Suspended Parliament
#21
(08-28-2019, 04:17 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: hasnt parliament just been shut for over six weeks?

was there a rush from mps to keep it open over summer?

this whole brexit thing needs ending quickly.

gone on way to long now

It hasn't started yet. This will drag on for a generation.
Reply
#22
I'm still not convinced that it would be such a disaster if we were to leave with no deal - I guess only time will tell. My only concern re a no deal is what happens in Northern Ireland, and the implications it will no doubt have for the peace process and the good friday agreement - In all honesty most people just want closure of the whole business and as much as I dislike Boris he is doing what should have been done following the referendum, planning for a no deal exit whilst trying to negotiate the best deal possible from the eu.
Reply
#23
FFS! I've only just finished stock piling for a no deal Brexit. Now I have to do it again for a civil war.
Reply
#24
(08-29-2019, 08:20 AM)igorbalis Wrote: I'm still not convinced that it would be such a disaster if we were to leave with no deal - I guess only time will tell. My only concern re a no deal is what happens in Northern Ireland, and the implications it will no doubt have for the peace process and the good friday agreement - In all honesty most people just want closure of the whole business and as much as I dislike Boris he is doing what should have been done following the referendum, planning for a no deal exit whilst trying to negotiate the best deal possible from the eu.

There’s no such thing as a no deal Brexit at some point unless we are going to trade with our BIGGEST trading partner on WTO rules for decades we will have to negotiate a deal. The idea we hold the best hand if this happens is nonsense. What are the benefits of leaving without a deal?
Reply
#25
(08-29-2019, 08:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 08:20 AM)igorbalis Wrote: I'm still not convinced that it would be such a disaster if we were to leave with no deal - I guess only time will tell. My only concern re a no deal is what happens in Northern Ireland, and the implications it will no doubt have for the peace process and the good friday agreement - In all honesty most people just want closure of the whole business and as much as I dislike Boris he is doing what should have been done following the referendum, planning for a no deal exit whilst trying to negotiate the best deal possible from the eu.

There’s no such thing as a no deal Brexit at some point unless we are going to trade with our BIGGEST trading partner on WTO rules for decades we will have to negotiate a deal. The idea we hold the best hand if this happens is nonsense. What are the benefits of leaving without a deal?

1. We are not tied into a backstop that we cannot exit unilaterally - which is arguably illegal on the basis of the decision of the ECJ in Wightman, where the ECJ was at pains to point-out that unilateral withdrawal from Treaty mechanisms is a right of a sovereign state

2. We are not subject to ECJ jurisdiction within the UK (albeit vicariously)

3. We are mot subject to EU laws that we have had no role in shaping

4. It evades the restrictions May agreed in our our future trade deals

5. It doesn't violate the GFA which the backstop arguable does as it alters the constitutional status of Northern Ireland in relation to the rest of the UK without consent of the NI people. (Incidentally, while no-one wants to see a border any more than currently exists across Ireland, there is no commitment in the GFA on any border type.)
Reply
#26
An observation on remainers and their affinity with democracy and respect for the constitution:

AC Grayling and MEPs meet EU leaders to tell them to make negotiation as hard as possible for the UK - silence from remainers

Some remainers want a second referendum to overturn the previous one before implementation - silence from remainers

Bercow ignores centuries of Parliamentary procedure and the advice of his clerks to allow amendments to a Government business motion - silence from remainers

Backbench MPs, Grieve et al, try to usurp the functions of Government and somehow coordinate and negotiate the UK's exit (or not) - silence from remainers

Remain MPs consider the idea of sending the Queen to the next EU summit as Head of State - silence from remainers

Caroline Lucas says that there is no mandate for Boris Johnson or leaving without a deal but suggests her alternative all-female Cabinet, which really does have no mandate - silence from remainers

Remain MPs seek to install Ken Clarke as PM in a 'Government of national unity' even though it seems that only remain would be represented - silence from remainers

Remain MPs like Caroline Lucas and Jo Swanson say they want a second referendum as a 'final say' but then admit that they won't accept a leave verdict. Therefore it's only a 'final say' if remain wins and remain only has to win once, but even winning twice isn't enough for leave - silence from remainers

Remain MPs say they will set-up an alternative HoC. Not only would this have no legitimacy or power, that really would be a coup attempt. Silence from remainers

Boris Johnson takes a course of action which leads to 3 fewer sitting days. John Major prorogued in 1997 for way longer, it's not unprecedented. Remainers: "OH MY GOD!! IT'S A COUP!!!".
Reply
#27
(08-29-2019, 09:57 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 08:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 08:20 AM)igorbalis Wrote: I'm still not convinced that it would be such a disaster if we were to leave with no deal - I guess only time will tell. My only concern re a no deal is what happens in Northern Ireland, and the implications it will no doubt have for the peace process and the good friday agreement - In all honesty most people just want closure of the whole business and as much as I dislike Boris he is doing what should have been done following the referendum, planning for a no deal exit whilst trying to negotiate the best deal possible from the eu.

There’s no such thing as a no deal Brexit at some point unless we are going to trade with our BIGGEST trading partner on WTO rules for decades we will have to negotiate a deal. The idea we hold the best hand if this happens is nonsense. What are the benefits of leaving without a deal?

1. We are not tied into a backstop that we cannot exit unilaterally - which is arguably illegal on the basis of the decision of the ECJ in Wightman, where the ECJ was at pains to point-out that unilateral withdrawal from Treaty mechanisms is a right of a sovereign state

2. We are not subject to ECJ jurisdiction within the UK (albeit vicariously)

3. We are mot subject to EU laws that we have had no role in shaping

4. It evades the restrictions May agreed in our our future trade deals

5. It doesn't violate the GFA which the backstop arguable does as it alters the constitutional status of Northern Ireland in relation to the rest of the UK without consent of the NI people. (Incidentally, while no-one wants to see a border any more than currently exists across Ireland, there is no commitment in the GFA on any border type.)

1. The backstop is an insurance policy designed to skirt around the delicate situation of the Irish border, and if a viable proposal on how to manage the border is put forward and implemented then the backstop is redundant

2. Canada is subject to ECJ jurisdiction through the CETA court

3. Do you understand how trade deals work? We will be subject to EU legislation through any trade deal and won't be able to shape it without being in the EU. This is the same with literally every trade deal

4. The political declaration in the withdrawal agreement is not a guarantee, it is a plan and subject to change as it is a separate document

5. We will need to put security forces to manage a customs border between NI and Ireland if we were trading with the EU on WTO rules unless we decide to do no customs checks at all with anyone (bad idea) and that violates the GFA.

You can't have your cake and eat it.
Reply
#28
(08-29-2019, 09:57 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote: 1. We are not tied into a backstop that we cannot exit unilaterally - which is arguably illegal on the basis of the decision of the ECJ in Wightman, where the ECJ was at pains to point-out that unilateral withdrawal from Treaty mechanisms is a right of a sovereign state

2. We are not subject to ECJ jurisdiction within the UK (albeit vicariously)

3. We are mot subject to EU laws that we have had no role in shaping

4. It evades the restrictions May agreed in our our future trade deals

5. It doesn't violate the GFA which the backstop arguable does as it alters the constitutional status of Northern Ireland in relation to the rest of the UK without consent of the NI people. (Incidentally, while no-one wants to see a border any more than currently exists across Ireland, there is no commitment in the GFA on any border type.)

1. How are you planning to manage the border in Ireland then? The backstop is simply and insurance policy that if a solution isn't in place then we know how to complete cross-border trade. According to Boris it's simple, he's just a bit vague on the detail - if he can show the solution the backstop missue goes away.

2. What ECJ rulings are you unhappy about specifically. Brexiteers are a bit vague on that point.

3. Which laws that the EU have imposed are you unhappy about? Brexiteers are a bit vague on that point. 

4. What restrictions? You mean a deal that would be in place that we have to renegotiate anyway now.

5. See point 1 - no one wants a border, but if we don't have EU trade rules then there has to be some way of measuring what is entering and leaving the UK to avoid any backdoor into the country.

Lot's of words from another brexiteer but no real detail - you've had 3 years to get to an answer and failed and your way forward is have no rules in place let's just go for it, what could possibly go wrong.
Reply
#29
(08-29-2019, 10:08 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote: Boris Johnson takes a course of action which leads to 3 fewer sitting days. John Major prorogued in 1997 for way longer, it's not unprecedented. Remainers: "OH MY GOD!! IT'S A COUP!!!".

This would be the longest proroguing of parliament in 40 years (planned to be 5 weeks by Boris, was previously 3 weeks with the usual being less than a week), longer than Major's (15 days, 24th March to 7th April). That is a bare faced lie, the rest of your post is opinionated rubbish.
Reply
#30
(08-29-2019, 10:26 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:08 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote: Boris Johnson takes a course of action which leads to 3 fewer sitting days. John Major prorogued in 1997 for way longer, it's not unprecedented. Remainers: "OH MY GOD!! IT'S A COUP!!!".

This would be the longest proroguing of parliament in 40 years (planned to be 5 weeks by Boris, was previously 3 weeks with the usual being less than a week), longer than Major's (15 days, 24th March to 7th April). That is a bare faced lie, the rest of your post is opinionated rubbish.

Well done BB, I read it and couldn't be arsed to even respond - it's just more bullshit from the leave at all costs camp. It would help if Boris just said what everyone knows is the reasoning and ballsed it out, instead he hides like a cheeky schoolboy.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: