Bilic and Dowling
#21
(09-30-2019, 03:43 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Luke Downing 1st transfer window Jan 2019 started off great - Holgate on the first day turned out to be an inspired signing filling our problematic right  full back problem. However Montero / Murphy / Johansen were not so great - Montero & Murphy were total rubbish and Johansen was unfit. They all came at the last minute and appeared to be desperation signings.
Our signing and selling of Sako was a joke. Considering Dowling has a team of 12 professionals working on new signings and contracts, this was poor and not what we needed at the time. Hence his reputation was tarnished. The removal of Darren could have been handled a lot better and the inability to select a new manager for months also reflected directly on Dowling. This may have been unfair, but that's life.
However all our latest signings (Bar Wllock) have been brilliant. Again credit to Dowling and Bilic who has certainly been instrumental in some of the signings.
While we continue to ride high the clubs management will receive the admiration and thanks from the fans. However we must not stand still, we must continue to drive forward and strive to return to the PL where we belong.
FWIW just my thoughts.

Amazing how differently people can see things.

Holgate was a very good deal, and it was done fast despite other interest.

Johansen and Murphy were lauded on here when they arrived, and Johansen I’d say was successful. Murphy however was a waste of space and entirely the wrong personality, Montero was entirely pointless and our inability to bring a striker in in January certainly contributed to our undoing.

I don’t care that it took several months to bring in a manager. We got the right one, and that’s all any of us could ask. Had it not been for Downing we’d have ended up with Alex Neil, Jenkins was certainly pushing him. Shan did as good a job as anyone and I actually think we did a very thorough job given the circumstances. 


Moore’s sacking was unfortunate, but he’d been given the chance to get rid of Jones, and didn’t. After that, it was only going to end one way and we got rid of him a the right time. The Leeds/Sheff Utd defeats and the Ipswixh game + recent home form suggested we wouldn’t be in 4th much longer.

This summer we’ve signed excellently - the Willock signing is utterly bizarre but believe it is a permanent deal but one which had to dressed as a loan due to time constraints. I expected it’ll be made permanent in January as he’s been bought as part of our development team. 

Overall there’s been far more good than bad, and that’s all you can expect from these guys, and crucially he, Jenkins and Bilic seem to be getting on. So far he seems far more Ashworth than Burton!
Reply
#22
(09-30-2019, 03:43 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Luke Downing 1st transfer window Jan 2019 started off great - Holgate on the first day turned out to be an inspired signing filling our problematic right  full back problem. However Montero / Murphy / Johansen were not so great - Montero & Murphy were total rubbish and Johansen was unfit. They all came at the last minute and appeared to be desperation signings.
Our signing and selling of Sako was a joke. Considering Dowling has a team of 12 professionals working on new signings and contracts, this was poor and not what we needed at the time. Hence his reputation was tarnished. The removal of Darren could have been handled a lot better and the inability to select a new manager for months also reflected directly on Dowling. This may have been unfair, but that's life.
However all our latest signings (Bar Wllock) have been brilliant. Again credit to Dowling and Bilic who has certainly been instrumental in some of the signings.
While we continue to ride high the clubs management will receive the admiration and thanks from the fans. However we must not stand still, we must continue to drive forward and strive to return to the PL where we belong.
FWIW just my thoughts.

It’s almost as if people need time to settle into their roles before they can be judged. 

I imagine the pantwetters will keep this in mind before writing people off again in the future.
Reply
#23
(09-30-2019, 04:38 PM)OmarLittle Wrote:
(09-30-2019, 03:43 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Luke Downing 1st transfer window Jan 2019 started off great - Holgate on the first day turned out to be an inspired signing filling our problematic right  full back problem. However Montero / Murphy / Johansen were not so great - Montero & Murphy were total rubbish and Johansen was unfit. They all came at the last minute and appeared to be desperation signings.
Our signing and selling of Sako was a joke. Considering Dowling has a team of 12 professionals working on new signings and contracts, this was poor and not what we needed at the time. Hence his reputation was tarnished. The removal of Darren could have been handled a lot better and the inability to select a new manager for months also reflected directly on Dowling. This may have been unfair, but that's life.
However all our latest signings (Bar Wllock) have been brilliant. Again credit to Dowling and Bilic who has certainly been instrumental in some of the signings.
While we continue to ride high the clubs management will receive the admiration and thanks from the fans. However we must not stand still, we must continue to drive forward and strive to return to the PL where we belong.
FWIW just my thoughts.

It’s almost as if people need time to settle into their roles before they can be judged. 

I imagine the pantwetters will keep this in mind before writing people off again in the future.

In the rush to make a sweeping judgement, people are either unwilling or incapable of informing themselves of what the role of Sporting and Technical director encompasses.  The idea that you can design and implement a new strategic framework after only a few weeks in the jib is sheer madness.  Essentially, Dowling had to work off the hoof during his first couple of transfer windows and should be judged on this summer just gone.  So far so good.

As for the sacking of Moore and the subsequent recruitment of Bilic, though frustrating, it has ultimately been proven to be the correct decision.  There's no way Bilic or his ilk would have come in March 2019 or i'm sure Dowling would have recruited him.

As an aside, i'm glad we didn't get promoted under Shan.  We were in no way prepared for the Premiership.  We needed a couple of transfer windows to slowly rebuild a complete squad, a new collective identity.  Dowling and Bilic, after some delay, are finally doing that.
Reply
#24
(09-30-2019, 04:51 PM)WWHO Wrote:
(09-30-2019, 04:38 PM)OmarLittle Wrote:
(09-30-2019, 03:43 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Luke Downing 1st transfer window Jan 2019 started off great - Holgate on the first day turned out to be an inspired signing filling our problematic right  full back problem. However Montero / Murphy / Johansen were not so great - Montero & Murphy were total rubbish and Johansen was unfit. They all came at the last minute and appeared to be desperation signings.
Our signing and selling of Sako was a joke. Considering Dowling has a team of 12 professionals working on new signings and contracts, this was poor and not what we needed at the time. Hence his reputation was tarnished. The removal of Darren could have been handled a lot better and the inability to select a new manager for months also reflected directly on Dowling. This may have been unfair, but that's life.
However all our latest signings (Bar Wllock) have been brilliant. Again credit to Dowling and Bilic who has certainly been instrumental in some of the signings.
While we continue to ride high the clubs management will receive the admiration and thanks from the fans. However we must not stand still, we must continue to drive forward and strive to return to the PL where we belong.
FWIW just my thoughts.

It’s almost as if people need time to settle into their roles before they can be judged. 

I imagine the pantwetters will keep this in mind before writing people off again in the future.

In the rush to make a sweeping judgement, people are either unwilling or incapable of informing themselves of what the role of Sporting and Technical director encompasses.  The idea that you can design and implement a new strategic framework after only a few weeks in the jib is sheer madness.  Essentially, Dowling had to work off the hoof during his first couple of transfer windows and should be judged on this summer just gone.  So far so good.

As for the sacking of Moore and the subsequent recruitment of Bilic, though frustrating, it has ultimately been proven to be the correct decision.  There's no way Bilic or his ilk would have come in March 2019 or i'm sure Dowling would have recruited him.

As an aside, i'm glad we didn't get promoted under Shan.  We were in no way prepared for the Premiership.  We needed a couple of transfer windows to slowly rebuild a complete squad, a new collective identity.  Dowling and Bilic, after some delay, are finally doing that.

+1

I know you can't afford to pick and choose when you get promoted - especially with our owner's lack of interest and support - but promotion last season would have no doubt seen us hang onto JRod, Dawson and co. when we really needed the refresh we've undertaken this summer. 

I also doubt Edwards, Ferguson and co. would be getting the game time they're currently enjoying and I can see another scenario where we'd find ourselves in the Championship again a couple years down the line lamenting the youth players that weren't good enough for us starring elsewhere. 

I was far more annoyed Villa went up than we didn't.
Reply
#25
Our survival as a competitive team is dependent on money, the only reason to be in the PL is to receive the 100 million bonus and a guarantee'd
100 million parachute payments if we got relegated again. Tbh our games within the "Championship" IMO have created a hell of a lot more interest then the PL. We have changed the squad and given youth a chance, creating an exciting time for us all.
But back to reality we have to get back to the PL. Interestingly all the talk of China lifting the restrictions on spending money on overseas assets in September has been met with silence, so I will take it as read that it's more BS as I assumed it was to begin with.
Reply
#26
(09-30-2019, 05:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-30-2019, 04:51 PM)WWHO Wrote:
(09-30-2019, 04:38 PM)OmarLittle Wrote:
(09-30-2019, 03:43 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Luke Downing 1st transfer window Jan 2019 started off great - Holgate on the first day turned out to be an inspired signing filling our problematic right  full back problem. However Montero / Murphy / Johansen were not so great - Montero & Murphy were total rubbish and Johansen was unfit. They all came at the last minute and appeared to be desperation signings.
Our signing and selling of Sako was a joke. Considering Dowling has a team of 12 professionals working on new signings and contracts, this was poor and not what we needed at the time. Hence his reputation was tarnished. The removal of Darren could have been handled a lot better and the inability to select a new manager for months also reflected directly on Dowling. This may have been unfair, but that's life.
However all our latest signings (Bar Wllock) have been brilliant. Again credit to Dowling and Bilic who has certainly been instrumental in some of the signings.
While we continue to ride high the clubs management will receive the admiration and thanks from the fans. However we must not stand still, we must continue to drive forward and strive to return to the PL where we belong.
FWIW just my thoughts.

It’s almost as if people need time to settle into their roles before they can be judged. 

I imagine the pantwetters will keep this in mind before writing people off again in the future.

In the rush to make a sweeping judgement, people are either unwilling or incapable of informing themselves of what the role of Sporting and Technical director encompasses.  The idea that you can design and implement a new strategic framework after only a few weeks in the jib is sheer madness.  Essentially, Dowling had to work off the hoof during his first couple of transfer windows and should be judged on this summer just gone.  So far so good.

As for the sacking of Moore and the subsequent recruitment of Bilic, though frustrating, it has ultimately been proven to be the correct decision.  There's no way Bilic or his ilk would have come in March 2019 or i'm sure Dowling would have recruited him.

As an aside, i'm glad we didn't get promoted under Shan.  We were in no way prepared for the Premiership.  We needed a couple of transfer windows to slowly rebuild a complete squad, a new collective identity.  Dowling and Bilic, after some delay, are finally doing that.

+1

I know you can't afford to pick and choose when you get promoted - especially with our owner's lack of interest and support - but promotion last season would have no doubt seen us hang onto JRod, Dawson and co. when we really needed the refresh we've undertaken this summer. 

I also doubt Edwards, Ferguson and co. would be getting the game time they're currently enjoying and I can see another scenario where we'd find ourselves in the Championship again a couple years down the line lamenting the youth players that weren't good enough for us starring elsewhere. 

I was far more annoyed Villa went up than we didn't
.

Never a truer word spoken.
Reply
#27
(09-30-2019, 03:43 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Luke Downing 1st transfer window Jan 2019 started off great - Holgate on the first day turned out to be an inspired signing filling our problematic right  full back problem. However Montero / Murphy / Johansen were not so great - Montero & Murphy were total rubbish and Johansen was unfit. They all came at the last minute and appeared to be desperation signings.
Our signing and selling of Sako was a joke. Considering Dowling has a team of 12 professionals working on new signings and contracts, this was poor and not what we needed at the time. Hence his reputation was tarnished. The removal of Darren could have been handled a lot better and the inability to select a new manager for months also reflected directly on Dowling. This may have been unfair, but that's life.
However all our latest signings (Bar Wllock) have been brilliant. Again credit to Dowling and Bilic who has certainly been instrumental in some of the signings.
While we continue to ride high the clubs management will receive the admiration and thanks from the fans. However we must not stand still, we must continue to drive forward and strive to return to the PL where we belong.
FWIW just my thoughts.

Or Dowling just needed time to sort things out and a bit of patience rather than fans making nonsense up about how many permanent signings we should have made, Lepko’s sourest of grapes and the army of twatterati spreading rumour and conjecture as fact etc.
Reply
#28
(09-28-2019, 05:22 PM)Peachy Wrote: I know this bored only does moans about the club but this needs to be said.

Early days I know and no awards handed out until May but both Dowling and Bilic deserve huge credit imo.

We all knew after the play off defeat we were in for a horrible summer. We were all in the doldrums thinking of losing all our best players and loans and knowing how we've dealt with huge upheavals in the past with that terrible Burton summer spree.

Dowling had a huge task. Massive imo. His first task was to get the right manager and boy did he do that well. Secondly was once Bilic was in he needed to get last season's players out and get new, fresh young hungry players in.

We have bought very well. We have loaned well. Bilic has instilled camaraderie within the squad. You can tell they love it. All hugs before the game. All smiles. He doesn't rant or rave. His in game management is a revelation.

So all in all its a massive well done to both Dowling and Bilic on what has been achieved so far.

We are top and unbeaten and have still only just moved from 3rd to 4th gear. There is plenty of room for more growth and understanding to come. 

Given the task this summer i'm struggling to think if I could have expected any better.

Superb effort. Now let's go and push the fuck on.

Well done Albion.......

Everyone has played a blider and don't forget we tried to sign Gayle in addition but he turned us down. 

If we can get 11 points from the next 5 games we will on course.

(09-30-2019, 03:43 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Luke Downing 1st transfer window Jan 2019 started off great - Holgate on the first day turned out to be an inspired signing filling our problematic right  full back problem. However Montero / Murphy / Johansen were not so great - Montero & Murphy were total rubbish and Johansen was unfit. They all came at the last minute and appeared to be desperation signings.
Our signing and selling of Sako was a joke. Considering Dowling has a team of 12 professionals working on new signings and contracts, this was poor and not what we needed at the time. Hence his reputation was tarnished. The removal of Darren could have been handled a lot better and the inability to select a new manager for months also reflected directly on Dowling. This may have been unfair, but that's life.
However all our latest signings (Bar Wllock) have been brilliant. Again credit to Dowling and Bilic who has certainly been instrumental in some of the signings.
While we continue to ride high the clubs management will receive the admiration and thanks from the fans. However we must not stand still, we must continue to drive forward and strive to return to the PL where we belong.
FWIW just my thoughts.

Willock may yet prove to be a gem. Long season.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: