Growth
My eyes are telling me that regardless of numbers
Raw Sausage
Reply
(06-18-2026, 03:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2026, 03:08 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-18-2026, 01:55 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Jobs that used to employ EU citizens are being taken up by non-EU migrants, no shit. Vote Leave put through a leaflet written in Punjabi through my grandparents letterboxes explicitly calling for that to happen, now you're surprised by that? I believe you referred to freedom of movement as a racist policy in the past so I thought that is what you and all the Brexit supporters in the CSJ wanted?

I have no problem with legal immigration from wherever. I have every problem with consigning British kids of whatever colour to the PIP or NEET scrapheap. What do the numbers tell you?

The numbers from that tell me that EU migration is likely being replaced with non-EU migration, it's very telling that the CSJ have decided to omit EU migrant data. Otherwise they're saying that number of jobs offered to UK citizens aged 16-24 has stayed relatively flat in that timeframe.

And you don't believe that is problematic?

(06-18-2026, 07:11 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Is Thieves actually a magician?

She's grown the year on year May borrowing figure by 30%.
Reply
(06-19-2026, 07:04 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-18-2026, 03:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2026, 03:08 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-18-2026, 01:55 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Jobs that used to employ EU citizens are being taken up by non-EU migrants, no shit. Vote Leave put through a leaflet written in Punjabi through my grandparents letterboxes explicitly calling for that to happen, now you're surprised by that? I believe you referred to freedom of movement as a racist policy in the past so I thought that is what you and all the Brexit supporters in the CSJ wanted?

I have no problem with legal immigration from wherever. I have every problem with consigning British kids of whatever colour to the PIP or NEET scrapheap. What do the numbers tell you?

The numbers from that tell me that EU migration is likely being replaced with non-EU migration, it's very telling that the CSJ have decided to omit EU migrant data. Otherwise they're saying that number of jobs offered to UK citizens aged 16-24 has stayed relatively flat in that timeframe.

And you don't believe that is problematic?

What am I supposed to believe is problematic? The CSJ purposefully omitted a key data point to prevent any meaningful conclusion to be able to be formed, if as I suspect EU migration is down massively and being taken up by non-EU migration then I'm upset that EU citizens no longer want to work in the UK especially as they're the highest tax contributors per capita of any labour cohort but otherwise comparing an increase vs a stable flat trend which is that the CSJ have given doesn't mean anything at all.

I'm very confused why you think it's problematic though seeing as you explicitly campaigned on it, unless you were completely unaware of the literature and campaign points of the campaign you were part of. Though given that you were supportive of it here I'd be very surprised that's the case.
Reply
I think you're confused. Perhaps you should read what I posted. It's not the immigration that is the problem, it's the lack of recruitment of young people that are already here.
Reply
I did read what was posted, there's no indication that British and Irish citizens aged 16-24 are being overlooked as the trend for them is relatively flat, and the CSJ have deliberately omitted the rates of EU citizens. If the EU rate has dropped (which I strongly suspect it has) then they're not being overlooked, it's a pretty serious omission.
Reply
"Young people not in work or training up almost 200,000 over the same period"

Is that not problematic?
Reply
Seeing as it corresponds to a 0.3% rise in that very same cohort being employed, no. As I said there's not enough information in that to make any sort of conclusion. Who's jobs are non-EU migrants taking if British and Irish nationals aren't the ones who are dropping? Where are these 200k people coming from relatively if there's been a growth in that cohort being employed? What has happened with EU citizens? 3 key statistics needed to make any sort of conclusion that are conveniently omitted. And I have a few reasons why the CSJ would want to do that.
Reply
Hmm. With over 1 million 16-24 NEETS and no increase in their propensity to be employed / employable I suspect we're approaching this from different perspectives.

If the jobs non-EU migrants are filling are entry level, why can't existing kids here?
Reply
The areas with the highest numbers of NEETs being post-industrial parts of the Midlands and North with low economic activity and the fact that most migrants (non-EU, EU and inter-UK migration) move to big cities or other areas with high economic activity should be a pretty obvious reason. For the most part they aren't competing for the same jobs, that's why even with the upturn in NEETs since 2022 the numbers of UK citizens aged 16-24 in employment has risen rather than dropped. But the study does not cover that, nor does it talk about what happened with EU migrants in that same range.

I think you need to ask yourself why the CSJ, a right wing think tank with strong links to Reform and the right of the Tories, would try to omit key data points from a study that is quite clearly trying to blame migration would try to obfuscate the facts to come to that conclusion.
Reply
(06-19-2026, 02:57 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I think you need to ask yourself why the CSJ, a right wing think tank with strong links to Reform and the right of the Tories...

Is that the same CSJ whose cross-party Social Justice Commissioners include Tim Farron, Stephen Timms and er....Andy Burnham?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)