Frustration is the word.........
#31
(01-04-2022, 01:06 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The reality is you have 3 years to get back up with any kind of advantage. As is Parachute payments.

We need to,  in those 3 years strive really hard to get back up, but change the mentality from, old proven players, to up and coming/homegrown. If we fail, so be it. But we must not risk getting to the end of that 3 year period and be at square one of a process we need to undertake anyway.

It's important to remember we haven't got three years of payments. We're spreading two years of payments over three seasons having gone straight back down.
Reply
#32
(01-04-2022, 11:57 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: This is one of the reasons I’m walking away from the site. There’s no balance or perspective. Everything is viewed through a singular bias lens and twisted to suit a particular narrative.

The moment you post something balanced, evidence based or thought provoking it simply gets ignored in favour of something on the edge, extreme or emotional. I’ve been a members since Rivals.net, under LeicBaggie etc, and it’s just not worth posting anymore.

I’m all for debate, it’s healthy and you can get a more informed perspective. Now it’s not like this, it’s who can piss the highest, who can be more absurd or who can use anything to bash the club or manager.

I don’t believe anyone is happy with the style or the results right now. But the manager deserves more than a single transfer window and in Dike it’s an excellent signing. People keep saying this squad should be doing better, really? A large part of this team was bombed out by Sam, the season prior they fell apart (yes the manager had a part) and we scrapped promotion and the core of the squad had been poor in the prem for years. This isn’t just about perceived talent; it’s about work ethic, desire and ability to be adaptable and the core of this squad has underachieved under 4 or 5 managers.

Surely it comes to a point where even the most basic consider it may not be all the manager…

Given the responses to the OP I'd argue that there is a lack of balance to the views, but the majority alignwith your perspective.

FODTHV  Smile
Reply
#33
(01-04-2022, 01:06 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The reality is you have 3 years to get back up with any kind of advantage. As is Parachute payments.

We need to,  in those 3 years strive really hard to get back up, but change the mentality from, old proven players, to up and coming/homegrown. If we fail, so be it. But we must not risk getting to the end of that 3 year period and be at square one of a process we need to undertake anyway.
This is why we will see a different Brentford once they drop again.
They have been, rightly, lorded for their philosophy, but, they did it on a very low wage budget and it took years. When they drop next time, which they will, they will have a much higher wage bill and will be held to ransom by the parachute payments just as much as we are. This will likely mean the end of them taking punts on lower league prospects and plugging for more "experienced" pros. It's all well and good saying we should follow their model but we simply can't as we don't have the time.
It's a vicious circle caused by the inequality of finance in the greed league.

Promotion is under-estimated in my opinion and for a club of our size to do it 5 times and never finish outside of the top 4, and all without ever having a rich sugar daddy, is one of the achievements of the century. We are the embodiment of successful self-sustainment.

That's why it's so important for us to remain in the top 6 this year and the reason a lot of fans, myself included, are getting twitchy with this slide.
If Dike is the missing link, then the club as a whole should be lauded, not just Val.
Reply
#34
(01-04-2022, 01:10 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(01-04-2022, 12:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-04-2022, 11:57 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: This is one of the reasons I’m walking away from the site. There’s no balance or perspective. Everything is viewed through a singular bias lens and twisted to suit a particular narrative.

The moment you post something balanced, evidence based or thought provoking it simply gets ignored in favour of something on the edge, extreme or emotional. I’ve been a members since Rivals.net, under LeicBaggie etc, and it’s just not worth posting anymore.

I’m all for debate, it’s healthy and you can get a more informed perspective. Now it’s not like this, it’s who can piss the highest, who can be more absurd or who can use anything to bash the club or manager.

I don’t believe anyone is happy with the style or the results right now. But the manager deserves more than a single transfer window and in Dike it’s an excellent signing. People keep saying this squad should be doing better, really? A large part of this team was bombed out by Sam, the season prior they fell apart (yes the manager had a part) and we scrapped promotion and the core of the squad had been poor in the prem for years. This isn’t just about perceived talent; it’s about work ethic, desire and ability to be adaptable and the core of this squad has underachieved under 4 or 5 managers.

Surely it comes to a point where even the most basic consider it may not be all the manager…

The problem with the argument that we need 2,3,4 transfer windows is our dwindling resources to do so. Where is the money coming from to improve the squad from where we are now if we fail to get promotion? We have an owner who wants to sell so long term plans are not likely to happen unless there is a change of outlook from the owners. 

The other point about the current squad I will make is who are the clubs that have better squads than we have? Fulham, yes, Bournemouth, maybe? Then it gets very difficult to make that case. The argument we scraped promotion is true BUT if we only scraped automatic promotion wtf were the other teams in the division doing with their squads that season? Have many of those squads improved their squads? 

Since Covid I haven’t seen any clubs really invest in their squads to any great degree in the Championship. It’s a weak league. We have a very good squad for this season’s Championship, we need promotion asap to keep moving forward as a club. 

The club has no long term plan or at least hasn’t articulated one. Given we have examples of clubs languishing in the league that have been where we are such as Blues, Forest, Derby, Ipswich, Sunderland, Sheff Weds as pointers towards where our future might lie, I’m not surprised we want instant success, it beats long term failure.

We scraped promotion is a core group of players plus some standout performers who are no longer with us like Pereira, like a pre-injury Diang. Pereira carried that team and made a significant difference against other squads in the league back then. If you take Peirera out of that team where do you realistically think we’d have finished?

I don’t think we need 3/4 windows I think the two this season of used well would be enough to judge Val on come season end. 

I struggle in my own head to balance the ‘who has got a better squad argument’ but you only have to look at Man Utd to understand it’s not about perceived talent or what they have done in the past. The core squad are past their peak, but more so we simply don’t have stand out key players in the squad. We have solid players with prem experience. Look at what Diaz is doing at Blackburn. 

Dike is a start, hopefully, getting in a quality CM will make a massive difference. But I believe our squad while strong in depth lacks key quality players.

(01-04-2022, 01:06 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The reality is you have 3 years to get back up with any kind of advantage. As is Parachute payments.

We need to,  in those 3 years strive really hard to get back up, but change the mentality from, old proven players, to up and coming/homegrown. If we fail, so be it. But we must not risk getting to the end of that 3 year period and be at square one of a process we need to undertake anyway.

I think as we only had a year in the champ we only get two years parachute money? Is that right?

I think you mean Prem, but yes that is my understanding.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: