaning him out. He'll definitely do a job for us this season, but like Molumby, I wouldn't be pushing for a permanent transfer.
Reply
#35
(01-11-2022, 04:56 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'm puzzled at how many don't rate Clarke. He is way better than anything else we have (not including O,Shea as he is out).

For me it’s not that I don’t rate him, I just don’t think he will be worth the money BHA will want for him come the summer, and it’s not a priority position we need to strengthen as we have Townsend and Bryan who can play there.

Should we get promoted we are likely to need better.

Next summer we need to spend what little money we can afford on our midfield as there’s no fucking way we can get another year out of Livermore.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: