12-30-2021, 04:05 PM
Cuzer Wrote:Pragmatist Wrote:TBF, re the sweeper-keeper role. Sam is decent with the ball at his feet. A new keeper might be an absolute nightmare at the quick changeovers we attempt. Foster was the best Albion keeper in my lifetime by a million miles, but he struggled to land a goal kick on the playing area. While not perfect (who is?) Sam normally finds a stripey shirt with his passes.Lillwall's left foot Wrote:Swagbaggie Wrote:Peachy Wrote:Thats the issue isn't it. How much will we get for Sam and will that money make enough difference at the other end of the pitch to negate the effects of losing a very good keeper.
If someone gave us £3m now instead of nothing this summer I'm sure we'll take it. FWIW If it meant we can get Dike and another striker in then I personally think its a gamble worth taking. Button is a decent keeper and our defence is solid enough and don't give many chances away. We simply have to be more clinical if we are going to get anywhere near the top 2.
If the bids are in the 3mill region, which I think is realistic given the contract position, we MUST keep him.
He could be the difference to a promotion, whether Top two or PO's, that would make a sum like that will seem paltry and if we don't go up then it is a small sum to lose out on.
This one was fucked up 18 months ago when we failed to extend or renegotiate his contract on promotion.
Even his howler at the weekend only cost us one point btw. We were never going to score if we were still there now and would have had a goalless draw at best
Which is why if it is an option to sell Sam to fund two strikers we need to take the money. In this Albion team, in this division, most games the keeper won't have a lot of saves to make, but does need to sweep, which isn't Sam's strength.
Even so, if there was a possibility he would stay on promotion than you'd do what you could to keep him as he is a great shot stopper, but he's run down his contract to move on regardless.
If there is a possibility of a sale they must have a shortlist of keepers who can play the sweeping role to replace.
Totally agree with this. Our defence is very solid. Replacing SJ with a good keeper and using the extra money where it is so badly needed would make far sense. Having a current England goalkeeper is a luxury for us in this division with our defence being so strong. I’d take the £3m.
Exactly this, SJ is a good keeper, personally his lack of communication and inability to come off his line for crosses will always stop him being a top, top keeper for me
Yet for us, right now, at our level he’s one of our better players but we don’t concede many chances and we have far bigger issues in the middle of the park and up top for me, we can afford to play a different keeper if we improve in other areas
Whether SJ and most likely his agent wants to entertain a January move is another matter
Cuzer

