How did it come to this?
#21
Can ChatGPT explain why you think that the minimum wage for under 18s and apprentices (£8/hour) is the same as the minimum wage for someone over 21 (£12.71/hour)
Reply
#22
(05-07-2026, 07:45 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And you'll have to explain to me how the RRA means 'a whole cohort of low income and benefit dependant tenants' are being locked out.

It's very simple. There's no longer a simple summary eviction process via S21. We have used that previously rather than getting a court order for a non-payer which could take a year and be even more expensive, it also prevented the tenant receiving a CCJ.

So, when you have an average of 8 applicants for every property within the first week or two we, and every other landlord apparently, have now increased affordability criteria (we're 30x monthly rent) plus we're demanding a homeowner guarantor. We will vet prospective tenants even more rigorously than we already do. 

Non payers will be pursued through the court resulting in a CCJ which means no landlord will touch them in future. Those failing affordability criteria include a huge number of those served a S21 before 1st May - they're in limbo and there are thousands of them.
Reply
#23
(05-07-2026, 08:55 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-07-2026, 08:14 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And what or who is the solution Dekka. I’ve asked dozens of times who you think should become the leader and what policies they will bring to solve the problems but tumbleweed every time.

I don’t want to upset you either but I won’t be voting Labour tonight if that helps you understand my ‘blind allegiance’

And Arf, I’ve enabled Reform and Greens. A real loff with that one

When I say you, I meant those who continue to believe and defend Starmer as a leader and his blue Labour policies. Blaming immigrants and the disabled has pushed those on the right towards Reform and those who dislike the right of centre ‘message’ that Labour pushed for their first year in charge at least have headed to the Greens. 

I had a ‘loff’ when you declared I was ruining your children’s future for defending the disabled.

You and I agree on the disabled, you just don't feel the need to put some controls around the funding of those in need because you don't believe, despite many examples and evidence based information made available, that there is any abuse in the system.

I'm still waiting for that alternative that you think will do a better job. Focus on this line of the question Dekka instead of continuously moaning about everything and expecting everyone else to provide the solutions.
Reply
#24
(05-07-2026, 08:58 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Can ChatGPT explain why you think that the minimum wage for under 18s and apprentices (£8/hour) is the same as the minimum wage for someone over 21 (£12.71/hour)

It's £10.85 for 18-20 year olds. A premium of less than £2 is well worth paying for experience. Snaggletooth wants £15 for everyone.
Reply
#25
(05-07-2026, 08:58 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-07-2026, 07:45 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And you'll have to explain to me how the RRA means 'a whole cohort of low income and benefit dependant tenants' are being locked out.

It's very simple. There's no longer a simple summary eviction process via S21. We have used that previously rather than getting a court order for a non-payer which could take a year and be even more expensive, it also prevented the tenant receiving a CCJ.

So, when you have an average of 8 applicants for every property within the first week or two we, and every other landlord apparently, have now increased affordability criteria (we're 30x monthly rent) plus we're demanding a homeowner guarantor. We will vet prospective tenants even more rigorously than we already do. 

Non payers will be pursued through the court resulting in a CCJ which means no landlord will touch them in future. Those failing affordability criteria include a huge number of those served a S21 before 1st May - they're in limbo and there are thousands of them.

So market forces are giving the landlord more choice. In any of the choices you give there, where there are 8 applicants for every property, why wouldn't you vet prospective tenants and choose the best option?

(05-07-2026, 09:01 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-07-2026, 08:58 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Can ChatGPT explain why you think that the minimum wage for under 18s and apprentices (£8/hour) is the same as the minimum wage for someone over 21 (£12.71/hour)

It's £10.85 for 18-20 year olds. A premium of less than £2 is well worth paying for experience. Snaggletooth wants £15 for everyone.

So not £12.71 then, and again market forces. If you can afford the extra £2 and the candidates are available why wouldn't you employ them (ironically after moaning you couldn't afford the NI rise as well)
Reply
#26
(05-07-2026, 09:01 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-07-2026, 08:55 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-07-2026, 08:14 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And what or who is the solution Dekka. I’ve asked dozens of times who you think should become the leader and what policies they will bring to solve the problems but tumbleweed every time.

I don’t want to upset you either but I won’t be voting Labour tonight if that helps you understand my ‘blind allegiance’

And Arf, I’ve enabled Reform and Greens. A real loff with that one

When I say you, I meant those who continue to believe and defend Starmer as a leader and his blue Labour policies. Blaming immigrants and the disabled has pushed those on the right towards Reform and those who dislike the right of centre ‘message’ that Labour pushed for their first year in charge at least have headed to the Greens. 

I had a ‘loff’ when you declared I was ruining your children’s future for defending the disabled.

You and I agree on the disabled, you just don't feel the need to put some controls around the funding of those in need because you don't believe, despite many examples and evidence based information made available, that there is any abuse in the system.

I'm still waiting for that alternative that you think will do a better job. Focus on this line of the question Dekka instead of continuously moaning about everything and expecting everyone else to provide the solutions.

Come on now B1, I said that the system needs reform and even gave examples of what I would do. What I disagreed with was Labour trying to pretend that their original cuts were ‘reform’. They hadn’t even consulted experts about how best to, it was simply a way to spare Reeves budget blushes. The ‘leak’ to the press was also unforgivably crass and mean spirited. 

Your assertion that their was widespread abuse of the system, hasn’t been backed up with any evidence, if there is go after them by all means. I trust the same if not more effort will be put into tax evasion and companies making huge profits paying their low paid employees better wages, and helping tackle the cost of living. There seems to be more effort chasing unpaid carers for going over their income ceiling by a few hundred quid than there is the latter. 

As for Labour ‘reforms’ I’m still waiting to see how they are going to get thousands of disabled people into jobs, when they have practically nothing in place to achieve this. Or a plan if they fail to.
Reply
#27
(05-07-2026, 09:04 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So market forces are giving the landlord more choice. In any of the choices you give there, where there are 8 applicants for every property, why wouldn't you vet prospective tenants and choose the best option?

The RRA and its effect on landlord incentives is giving low income tenants zero choice B1. We have taken a chance in the past knowing that we can summarily secure possession if we need to. That simply won't be case in future.

Perhaps you can explain to low income tenants why they will now be completely locked out of a shrinking market.

(05-07-2026, 09:04 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So not £12.71 then, and again market forces. If you can afford the extra £2 and the candidates are available why wouldn't you employ them (ironically after moaning you couldn't afford the NI rise as well)

Simply put, wage differentials need to be greater between those with / without experience and those with / without responsibility. Wage compression has reduced incentives to take on youg inexperienced workers and reduced employee incentives to take on additional responsibilities. Please don't mention market forces in relation to the minimum wage, it's a bit of an oxymoron.
Reply
#28
Proth's logic is that you would have an empty property rather than 'take a chance' on a tenant.

And I love the pay logic that you should be paying those with experience and responsibility the minimum wage that you can get away with.
Reply
#29
(05-07-2026, 09:35 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Proth's logic is that you would have an empty property rather than 'take a chance' on a tenant.

And I love the pay logic that you should be paying those with experience and responsibility the minimum wage that you can get away with.

Well, yes. What do you think all the S21s issued prior to May 1st were about? What do you think is happening to the size of the private rental market? What do you think the result will be for lower income tenants?

And erm, no. At the lower end of income distribution wage differentials need to be greater to incentivise employees to take on greater responsibility otherwise - why would they? Even the Unions recognise that.

Further up the scale another mate of mine mid 50s is going down to 4 days a week because it makes no sense for him to earn more than £100K.

I know you like to ignore the effect of policy on incentives. You have so much in common with most Labour MPs in that respect. It doesn't mean those (dis)incentives don't exist, or that individuals and firms act rationally when presented with them.
Reply
#30
Ah the old 100k barrier to earning more, apart from the fact he could put more into his pension pot to get below the threshold without too much effort. And if he doesn't need to put any more into his pension pot maybe he is comfortable to get a better work life balance - who would have thought that the unintended consequence of the threshold is that people get to live better lives eh?

Yes the income wage differential will be small if you decide to pay the absolute bare minimum that you can get away with. Here's an idea, pay those with responsibility and experience more rather than those without it less.

And another unintended consequence of the RRA is that more houses will be available to buy (and in theory in the numbers you are referencing) enough to drive prices down.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)