AFGHANISTAN
#31
ISnt it just a case of Islam being used by certain groups to control & protect their way of life

Its a akin to witchcraft in the 1600's
Reply
#32
Afghanistan always has historically been a nightmare. We fought three wars there in the 19th Century, ostensibly to restrict Russian influence over the country and prevent their drift as a consequence towards the jewel in the crown, India - a theory often referred to as "The Great Game". None of those wars did us much good and the idea of increasing Russian control eventually leading to a collapse over our most prized asset of empire was always somewhat unrealistic.

Ironically, the Russian invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 which led to a near decade long war between the Soviets and the Mujahideen was a similar problem in reverse. Almost all western commentators voiced the idea that this was a nasty attempt to spread the influence of communist ideology to a backward but essentially decent people, the TV news being full of those nasty Russians killing the locals and why we in the west must help arm the Muslim fighters who some twenty years later morphed into the Taliban.

It was only when I met Russian students in Manchester in the early 80's that I was told by one of them that the war was being fought there in order to stop the spread of Muslim fundamentalist ideology into the border states of the USSR - now Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan and Tajikistan. I never heard any of this on the news reports and don't ever remember a western commentator, be it news or government mentioning this. The reality for Russia was that it was a problem which the Russians (quite rightly as it turned out) saw to be a horrendous situation which, if left alone, could lead to the radicalisation of Muslims in those border states, in turn resulting in the beginning of the break-up of the Soviet Union. They were already fighting hard to suppress Muslim insurgents in Chechnia - the idea of having to counter the same nightmare in land mass regions hundreds of times larger was unthinkable.

Here endeth the history lesson. Sufficeth to say it's not new and that western involvement in the country always ends in tears.
Reply
#33
(08-14-2021, 09:33 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(08-14-2021, 08:39 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(08-14-2021, 01:13 AM)Squid Wrote:
(08-13-2021, 08:13 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(08-13-2021, 07:31 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Absolute shambles as usual

According to reports on newsnight last night the local leaders just surrender the areas to the Taliban in exchange for safe passage out

With leaders like that you may as well just hand the keys over 

Its an insult to all those that lost lives or were injured over there trying to bring freedom & democracy
And to the ordinary Afghans 
 
We should have never gone to fight in a country akin to living in the 14th century

The Talban are from Pakistan so guessing they are the ones arming the group?
Im probably going to get slaughtered for this and maybe a ban ,but fugg it i speak as i find. IMVHO The Taliban and Afghanistan sums ALL that is wrong with Islam despite what what we are told to contrary, a religion stuck in medieval times and mindset and complely unwilling to change and adapt to modern society.

You do realise that there are over one billion Muslims on the planet and the most populous Muslim country is Indonesia. Claiming Afghanistan and Pakistan represent Muslims is like claiming the Serbs in the 90s represented all white people.

It makes me so sad to see this ignorance on here. I could understand if this was a football board for some rural team and Muslims were only people you saw on telly, but the Albion are in a town with a sizable Muslim population.

You probably work with Muslims, live next door to Muslims, when you go to the doctors or hospital, it's likely that one or more of the staff that is caring for you is Muslim. There's even been two Muslim players pulling on the stripes in recent times.

Yet despite all that, some on here clearly view Muslims as subhuman.

Firstly apologies to anyone offend by my post ,wasn't my intention,  i obviously didn't put it across very well but meant it to highlight the extreme followers and their views of Islam(taliban,isis etc) rather than all muslims. I've lived and worked alongside muslims all my working life and found some are salt of the earth types and some are just massive egotistical twats, just like society in general tbh.  Once again apologies for any offence caused. 
Getting back to the topic it never ceases to amaze me when we go into these places to help brng law and order and to protect the vulnerable , establish some form of democracy train their military up to a standard to achieve this then the minute we pull out it all crumbles ,,,do we never learn anything?

Your initial post came across fine, too many quick to assume unfortunately 

Cuzer

Thanks for the support Cuz, i usually dont post things like that for obvious reasons but when over 450 of our brave service men gave their lives to help make that place safe from a bunch of Medieval minded scum who have no wish to move with the times and then to see it all crumble the moment  we leave and us having to go back really boils my piss. Seems to me Afghanistan will never be a country that will ever live in some sort of harmony as there are to many factions hell bent on imposing their will on others and fighting with and killing any who do not conform to their will, i doubt there will ever be any lasting peace there.
Reply
#34
(08-14-2021, 09:57 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(08-14-2021, 09:33 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(08-14-2021, 08:39 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(08-14-2021, 01:13 AM)Squid Wrote:
(08-13-2021, 08:13 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Im probably going to get slaughtered for this and maybe a ban ,but fugg it i speak as i find. IMVHO The Taliban and Afghanistan sums ALL that is wrong with Islam despite what what we are told to contrary, a religion stuck in medieval times and mindset and complely unwilling to change and adapt to modern society.

You do realise that there are over one billion Muslims on the planet and the most populous Muslim country is Indonesia. Claiming Afghanistan and Pakistan represent Muslims is like claiming the Serbs in the 90s represented all white people.

It makes me so sad to see this ignorance on here. I could understand if this was a football board for some rural team and Muslims were only people you saw on telly, but the Albion are in a town with a sizable Muslim population.

You probably work with Muslims, live next door to Muslims, when you go to the doctors or hospital, it's likely that one or more of the staff that is caring for you is Muslim. There's even been two Muslim players pulling on the stripes in recent times.

Yet despite all that, some on here clearly view Muslims as subhuman.

Firstly apologies to anyone offend by my post ,wasn't my intention,  i obviously didn't put it across very well but meant it to highlight the extreme followers and their views of Islam(taliban,isis etc) rather than all muslims. I've lived and worked alongside muslims all my working life and found some are salt of the earth types and some are just massive egotistical twats, just like society in general tbh.  Once again apologies for any offence caused. 
Getting back to the topic it never ceases to amaze me when we go into these places to help brng law and order and to protect the vulnerable , establish some form of democracy train their military up to a standard to achieve this then the minute we pull out it all crumbles ,,,do we never learn anything?

Your initial post came across fine, too many quick to assume unfortunately 

Cuzer

Thanks for the support Cuz, i usually dont post things like that for obvious reasons but when over 450 of our brave service men gave their lives to help make that place safe from a bunch of Medieval minded scum who have no wish to move with the times and then to see it all crumble the moment  we leave and us having to go back really boils my piss. Seems to me Afghanistan will never be a country that will ever live in some sort of harmony as there are to many factions hell bent on imposing their will on others and fighting with and killing any who do not conform to their will, i doubt there will ever be any lasting peace there.

Must admit I had to go hunting for the post that had caused the fauxrage. then saw it and re-read it about five times to try and make it fit with the replies that actually had bugger all to do with it, but seemed aimed at it. Couldn't make it fit though so gave up.

The Muslim religion states that they are allowed to lie and deceive infidels and that it is encouraged, so it's hard to believe much that their leaders ever say. it's an archaic 'religion', but weirdly i'm Ok with that as it doesn't adapt and change its views to try and fit with the modern World. it's all a load of old wank though as are virtually all religiios, but you have to admire them sticking with stuff for so long. Unlike the West's churches that will change their own beliefs to attract new fans and stuff, now that their money is drying up, which is all its ever been about, wealth and power.
Reply
#35
Sorry but the situation in Afghanistan is one of the biggest shambles I’ve ever seen. A 20 year war. Billions spent. 400+ British soldiers dead, 2500 US soldiers dead, 66k Afghan soldiers dead, 47k Afghan civilians dead for it all to be lost in WEEKS. Catastrophic. I haven’t even mentioned those who are alive but lives have changed forever. Western and Afghan.

Of course there have been societal gains but even those will be lost under a taliban led government. SCARY.
Reply
#36
(08-14-2021, 09:51 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: Afghanistan always has historically been a nightmare.  We fought three wars there in the 19th Century, ostensibly to restrict Russian influence over the country and prevent their drift as a consequence towards the jewel in the crown, India - a theory often referred to as "The Great Game".  None of those wars did us much good and the idea of increasing Russian control eventually leading to a collapse over our most prized asset of empire was always somewhat unrealistic. 

Ironically, the Russian invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 which led to a near decade long war between the Soviets and the Mujahideen was a similar problem in reverse.  Almost all western commentators voiced the idea that this was a nasty attempt to spread the influence of communist ideology to a backward but essentially decent people, the TV news being full of those nasty Russians killing the locals and why we in the west must help arm the Muslim fighters who some twenty years later morphed into the Taliban.

It was only when I met Russian students in Manchester in the early 80's that I was told by one of them that the war was being fought there in order to stop the spread of Muslim fundamentalist ideology into the border states of the USSR - now Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan and Tajikistan.  I never heard any of this on the news reports and don't ever remember a western commentator, be it news or government mentioning this.  The reality for Russia was that it was a problem which the Russians (quite rightly as it turned out) saw to be a horrendous situation which, if left alone, could lead to the radicalisation of Muslims in those border states, in turn resulting in the beginning of the break-up of the Soviet Union.  They were already fighting hard to suppress Muslim insurgents in Chechnia - the idea of having to counter the same nightmare in land mass regions hundreds of times larger was unthinkable.

Here endeth the history lesson.  Sufficeth to say it's not new and that western involvement in the country always ends in tears.

Absolutely spot on.
Reply
#37
(08-14-2021, 09:51 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: Afghanistan always has historically been a nightmare.  We fought three wars there in the 19th Century, ostensibly to restrict Russian influence over the country and prevent their drift as a consequence towards the jewel in the crown, India - a theory often referred to as "The Great Game".  None of those wars did us much good and the idea of increasing Russian control eventually leading to a collapse over our most prized asset of empire was always somewhat unrealistic. 

Ironically, the Russian invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 which led to a near decade long war between the Soviets and the Mujahideen was a similar problem in reverse.  Almost all western commentators voiced the idea that this was a nasty attempt to spread the influence of communist ideology to a backward but essentially decent people, the TV news being full of those nasty Russians killing the locals and why we in the west must help arm the Muslim fighters who some twenty years later morphed into the Taliban.

It was only when I met Russian students in Manchester in the early 80's that I was told by one of them that the war was being fought there in order to stop the spread of Muslim fundamentalist ideology into the border states of the USSR - now Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan and Tajikistan.  I never heard any of this on the news reports and don't ever remember a western commentator, be it news or government mentioning this.  The reality for Russia was that it was a problem which the Russians (quite rightly as it turned out) saw to be a horrendous situation which, if left alone, could lead to the radicalisation of Muslims in those border states, in turn resulting in the beginning of the break-up of the Soviet Union.  They were already fighting hard to suppress Muslim insurgents in Chechnia - the idea of having to counter the same nightmare in land mass regions hundreds of times larger was unthinkable.

Here endeth the history lesson.  Sufficeth to say it's not new and that western involvement in the country always ends in tears.
They don’t call it the graveyard of empires for no reason!
Reply
#38
(08-14-2021, 10:15 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(08-14-2021, 09:57 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(08-14-2021, 09:33 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(08-14-2021, 08:39 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(08-14-2021, 01:13 AM)Squid Wrote: You do realise that there are over one billion Muslims on the planet and the most populous Muslim country is Indonesia. Claiming Afghanistan and Pakistan represent Muslims is like claiming the Serbs in the 90s represented all white people.

It makes me so sad to see this ignorance on here. I could understand if this was a football board for some rural team and Muslims were only people you saw on telly, but the Albion are in a town with a sizable Muslim population.

You probably work with Muslims, live next door to Muslims, when you go to the doctors or hospital, it's likely that one or more of the staff that is caring for you is Muslim. There's even been two Muslim players pulling on the stripes in recent times.

Yet despite all that, some on here clearly view Muslims as subhuman.

Firstly apologies to anyone offend by my post ,wasn't my intention,  i obviously didn't put it across very well but meant it to highlight the extreme followers and their views of Islam(taliban,isis etc) rather than all muslims. I've lived and worked alongside muslims all my working life and found some are salt of the earth types and some are just massive egotistical twats, just like society in general tbh.  Once again apologies for any offence caused. 
Getting back to the topic it never ceases to amaze me when we go into these places to help brng law and order and to protect the vulnerable , establish some form of democracy train their military up to a standard to achieve this then the minute we pull out it all crumbles ,,,do we never learn anything?

Your initial post came across fine, too many quick to assume unfortunately 

Cuzer

Thanks for the support Cuz, i usually dont post things like that for obvious reasons but when over 450 of our brave service men gave their lives to help make that place safe from a bunch of Medieval minded scum who have no wish to move with the times and then to see it all crumble the moment  we leave and us having to go back really boils my piss. Seems to me Afghanistan will never be a country that will ever live in some sort of harmony as there are to many factions hell bent on imposing their will on others and fighting with and killing any who do not conform to their will, i doubt there will ever be any lasting peace there.

Must admit I had to go hunting for the post that had caused the fauxrage. then saw it and re-read it about five times to try and make it fit with the replies that actually had bugger all to do with it, but seemed aimed at it. Couldn't make it fit though so gave up.

The Muslim religion states that they are allowed to lie and deceive infidels and that it is encouraged, so it's hard to believe much that their leaders ever say. it's an archaic 'religion', but weirdly i'm Ok with that as it doesn't adapt and change its views to try and fit with the modern World. it's all a load of old wank though as are virtually all religiios, but you have to admire them sticking with stuff for so long. Unlike the West's churches that will change their own beliefs to attract new fans and stuff, now that their money is drying up, which is all its ever been about, wealth and power.

No, it doesn't. What you are referring to is Taqiyyah, which is when one is allowed to lie about their religious adherence in a life or death situation. 

As for someone else defending the Russian invasion of Afghanistan. The Russians went in there to prop up a deeply unpopular Communist regime (unpopular for the same reasons most Communist regimes are, they imprison and kill those opposed to them). The idea they were bravely fighting Islamic extremism is nonsense.
Reply
#39
(08-16-2021, 04:40 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Sorry but the situation in Afghanistan is one of the biggest shambles I’ve ever seen. A 20 year war. Billions spent. 400+ British soldiers dead, 2500 US soldiers dead, 66k Afghan soldiers dead, 47k Afghan civilians dead for it all to be lost in WEEKS. Catastrophic. I haven’t even mentioned those who are alive but lives have changed forever. Western and Afghan.

Of course there have been societal gains but even those will be lost under a taliban led government. SCARY.

+1 
Though I have a theory that it’s all deliberate. In a year or 2 we will find a reason to go back in there and the cycle will start all over again. There will be an increased trade in weapons and defence companies will make billions. 
As Gil Scot Heron once said, Americans no longer fight to keep our shores safe, just to keep the Jobs going in the arms making workplace 

Reply
#40
Squid, you are of course partly right in stating that the Russians entered Afghanistan to prop up a largely unpopular Communist govt. But it does not negate their fear of Islamic fundamentalism and the danger that such a state on its borders posed to its own regime. The fact that the west propped up the Mujahadeen, armed and financed them was itself a Cold War by proxy in order to facilitate their own agenda re. the undermining of the Soviet Union. Read my post. I did not defend the Soviets and I did not state they “bravely” did anything. It was political pragmatism. I merely pointed out that when the west decided to back the Mujahadeen they only helped sustain and create a monster equally as deadly and unpleasant as the regime they sought to remove.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: