Fuck off Mason.
#21
He does seem to be a nice guy, and I think he really cares. But..he seems slow to learn, or overwhelmed with the task. The most naive of us wouldn’t put Wildsmith in over Griffiths, or constantly mess with the back four. He also leaves substitutions far too late to have any real impact, (I’m guessing he’s taking too long to figure out his options after his game plan turns to shit), and then makes baffling subs when he does! He may in time become a good coach, but it won’t be at West Brom. He shouldn’t be learning his trade with our team on match days.
Reply
#22
(12-10-2025, 07:50 AM)Pf1ster Wrote: or overwhelmed with the task. 

It is a tough job, I can't see a seasoned vet that's actually a really good manager getting this set of players into the play-offs, we're just not very good. 

We're certainly better than recent performances, however, and it's worrying how bad we're playing. All I'm saying is is that you cor polish a turd.
Reply
#23
When Bruce had us bottom of the league everyone was saying it was a terrible squad, poor attitude, no fight, individual errors and we were in a right mess. Along comes a proper manager…

We’re not play-off shoe-ins but we should be challenging the top 6 over 46 games, we’re currently in 16th on a terrible run with no sign of it getting better.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#24
(12-10-2025, 08:05 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: When Bruce had us bottom of the league everyone was saying it was a terrible squad, poor attitude, no fight, individual errors and we were in a right mess.  Along comes a proper manager…

We’re not play-off shoe-ins but we should be challenging the top 6 over 46 games, we’re currently in 16th on a terrible run with no sign of it getting better.

Players are players no matter what club they're at.
Another way of looking at why we are where we are is lto ook at other clubs who IMO certainly have a worse set of players then we do 
Millwall, Stoke aren't blessed with a squad full of mega stars but are still performing way better then we are. It can only be how well they are managed or how poorly we are 
Good managers can get the best out of players or adopt a system of play that suits them. We are not capable of either. Asante at Cov is scoring goals for us he tried but never looked as though he was going to be prolific. Why is that. 
We need a manager who is organised and can the most out of the players we've got. Can Mason do that. Well it's a big NO he can't. So why is he still here is the question. It's down to Nestor and our owners.
Reply
#25
I don't accept the squad isn't very good calls at all.

The team has weaknesses for sure but they beat Stoke away, went 2-0 up at Cov and outplayed Southampton in the second half...now wether that was because the Saints had given up or because we improved is questionable.

But - the team is underperforming for where it should be.

Watching Masons interview I did question whether it's his job to restore belief or to give them an absolute pasting for that shit first half. An Alex Ferguson boot kicked across the changing room at SIJ type rant. Could be the guys too nice. Simple mistakes are costing the team, maybe the team needs a rocket highlighting this type of shit is not acceptable at WBA....even more so away in front of travelling fans that have paid good money to watch the team fuck up basics.
Reply
#26
It's both, isn't it? The squad isn't particularly good, but neither is Mason doing a particularly good job. I would expect a better manager to get a lot more out of the team, make us more difficult to beat and cut out the basic errors that lead to us conceding sloppy goals, but I don't think a good manager instantly makes us play-off contenders.

The squad is limited. It's doesn't have great depth and is short of real quality. It is better than what we're currently seeing, however.

If you want to defend Mason and say the squad isn't great - you're correct.

If you want to attack Mason and suggest the squad is better than what we're getting out of it ATM - you're correct.
Reply
#27
(12-10-2025, 07:04 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I can't bring myself to tell him to fuck off. He seems a reasonable chap and I believe he's trying he's just got far too much to learn.

Nestor too bears the brunt of my ire as his two appointments in the last 12 months have put us back in the position of needed another miracle of Corberan proportions.

Agreed. Mason seems a genuine good bloke, who really wants to do well. But way out of his depth. I'm starting to feel sorry for the guy. Lets just sort out a 'mutual consent' deal, admit the mistake and move on.
Reply
#28
Most seasons i would agree with you, not this one.

I think it is entirely possible that under different leadership we could have an extra 10 points with a better set up, better subs, less stupid decisions (such as Wildsmith in goal) and less individual errors - and be higher up the league as a result i.e. play off spot.

Mason is a nice guy and it would be great for it to work out for him but it's getting harder for that to happen by the day. IDK - I just feel he's got to get something about him asap, a sense of authority, an urgency, a portrayal of a guy who has a plan and knows what he's doing. The interview, whilst clear he's hurting, inspires little confidence that he's going to put it right next game.
Reply
#29
There's a lot of talk of inexperience with this manager and to a certain extent it's warranted but, Jesus, the bloke has been involved with top level football for most of his life. I'm still perplexed as to how he can't see 1) when his starting line-ups are wrongly balanced and 2) how he can't see that changes need to be made sooner rather than later to try and affect the game he's in charge of. I know I'm just repeating what's been said on here a thousand times already but he's had his leeway and even though extolling the virtues of patience now must have lost all of theirs.
Reply
#30
Things to ponder…

It has taken us weeks to find new managers
We have then chosen Mowbray and Mason

… why then have any faith that this time, more than any other time, we’ll get it right?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)