Villa - FFP !
#21
(01-23-2020, 10:16 PM)Jezstatham Wrote: My girlfriends a chartered surveyor!. What's the question?!

Whsts her mates like ? Heart
Reply
#22
Of course the Prem have jurisdiction, they are investigating the valuation of the stadium and are getting independent valuations.

(01-23-2020, 09:42 PM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(01-23-2020, 08:43 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-23-2020, 08:41 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-23-2020, 08:21 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: https://twitter.com/kieranmaguire/status...67298?s=21

About time too!

Saw this earlier.

The deludedfisheatingsealcunts reckon Villa Park is worth more than Pride Park, because it seats more......

The real question is basis of valuation. Vacant Possession? Market Value based on Matket Rent? What are your comparibles?

Do we have a Chartered Surveyor on here who can offer an insight?

I’m no surveyor but I would imagine that a 40k historic stadium near Birmingham City Center with good links to Spaghetti Junction would be worth more than a 35k identikit stadium on a retail park outside Derby.

I'd imagine that if stadiums were valued on that basis it would depend on how many buyers there are who are interested in moving a sports team into a 40,000+ capacity stadium near a motorway junction in Aston. My guess would be not very many, therefore making having more seats than Derby largely irrelevant. In my none surveyor status I'd imagine there'd be far more money to be made converting the land to another use.

None is the answer.  It's only financially viable use would be as a development site for housing.
Reply
#23
(01-23-2020, 10:16 PM)Jezstatham Wrote: My girlfriends a chartered surveyor!. What's the question?!

Have your tried "Will you marry me?"  Tongue
Reply
#24
(01-23-2020, 10:17 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-23-2020, 10:16 PM)Jezstatham Wrote: My girlfriends a chartered surveyor!. What's the question?!

I don’t know anymore!

The question is will the Vile be stung by FFP, the answer as we all know is NOT IN A MILLION FUGGIN YEARS THE JAMMY AROGANT DELUDEDFISHEATINGSEAL CUNTS.
Reply
#25
(01-23-2020, 09:58 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-23-2020, 09:40 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Would they not look at rental yield? ..ie Derby and Veela need to be paying a commercial rent and that rent would be indicative of the value of the stadium.

That is the traditional way to achieve Market Value. If you apply a yield of 7%, this gives a market rent of £4M p.a.

Is £4M a realistic rent for a stadium that hosts 20 games, and a few rock concerts, with very little other income?

As a commercial property a viable investment would surely look at yields of 7% and perhaps more.

5% would not get many investors looking to deal.
Reply
#26
Have no fear, the Seals will get away with it...
Reply
#27
As the owner would in reality paying the rent to himself, it's just a paperwork exercise. I believe they can even sell the stadium back to the club for a £1 if they want to. But they can only sell it once at its market value.

I've not checked, but I think WHU pay less then £4m a year to rent the Olympic stadium. Which must be worth a least 10 times the Seal sanctuary.
Reply
#28
(01-23-2020, 10:41 PM)Hopalong Wrote: Of course the Prem have jurisdiction, they are investigating the valuation of the stadium and are getting independent valuations.

(01-23-2020, 09:42 PM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(01-23-2020, 08:43 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-23-2020, 08:41 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-23-2020, 08:21 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: https://twitter.com/kieranmaguire/status...67298?s=21

About time too!

Saw this earlier.

The deludedfisheatingsealcunts reckon Villa Park is worth more than Pride Park, because it seats more......

The real question is basis of valuation. Vacant Possession? Market Value based on Matket Rent? What are your comparibles?

Do we have a Chartered Surveyor on here who can offer an insight?

I’m no surveyor but I would imagine that a 40k historic stadium near Birmingham City Center with good links to Spaghetti Junction would be worth more than a 35k identikit stadium on a retail park outside Derby.

I'd imagine that if stadiums were valued on that basis it would depend on how many buyers there are who are interested in moving a sports team into a 40,000+ capacity stadium near a motorway junction in Aston. My guess would be not very many, therefore making having more seats than Derby largely irrelevant. In my none surveyor status I'd imagine there'd be far more money to be made converting the land to another use.

None is the answer.  It's only financially viable use would be as a development site for housing.

This is true but using a housing valuation to underpin the value is utter hogwash. I worked as a commercial land agent for 15 years so know a bit about it.

The stadium is a commercial property and is employment generating. For the stadium to be knocked down and used for housing you would have to prove that the stadium was no longer commercially viable. With 40,000 paying twats turning up every other week that's hard to prove.

I suppose you could say that you have another site to move to and Villa Park will then be an empty site. Fine. Problem being is finding new land close by and the cost of building a new stadium dwarfs that of building a few poxy houses so again you are no better off.

They'll get out of this though. I was listening to SIMON Jordan talking about Derby earlier this week. He said that on the face of it it doesn't seem fair but ALL derby (and Villa) did was exploit a loophole. He said Derby were in open dialogue with the EFL all the way through the whole process.

He said the loophole needs closing but if he was Mel Morris he would take this to the highest court possible because the EFL has no basis on which to enforce any sanctions.

Fucked if I know what's going to happen but my guess would be just that. They'll all get a slap on the wrists and the loophole closed.
Reply
#29
(01-24-2020, 06:46 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: As the owner would in reality paying the rent to himself, it's just a paperwork exercise. I believe they can even sell the stadium back to the club for a £1 if they want to. But they can only sell it once at its market value.

I've not checked, but I think WHU pay less then £4m a year to rent the Olympic stadium. Which must be worth a least 10 times the Seal sanctuary.

Absolutely not.  Any transactions between connected parties have to be on fully arms length terms under the FFP rules

(01-24-2020, 07:31 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(01-23-2020, 10:41 PM)Hopalong Wrote: Of course the Prem have jurisdiction, they are investigating the valuation of the stadium and are getting independent valuations.

(01-23-2020, 09:42 PM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(01-23-2020, 08:43 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-23-2020, 08:41 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Saw this earlier.

The deludedfisheatingsealcunts reckon Villa Park is worth more than Pride Park, because it seats more......

The real question is basis of valuation. Vacant Possession? Market Value based on Matket Rent? What are your comparibles?

Do we have a Chartered Surveyor on here who can offer an insight?

I’m no surveyor but I would imagine that a 40k historic stadium near Birmingham City Center with good links to Spaghetti Junction would be worth more than a 35k identikit stadium on a retail park outside Derby.

I'd imagine that if stadiums were valued on that basis it would depend on how many buyers there are who are interested in moving a sports team into a 40,000+ capacity stadium near a motorway junction in Aston. My guess would be not very many, therefore making having more seats than Derby largely irrelevant. In my none surveyor status I'd imagine there'd be far more money to be made converting the land to another use.

None is the answer.  It's only financially viable use would be as a development site for housing.

This is true but using a housing valuation to underpin the value is utter hogwash. I worked as a commercial land agent for 15 years so know a bit about it.

The stadium is a commercial property and is employment generating. For the stadium to be knocked down and used for housing you would have to prove that the stadium was no longer commercially viable. With 40,000 paying twats turning up every other week that's hard to prove.

I suppose you could say that you have another site to move to and Villa Park will then be an empty site. Fine. Problem being is finding new land close by and the cost of building a new stadium dwarfs that of building a few poxy houses so again you are no better off.

They'll get out of this though. I was listening to SIMON Jordan talking about Derby earlier this week. He said that on the face of it it doesn't seem fair but ALL derby (and Villa) did was exploit a loophole. He said Derby were in open dialogue with the EFL all the way through the whole process.

He said the loophole needs closing but if he was Mel Morris he would take this to the highest court possible because the EFL has no basis on which to enforce any sanctions.

Fucked if I know what's going to happen but my guess would be just that. They'll all get a slap on the wrists and the loophole closed.

Jordan is only partially right.  The loophole is that a club may sell its stadium and the profit will be taken into account for FFP.  But it must be either to a genuine third party or on fully arms length terms.  That is where it can fall down and that’s what the EFL are challenging.  Christ, Sheffield Wednesday claimed to have sold their ground in July 2018 to a company that wasn’t formed till July 2019!
Reply
#30
Didn’t Purslow write the FFP legislation? If anyone knows where the loopholes are it’s him.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)