Rogers FFS
#21
(07-08-2019, 03:33 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I'm not sure that Harrison leaving has been a catalyst, after all we seemed to lose the starlets on a regular basis when he was running it. We're just a victim of our own success.

That said the current levels of compo are a joke. I guess at least with Rogers we'll agree something worthwhile, rather than the 1 month of J Rod's wages that we'll get for Barry.

I think ALL Academy transfers should have an automatic 25% sell on clause added, as well as a minimum of £100k per year that the player was at the club, irrespective of whether it's abroad or UK based.

As well as an automatic sell on clause I think that they should have to pay an additional fee if the player has not played a minimum number of 1st team games by a certain age. That way they will only sign players that they have a genuine interest in and not just stockpile players or flog them on for a profit. Lets be honest if Rogers goes to City and fails to make the grade then they will sell him for more than the compensation that we will get now so its a no lose situation for them.
Reply
#22
Do the clubs below us even have academies? I honestly don't know.

On that note, don't the big boys have academies too? Surely they must have some disgruntled decent kids knocking about who are annoyed at their chances being restricted by the kids that the clubs are poaching?

(07-08-2019, 03:43 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(07-08-2019, 03:33 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I'm not sure that Harrison leaving has been a catalyst, after all we seemed to lose the starlets on a regular basis when he was running it. We're just a victim of our own success.

That said the current levels of compo are a joke. I guess at least with Rogers we'll agree something worthwhile, rather than the 1 month of J Rod's wages that we'll get for Barry.

I think ALL Academy transfers should have an automatic 25% sell on clause added, as well as a minimum of £100k per year that the player was at the club, irrespective of whether it's abroad or UK based.

As well as an automatic sell on clause I think that they should have to pay an additional fee if the player has not played a minimum number of 1st team games by a certain age. That way they will only sign players that they have a genuine interest in and not just stockpile players or flog them on for a profit. Lets be honest if Rogers goes to City and fails to make the grade then they will see him for more than the compensation that we will get now so its a no lose situation for them.

Aye a great idea, trouble is, it's the big clubs that make all the rules.
Reply
#23
(07-08-2019, 03:42 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(07-08-2019, 03:37 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: There is no deterrent for the big clubs to just take all the best players. It costs them next to nothing and they have everything to gain and nothing to lose. 

It is like me being given access to the Playboy mansion for a £1. I can have a crack on all the women in there that look good. Some will turn out to be shite, some will be ok and now and then one will be fantastic  Big Grin

Ahhh, but the Bunnies would still have to be consenting to your advances! Seems our youths all like the advances of the big boys!

They would be paying me the £1  Tongue
Reply
#24
Time to close the Academy , doing all the work for no return makes no sense

We all slagged JP off but what he said a few seasons ago is all coming home to roost

Let the big 6 run academies , and leave the rest of us to just fight for their cast offs.
Reply
#25
How disappointing - Seriously thinking what's the point in the academy, and with modern day football in general. I was hoping one of the benefits of staying down was seeing some of the younger players get more of a chance, and seeing them develop. It looks like we've now lost two of our brightest hopes withn a couple of days. I get that if they progress within our first team, we'd end up eventualy having to sell, but not getting an opportunity to see them develop even for a few games is really disappointing.

Unfortunately money talks, and we just can't compete with the big boys, even an offer of first team football isn't cutting it, with wages that other teams are offering. Let's hope we get a fair offer for Rogers, perhaps a deal including add ons, a sell on clause and a season loan for Aguero...
Reply
#26
(07-08-2019, 03:45 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(07-08-2019, 03:42 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(07-08-2019, 03:37 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: There is no deterrent for the big clubs to just take all the best players. It costs them next to nothing and they have everything to gain and nothing to lose. 

It is like me being given access to the Playboy mansion for a £1. I can have a crack on all the women in there that look good. Some will turn out to be shite, some will be ok and now and then one will be fantastic  Big Grin

Ahhh, but the Bunnies would still have to be consenting to your advances! Seems our youths all like the advances of the big boys!

They would be paying me the £1  Tongue

Ahhh got ya! My mistake Smile I'll tell them they can do me for just 50p!
Reply
#27
You cannot blame the Barry's and Rogers for moving to bigger and better clubs. We have to actually praise our Academy not shut it. They are producing some fantastic talent. Losing them is a blow, but we need to do the same go and raid others. This is football guys we need to wake up. It's no longer a game.
Reply
#28
Point is Remi...Morgan is lifelong WBA fan, as are his parents. If we can’t keep morgan we have zero chance with anyone else.

The only Academy player to show any loyalty to wba has been Leko. Chelsea, Man United wanted him when he was 16. He turned them down to stay here, hence why I stand up for him so much
Reply
#29
(07-08-2019, 03:57 PM)Super_Slav Wrote: Point is Remi...Morgan is lifelong WBA fan, as are his parents. If we can’t keep morgan we have zero chance with anyone else.

The only Academy player to show any loyalty to wba has been Leko. Chelsea, Man United wanted him when he was 16. He turned them down to stay here, hence why I stand up for him so much

Loyalty can be purchased and or sold in a business. Like I said football is not a game.
Reply
#30
Pathetic fred imvhfo.

Losing Tyler Roberts to Leeds was a bigger blow as he was getting very close and now in hindsight wouldve likely been playing games for us.

These two are well beyond our control and it's very clear there needs to be a rule change rather then throwing in the hat or the giving up.

Harper just signed a three year contract. Edwards won us a game last season. Field has been off playing with England this summer.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)