Appleton
#31
(02-27-2021, 02:00 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: If Aoppleton hadn't played for us would there be the clamour for him to manage us?

I doubt it.

Good managers at 3rd tier level don't always step-up to the Championship, like Paul Hurst who ruine Ipswich in his short time. And I still remember the game against West Ham he was in charge for. That second half...

Allardyce will probably have us thereabouts next season if he stays, I am not sure Appleton would.

West Ham was his first competitive game as manager ffs.
Reply
#32
(02-27-2021, 02:00 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: If Aoppleton hadn't played for us would there be the clamour for him to manage us?

I doubt it.

Good managers at 3rd tier level don't always step-up to the Championship, like Paul Hurst who ruine Ipswich in his short time. And I still remember the game against West Ham he was in charge for. That second half...

Allardyce will probably have us thereabouts next season if he stays, I am not sure Appleton would.

Are you seriously using a substitution made as a caretaker manager a decade ago as a reason for not emplying him? Christ on a bike.

As for only being interested in him because of his links, that's also very much untrue. Take away the link and look at the job he has done there over the last 20 months and it's exactly the type of manager a club out level would be looking at. The job he is doing is nothing short of remarkable. Add in the job he did at Oxford and it's clear that when he is allowed time to implement his ideas, he's one of the brightest managers in the game.
Reply
#33
(02-27-2021, 02:00 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: If Aoppleton hadn't played for us would there be the clamour for him to manage us?

I doubt it.

Good managers at 3rd tier level don't always step-up to the Championship, like Paul Hurst who ruine Ipswich in his short time. And I still remember the game against West Ham he was in charge for. That second half...

Allardyce will probably have us thereabouts next season if he stays, I am not sure Appleton would.

We interviewed the Cowley brothers at Lincoln and they weren’t doing as well as Appy is. They had no connection
Reply
#34
(02-27-2021, 08:34 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2021, 02:00 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: If Aoppleton hadn't played for us would there be the clamour for him to manage us?

I doubt it.

Good managers at 3rd tier level don't always step-up to the Championship, like Paul Hurst who ruine Ipswich in his short time. And I still remember the game against West Ham he was in charge for. That second half...

Allardyce will probably have us thereabouts next season if he stays, I am not sure Appleton would.

Are you seriously using a substitution made as a caretaker manager a decade ago as a reason for not emplying him? Christ on a bike.

As for only being interested in him because of his links, that's also very much untrue. Take away the link and look at the job he has done there over the last 20 months and it's exactly the type of manager a club out level would be looking at. The job he is doing is nothing short of remarkable. Add in the job he did at Oxford and it's clear that when he is allowed time to implement his ideas, he's one of the brightest managers in the game.

He's an absolutely first rate coach, people who have done any coaching with him can only say how fantastic he is.

Exactly what we need.
Reply
#35
What we need is someone to get us out the Champ next year and a reasonable chance of keeping us in the Prem the year later. No projects, no long term vision that’s not going to happen with an owner who wants to sell. I’m not sure how Appleton becomes the answer within those parameters.

All my opinion is based on is where we are as a club nothing against Appleton but I’m really not sure the timing or circumstances would be right.
Reply
#36
(02-27-2021, 09:07 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What we need is someone to get us out the Champ next year and a reasonable chance of keeping us in the  Prem the year later. No projects, no long term vision that’s not going to happen with an owner who wants to sell. I’m not sure how Appleton becomes the answer within those parameters.

All my opinion is based on is where we are as a club nothing against Appleton but I’m really not sure the timing or circumstances would be right.

Just wondered what circumstances would be right? 

I don’t think anyone wants to employ someone who we know won’t take us up. 

Staying up on our current budget will be difficult for anyone. I think the term ‘project’ is being used for planning to keep hold of the manager if we go down and going again hopefully a bit stronger. If we stay up, fine.
Reply
#37
(02-27-2021, 09:13 AM)Wotty Wrote:
(02-27-2021, 09:07 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What we need is someone to get us out the Champ next year and a reasonable chance of keeping us in the  Prem the year later. No projects, no long term vision that’s not going to happen with an owner who wants to sell. I’m not sure how Appleton becomes the answer within those parameters.

All my opinion is based on is where we are as a club nothing against Appleton but I’m really not sure the timing or circumstances would be right.

Just wondered what circumstances would be right? 

I don’t think anyone wants to employ someone who we know won’t take us up. 

Staying up on our current budget will be difficult for anyone. I think the term ‘project’ is being used for planning to keep hold of the manager if we go down and going again hopefully a bit stronger. If we stay up, fine.

If the owner wants out the manager isn't going to be afforded two or three seasons to get us up for example. If he does get us up next season his position is in danger because potential new owners have different ideas and change managers on a whim. I cannot see past a short term solution because that’s where the club is at the moment. If we were building firm foundations for the future then maybe but nothing feels long term at the moment and certainly not our financial advantage which is entirely thanks to parachute payments. It’s another two or at a unrealistic push three years poop or bust promotion at any cost for the club. The inevitable consequence of a club that is reliant on being self sufficient. It’s worth noting the average tenure for any manager is two years in the Prem and Championship long term plans are what you make whilst results are what determines the reality of those plans.
Reply
#38
(02-27-2021, 09:21 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2021, 09:13 AM)Wotty Wrote:
(02-27-2021, 09:07 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What we need is someone to get us out the Champ next year and a reasonable chance of keeping us in the  Prem the year later. No projects, no long term vision that’s not going to happen with an owner who wants to sell. I’m not sure how Appleton becomes the answer within those parameters.

All my opinion is based on is where we are as a club nothing against Appleton but I’m really not sure the timing or circumstances would be right.

Just wondered what circumstances would be right? 

I don’t think anyone wants to employ someone who we know won’t take us up. 

Staying up on our current budget will be difficult for anyone. I think the term ‘project’ is being used for planning to keep hold of the manager if we go down and going again hopefully a bit stronger. If we stay up, fine.

If the owner wants out the manager isn't going to be afforded two or three seasons to get us up for example. If they do get us up next season their position is in danger because potential new owners have different ideas and change managers at a who etc. I cannot see past a short term solution because that’s where the club is at the moment. If we were building firm foundations for the future then maybe but nothing feels long term at the moment and certainly not our financial advantage thanks to parachute payments.

So the ownership issue isn’t going to lend itself to anything requiring patience or forward planning. 

I see your point.

It would be wrong for the club mind
Reply
#39
Whoever the coach is will be expected to deliver promotion on a shoestring with a few permanent but mainly loan signings , no disrespect to Appleton who may be a fantastic coach but if your a young player at a big club looking for a loan with a number of options on the table and someone like a Big Sam or a Lampard comes calling the lure of playing for them would be there , I’m not sure Appleton carries the same kind of gravitas .
Reply
#40
(02-27-2021, 10:00 AM)Faggits Wrote: Whoever the coach is will be expected to deliver promotion on a shoestring with a few permanent but mainly loan signings , no disrespect to Appleton who may be a fantastic coach but if your a young player at a big club looking for a loan with a number of options on the table and someone like a Big Sam or a Lampard comes calling the lure of playing for them would be there , I’m not sure Appleton carries the same kind of gravitas .

I agree Lampard may well be a pull but the coaches at these clubs are well aware of Appleton and what a good coach he is. They can advise accordingly.
I’m not sure BFS is a pull to anyone
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: