Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
And what do Mepham, Phillips and Taylor have in common? All ageing, all in their way down. It’s why we were so successful from Megson onwards until Ashworth left as we sought characters who wanted to go places and we offered them that opportunity.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Mepham and Phillips are 27/28, that's not ageing, that's being in your prime.
What has happened with the defence is a lot to do with the financial mess inherited from the last regime.
Palmer, Heggem, Bartley, Furlong, even Ajayi for me were all competent defenders at this level, and with Caleb Taylor developing, defence was a strength for us.
But our psr situation meant Palmer, Furlong, Heggem and Taylor had to be sold, and time and fitness had caught up with Bartley and Ajayi.
Was there too much to do in the summer window, maybe, but we haven't recruited well. Only Campbell has been anywhere near a success. Gilchrist hasto be better than he is showing...but where would you play him. Why him and Campbell?
As for Phillips and Mepham. Phillips is a no nonsense championship defender, great if your primary consideration is survival. Mepham has a track record at this level, but does he flatter to deceive? But I would imagine he is an expensive option, and it hasn't worked out at all...who would want to take him off our hands, who could afford to?
Maybe there is redemption for both of them, football is fickle and it can go up as well as down, so a couple of decent performances/results will see confidence restored and performances improve. But even then, before we are good enough to go for automatic promotion we would need to recruit again in central defence.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
We were spoiled with our defensive options for a number of years. Some just refused to admit it.
We also had Carlos Corberan.
Posts: 1,020
Threads: 31
Joined: Nov 2025
Reputation:
3
01-22-2026, 08:14 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-22-2026, 08:30 AM by HeggebøsBarnDoor.)
Campbell, Gilchrist, Mepham, Taylor and Phillips and the defence has never looked so fragile. It's a terrible state of affairs and looks like we spunked £5m-10m up the wall.
Out of all of these Mepham should be the one leading by example. He played for Sunderland in a promotion wining side and is well proven at Championship level. He also had premier league experience with Brentford and Bournemouth - this is why i'm so annoyed with his individual performances and inability to put a shift it. Perhaps he wanted to stay at Sunderland in the prem and resents playing in a Champ relegation battle who knows.
But you would hope a player like this would dig in and get the defence through instead of bottling tackles and putting pressure on the rest of the back line via his stray passing.
Then there's the dynamic with Phillips. Mepham is used to playing with other defenders such O'Nien, Ballard who are not shrinking violets - Phillips seems different and this could be one of the reasons why it just doesn't work in terms of them gelling together.
Definitely want to see him dropped for a bit for Campbell or Banter Bielik.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
I pin the blame for this seasons defensive frailties on the fact we regularly line up with a RB wearing 6, 2 and 3 at CB and a LB wearing 4. Makes me so cross even before we've kicked off.