Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(04-20-2020, 08:38 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: For anyone interested, there is a response now on the official gov.com site.
(Sad day when we are referring to the governments one as the OS. Bring back football!)
Isn't anyone going to post the rebuttal for accuracy of how government actually works? Or for balance?
Oh well, never mind.
There was also a great article in The Sunday Times about how the government scientists driving our strategy have been consistently wrong about pandemics in the past:
1990 50,000 British Deaths due to Mad Cow Disease - outturn 177
2005 200 million projected wordwide deaths from Bird Flu - actual deaths 282 over six years
2009 65,000 British Deaths due to Swine Flu - actual deaths 457
Scientists ALL think differently. Consequently, "listening to the science" is as much a question of weighing up opportunity cost as the ridiculous debate about "climate change".
It doesn't really help that the Chinese have been bullshitting about this since day one either.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(04-20-2020, 10:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-20-2020, 08:38 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: For anyone interested, there is a response now on the official gov.com site.
(Sad day when we are referring to the governments one as the OS. Bring back football!)
Isn't anyone going to post the rebuttal for accuracy of how government actually works? Or for balance?
Oh well, never mind.
There was also a great article in The Sunday Times about how the government scientists driving our strategy have been consistently wrong about pandemics in the past:
1990 50,000 British Deaths due to Mad Cow Disease - outturn 177
2005 200 million projected wordwide deaths from Bird Flu - actual deaths 282 over six years
2009 65,000 British Deaths due to Swine Flu - actual deaths 457
Scientists ALL think differently. Consequently, "listening to the science" is as much a question of weighing up opportunity cost as the ridiculous debate about "climate change".
It doesn't really help that the Chinese have been bullshitting about this since day one either.
This is very true, especially in regard to this situation, if for the very obvious reason that Covid 19 is anew virus, that scientists are having to learn about on the hoof - the view of scientists will evolve over time, but as it evolves there will be a consensus of opinion develop. This is why the second half of your paragraph is dangerous, because there is an overwhelming consensus amongst scientist of varying disciplines that climate change is happening, and the reasons why it is happening. There are a small minority of scientists who disagree with the consensus, but in these cases many have an economic reason for their minority opinion.
On the Sunday Times, I am not sure how helpful it is. But what is interesting is the why it was published. To whose advantage was it published, and who supplied the journalists with the story. A possible clue maybe gleaned by the news report being run today, that Johnson has become cautious about when lockdown should end, a view that ay be contrary to some/many of his cabinet colleagues.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
04-20-2020, 12:49 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-20-2020, 12:51 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
The problem with any rebuttal / reply to any critcism levelled at this government is their outstanding record of lying.
Is anything their fault?
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
04-20-2020, 12:54 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-20-2020, 12:56 PM by Protheroe.)
(04-20-2020, 10:28 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: This is why the second half of your paragraph is dangerous, because there is an overwhelming consensus amongst scientist of varying disciplines that climate change is happening, and the reasons why it is happening.
The ridiculous debate about climate change is not about whether it's happening or not, it's the use of science to inform the false and inflammotory rhetoric about people "dying from climate change" (100% bollocks Greta) - and the belief amongst XR's that the only solution is to impoverish ourselves which will actually make us less able to deal with th effects of climate change.
I apologise if you got the wrong end of the stick.
(04-20-2020, 12:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The problem with any rebuttal / reply to any critcism levelled at this government is their outstanding record of lying.
Is anything their fault?
But you're ready to believe a Murdoch paper. You are funny Dekka. Inconsistent, and funny.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-20-2020, 12:54 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-20-2020, 10:28 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: This is why the second half of your paragraph is dangerous, because there is an overwhelming consensus amongst scientist of varying disciplines that climate change is happening, and the reasons why it is happening.
The ridiculous debate about climate change is not about whether it's happening or not, it's the use of science to inform the false and inflammotory rhetoric about people "dying from climate change" (100% bollocks Greta) - and the belief amongst XR's that the only solution is to impoverish ourselves which will actually make us less able to deal with th effects of climate change.
I apologise if you got the wrong end of the stick.
(04-20-2020, 12:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The problem with any rebuttal / reply to any critcism levelled at this government is their outstanding record of lying.
Is anything their fault?
But you're ready to believe a Murdoch paper. You are funny Dekka. Inconsistent, and funny.
I’m sure that the truth is somewhere in-between but the Reuter’s article I linked to before had similar if not so opinionated position on wasted time, failure to listen to a wider number of experts, preoccupation with Brexit etc.
If I had to guess I’d say the Conservatives party was completely preoccupied by Brexit and they underestimated the problem. I’d say they are now trying to place the criticism at the feet of the NHS and the experts. It’s playground stuff but this childish populism and looking to blame others has worked since Brexit and I can’t see them changing tactics anytime soon. If it doesn’t then they will do what they always do and make a sacrificial lamb to take the blame like Matt Hancock Behind the scenes there will be trigger happy hardliners, stirring the pot wanting to lift the lockdown early I’m sure.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
04-20-2020, 02:40 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-20-2020, 03:01 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(04-20-2020, 02:09 PM)The liquidator Wrote: (04-20-2020, 12:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The problem with any rebuttal / reply to any critcism levelled at this government is their outstanding record of lying.
Is anything their fault?
They are not lying keeping your household afloat derek you should be grateful Instead of daily trying to stick the knife into the people that are putting food on your table
You should be sucking them off not stabbing them everytime you have the chance .
I’m working I’m not furloughed currently but with a reduced wage, with a fair few jobs postponed. That said I’m far far better off than many I know. I’ve also said thank you and praised the government on the financial packages. The thread is still up for f you want proof. They are very good as was the imo previous pre-Covid budget. I also feel a bit sorry for Matt Hancock who seems to be struggling to square a circle. My problem with the party, particularly since Brexit is the lack of honesty and harsh cuts to public services previously.
Their are millions of people who are furloughed who may or may not share your political beliefs but are doing what the country needs to ensure we flatten the curve. They haven’t chosen to be in this situation and it doesn’t mean you cannot question decisions. Some things they have got right some things they haven’t. You are right in one respect that I’m going to take a step back from the overly partisan posts I’ve done recently because things are never black and white and I’ve been guilty of of treating this as such which I never used to do. Perhaps it’s the nature of message boards as you pick a side and don’t give an inch. Try not to get too personal though Liq eh
Posts: 4,217
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
04-20-2020, 04:45 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-20-2020, 04:48 PM by The liquidator.)
I was going to take it down but you clearly have drawn your line in the sand and will stab the government at every chance .......I think the financial packages have been very good and still the tory haters continue to put the knife in I've got a feeling that some are willing the death rates to go up to say I told you so .....quite sickening by some on Twitter it's a evil place
(04-20-2020, 02:40 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-20-2020, 02:09 PM)The liquidator Wrote: (04-20-2020, 12:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The problem with any rebuttal / reply to any critcism levelled at this government is their outstanding record of lying.
Is anything their fault?
They are not lying keeping your household afloat derek you should be grateful Instead of daily trying to stick the knife into the people that are putting food on your table
You should be sucking them off not stabbing them everytime you have the chance .
I’m working I’m not furloughed currently but with a reduced wage, with a fair few jobs postponed. That said I’m far far better off than many I know. I’ve also said thank you and praised the government on the financial packages. The thread is still up for f you want proof. They are very good as was the imo previous pre-Covid budget. I also feel a bit sorry for Matt Hancock who seems to be struggling to square a circle. My problem with the party, particularly since Brexit is the lack of honesty and harsh cuts to public services previously.
Their are millions of people who are furloughed who may or may not share your political beliefs but are doing what the country needs to ensure we flatten the curve. They haven’t chosen to be in this situation and it doesn’t mean you cannot question decisions. Some things they have got right some things they haven’t. You are right in one respect that I’m going to take a step back from the overly partisan posts I’ve done recently because things are never black and white and I’ve been guilty of of treating this as such which I never used to do. Perhaps it’s the nature of message boards as you pick a side and don’t give an inch. Try not to get too personal though Liq eh 
I stand corrected sir but dont sharpen that knife anymore its lethal already
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(04-20-2020, 10:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-20-2020, 08:38 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: For anyone interested, there is a response now on the official gov.com site.
(Sad day when we are referring to the governments one as the OS. Bring back football!)
Isn't anyone going to post the rebuttal for accuracy of how government actually works? Or for balance?
Oh well, never mind.
There was also a great article in The Sunday Times about how the government scientists driving our strategy have been consistently wrong about pandemics in the past:
1990 50,000 British Deaths due to Mad Cow Disease - outturn 177
2005 200 million projected wordwide deaths from Bird Flu - actual deaths 282 over six years
2009 65,000 British Deaths due to Swine Flu - actual deaths 457
Scientists ALL think differently. Consequently, "listening to the science" is as much a question of weighing up opportunity cost as the ridiculous debate about "climate change".
It doesn't really help that the Chinese have been bullshitting about this since day one either. The point of my post was exactly for balance  I thought I'd make people aware of the government response.
I read the Paterson article, which has kicked up the mother of all storms, and thought it raised many valid points. I also think it was clearly polemic. For instance by not mentioning the incompetence of the WHO, by mentioning Brexit a good half dozen times, by delivering a few good personal insults. I said originally, the validity of the points raised, was undermined by the selective nature of the scapegoating. There's nothing wrong with a viewpoint from the Left or the Right, but if you only report what you want, then the point is disingenuous.
While I understand the necessity of scrutiny, I don't find the constant criticism of any action the government take (or don't take), to be constructive at this time. Eventually this entire business will be examined, blame (and hopefully credit) apportioned and many held accountable. Doing those things now, with partial hindsight, is IMO very unhelpful.
Posts: 3,032
Threads: 78
Joined: Jun 2019
Reputation:
22
(04-20-2020, 06:05 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: While I understand the necessity of scrutiny, I don't find the constant criticism of any action the government take (or don't take), to be constructive at this time. Eventually this entire business will be examined, blame (and hopefully credit) apportioned and many held accountable. Doing those things now, with partial hindsight, is IMO very unhelpful.
TJ, that is entirely consistent with my own view; and that appraisal will need to take account not only of the timing and manner of the response, but also the general level of preparedness for not just this but any national emergency. In other words scrutiny of the policies in the years leading up to this outbreak.
Evaluating whether the timing of the reaction was slower than need be - and whether that cost lives - will inevitably be subjective, and we'll no doubt all have varying views on that. I'm not impressed with Johnson (but hope he gets fully well as soon as possible) and am never likely to be; Matt Hancock has actually exceeded my expectations, although it has to be said they were set at a very low level; Sunak has so far made a more than decent fist of being the one holding a pretty shitty parcel when the music stopped.
What will interest me most is the verdict on the 10 years 2010-2019 and how the legacy of that decade impacted on the preparedness of the NHS in terms of its resources - infrastructure, equipment, and - most of all - personnel. The media will need to shine a light on those deliberations; let's see if they can behave like adults when the situation requires it.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(04-20-2020, 06:05 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (04-20-2020, 10:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-20-2020, 08:38 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: For anyone interested, there is a response now on the official gov.com site.
(Sad day when we are referring to the governments one as the OS. Bring back football!)
Isn't anyone going to post the rebuttal for accuracy of how government actually works? Or for balance?
Oh well, never mind.
There was also a great article in The Sunday Times about how the government scientists driving our strategy have been consistently wrong about pandemics in the past:
1990 50,000 British Deaths due to Mad Cow Disease - outturn 177
2005 200 million projected wordwide deaths from Bird Flu - actual deaths 282 over six years
2009 65,000 British Deaths due to Swine Flu - actual deaths 457
Scientists ALL think differently. Consequently, "listening to the science" is as much a question of weighing up opportunity cost as the ridiculous debate about "climate change".
It doesn't really help that the Chinese have been bullshitting about this since day one either. The point of my post was exactly for balance I thought I'd make people aware of the government response.
I read the Paterson article, which has kicked up the mother of all storms, and thought it raised many valid points. I also think it was clearly polemic. For instance by not mentioning the incompetence of the WHO, by mentioning Brexit a good half dozen times, by delivering a few good personal insults. I said originally, the validity of the points raised, was undermined by the selective nature of the scapegoating. There's nothing wrong with a viewpoint from the Left or the Right, but if you only report what you want, then the point is disingenuous.
While I understand the necessity of scrutiny, I don't find the constant criticism of any action the government take (or don't take), to be constructive at this time. Eventually this entire business will be examined, blame (and hopefully credit) apportioned and many held accountable. Doing those things now, with partial hindsight, is IMO very unhelpful.
I agree with this.
Throughout this I have tried not to be too critical of the Govt, although politically they are not to my taste. I don't feel that I know enough on this subject to make comment, as a layman there are things happening or suggestions being made that make no sense to me, but time will tell if my 'amateur' hunches are correct or not.
However I would make this observation, the Govt, or more pertinently individuals within the Govt need to stop playing politics. Too many times the media report on anonymous cabinet sources, which can often be contradictory. So on Sunday, the Sunday Times published a story based on briefings from an unnamed cabinet source that schools would be re-opening on May 11th, only fort his to be re-butted by the Education Secretary. If the Govt wants the country to be united during this crisis, then it need to show a united front as well and cut out the off the record briefings to the media.
|