Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(10-29-2025, 11:28 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (10-29-2025, 11:25 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I didn't mind Pulis, he was exactly what we needed when he arrived and he laid the foundations for what should have been a long-term stint in the PL.
With better ownership we could have seized on the platform Pulis gave us and we could have gone on to something similar to Crystal Palace or Brentford. Wasn't Pulis' fault the owners at the time couldn't see this and had no ideas what they were doing.
Certainly a better manager than the likes of Bilic or Mowbray down here for me.
I think that’s a very rose-tinted view of it.
I have no doubts about Pulis’ ability to manage us. Or many other Premier League clubs for that matter, and he is indeed far more capable than any you mention. But when he lost his court case against Palace, and was faced with an enormous legal bill not to mention repayment of his seven-figure severance, the only way he saw fit to balance his books was by getting himself fired by us. So I think laying the foundations for him (given than he’d already pretty-much reassumed control over transfer activity by then) is completely a moot point.
This ! Pulis, ( and others, Allardyce, allegedly ) always are looking for money. Pulis has been taken to court over financial matters by about 4 clubs. Allardyce got the England job, but was still open to briefcases full of money from dodgy business men, I know the film of him talking to people about being an `advisor`, how to get around transfer rules, was a set up, but, he didn`t have to take the bait, an offer of a couple of hunfred grand, he is already wealthy.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(10-29-2025, 09:15 AM)Pontificator Wrote: You can't argue with the fact that he was our most succesful manager in over 45 years. Yes we played some dire football but he nearly got us into Europe. The football he played wasn't the best to watch but look at us now. Maybe if the board had backed him, bigged him up etc he wouldn't have behaved like he did towards the end. I believe he engineered his own demise and for that I haven't any time for him. I'll never forget that Chelsea game in '17.
Given the money he owned Crystal Palace and the legal costs associated with that I think it's almost certain that he needed to get sacked by Albion to pay that off. He's been very good at creating this 'honest, hard-working, just a regular kind of guy' persona which the media lap up but that whole court case just showed what a thoroughly deceitful individual he is. His latter period at the club is what makes me dislike him so much as up to spring 2017 I think anyone would largely consider he did a pretty good job for us no matter what you think of the quality of the football.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(10-29-2025, 11:35 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (10-29-2025, 09:15 AM)Pontificator Wrote: You can't argue with the fact that he was our most succesful manager in over 45 years. Yes we played some dire football but he nearly got us into Europe. The football he played wasn't the best to watch but look at us now. Maybe if the board had backed him, bigged him up etc he wouldn't have behaved like he did towards the end. I believe he engineered his own demise and for that I haven't any time for him. I'll never forget that Chelsea game in '17.
Given the money he owned Crystal Palace and the legal costs associated with that I think it's almost certain that he needed to get sacked by Albion to pay that off. He's been very good at creating this 'honest, hard-working, just a regular kind of guy' persona which the media lap up but that whole court case just showed what a thoroughly deceitful individual he is. His latter period at the club is what makes me dislike him so much as up to spring 2017 I think anyone would largely consider he did a pretty good job for us no matter what you think of the quality of the football.
This.
Posts: 7,715
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(10-29-2025, 11:07 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (10-29-2025, 10:32 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (10-29-2025, 10:23 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (10-29-2025, 09:15 AM)Pontificator Wrote: You can't argue with the fact that he was our most succesful manager in over 45 years. Yes we played some dire football but he nearly got us into Europe. The football he played wasn't the best to watch but look at us now. Maybe if the board had backed him, bigged him up etc he wouldn't have behaved like he did towards the end. I believe he engineered his own demise and for that I haven't any time for him. I'll never forget that Chelsea game in '17.
Someone else has argued it for me. Yes, it was stable while it lasted, but it’s this bit that’s the abiding memory for me; which allowed a rot to set in from which we still haven’t yet recovered.
Seasons last longer than 14 games. I’m sure someone had us higher than sixth at one point. Pulis perhaps could have eclipsed the finishes of Hodgson and Clark, but we’ll never know given his fondness for downing tools in February/March.
Of course he can’t be blamed for the failings of Pardew, sacking Big Dave, Fat Sam, appointing that moron Val on a 4-year deal, Bruce and Mowbray afterwards etc. But that Pulis era truly was the beginning of the end. Whilst Pardew will never, ever have been the right successor for anyone (let alone us), what Pulis left behind was a team who had completely forgotten how to play football at the expense of his ailing ideals. I don’t think Big Dave quite gets enough credit for doing his bit to change that (even if he did lose his way in listening too much to others).
All water under the bridge now, but the pendulum will one day swing again back in favour of teams that can defend set-pieces and play a bit as well. Nothing stays in vogue forever and I’m hardly surprised to see him milking this while it is.
Indeed it is water under the bridge but you cant argue with the facts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016%E2%80....C._season
Indeed you can’t.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012–13_We....C._season
3rd in beginning, 4th after the same period you claim.
Yep we were 4th when I got back from a holiday in Egypt the day of Swansea away at the end of November, went straight to the game as soon as I got home from Manchester Airport, got battered, then only won 2 of the next 11 league games including our annual defeat to Pulis and Stoke. From Swansea onwards we only picked up 23 more points from 25 games. Having gone into the game on 26 points from 13 games. It was a massive drop off, a borderline failure given the goals we had in the team and the reason Clarke isn't given a great deal of credit beyond taking Hodgson's team and making it worse once he started to bring in his own ideas.
The start to that season was incredible though 2ppg for 13 games in the top division.
Posts: 8,085
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
10-29-2025, 11:38 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-29-2025, 11:39 AM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Yes, I’m not denying that JRP didn’t capitalise on the situation. Both parties took the piss out of us, in the end. TP was the ‘safe paid of hands’ JRP needed at the helm while the sale went through, and once it had TP’s own fortunes had completely changed.
But, effective as it was for a while I’m not going to sit here and admire his work at WBA, because - whether he was allowed to or not - he completely shat on us. I also agree that he should have gone a lot sooner, but the erstwhile owner had his own motives. All in all, another reason why modern football is bollocks, really.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(10-29-2025, 11:07 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (10-29-2025, 10:32 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (10-29-2025, 10:23 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (10-29-2025, 09:15 AM)Pontificator Wrote: You can't argue with the fact that he was our most succesful manager in over 45 years. Yes we played some dire football but he nearly got us into Europe. The football he played wasn't the best to watch but look at us now. Maybe if the board had backed him, bigged him up etc he wouldn't have behaved like he did towards the end. I believe he engineered his own demise and for that I haven't any time for him. I'll never forget that Chelsea game in '17.
Someone else has argued it for me. Yes, it was stable while it lasted, but it’s this bit that’s the abiding memory for me; which allowed a rot to set in from which we still haven’t yet recovered.
Seasons last longer than 14 games. I’m sure someone had us higher than sixth at one point. Pulis perhaps could have eclipsed the finishes of Hodgson and Clark, but we’ll never know given his fondness for downing tools in February/March.
Of course he can’t be blamed for the failings of Pardew, sacking Big Dave, Fat Sam, appointing that moron Val on a 4-year deal, Bruce and Mowbray afterwards etc. But that Pulis era truly was the beginning of the end. Whilst Pardew will never, ever have been the right successor for anyone (let alone us), what Pulis left behind was a team who had completely forgotten how to play football at the expense of his ailing ideals. I don’t think Big Dave quite gets enough credit for doing his bit to change that (even if he did lose his way in listening too much to others).
All water under the bridge now, but the pendulum will one day swing again back in favour of teams that can defend set-pieces and play a bit as well. Nothing stays in vogue forever and I’m hardly surprised to see him milking this while it is.
Indeed it is water under the bridge but you cant argue with the facts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016%E2%80....C._season
Indeed you can’t.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012–13_We....C._season
3rd in beginning, 4th after the same period you claim.
Oh to have this team back. Halcyon days.
Posts: 7,715
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(10-29-2025, 12:19 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (10-29-2025, 11:07 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (10-29-2025, 10:32 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (10-29-2025, 10:23 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (10-29-2025, 09:15 AM)Pontificator Wrote: You can't argue with the fact that he was our most succesful manager in over 45 years. Yes we played some dire football but he nearly got us into Europe. The football he played wasn't the best to watch but look at us now. Maybe if the board had backed him, bigged him up etc he wouldn't have behaved like he did towards the end. I believe he engineered his own demise and for that I haven't any time for him. I'll never forget that Chelsea game in '17.
Someone else has argued it for me. Yes, it was stable while it lasted, but it’s this bit that’s the abiding memory for me; which allowed a rot to set in from which we still haven’t yet recovered.
Seasons last longer than 14 games. I’m sure someone had us higher than sixth at one point. Pulis perhaps could have eclipsed the finishes of Hodgson and Clark, but we’ll never know given his fondness for downing tools in February/March.
Of course he can’t be blamed for the failings of Pardew, sacking Big Dave, Fat Sam, appointing that moron Val on a 4-year deal, Bruce and Mowbray afterwards etc. But that Pulis era truly was the beginning of the end. Whilst Pardew will never, ever have been the right successor for anyone (let alone us), what Pulis left behind was a team who had completely forgotten how to play football at the expense of his ailing ideals. I don’t think Big Dave quite gets enough credit for doing his bit to change that (even if he did lose his way in listening too much to others).
All water under the bridge now, but the pendulum will one day swing again back in favour of teams that can defend set-pieces and play a bit as well. Nothing stays in vogue forever and I’m hardly surprised to see him milking this while it is.
Indeed it is water under the bridge but you cant argue with the facts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016%E2%80....C._season
Indeed you can’t.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012–13_We....C._season
3rd in beginning, 4th after the same period you claim.
Oh to have this team back. Halcyon days.
Certainly a halcyon 3 months.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
(10-29-2025, 10:00 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: I was a STH for 18 years up until Pulis, it wasn’t the football that did for me it was the toxicity his dull shit football created in the stands. A fight broke out between “ support the team” and “ Tony Pulis get out of our club” fans in the BRE right next to me, my daughter and my nephew and I thought I just can’t be arsed with this. Wonder how many others gave up during his regime? Still go, was there against Preston and will be there Saturday, but haven’t had a season ticket since Pulis.
This completely. There was a huge group of us met up in West Brom or JQ every game, many had been season ticket holders for donkeys years. Apart from my family, they all packed in under Pulis, more than a dozen in our group alone. Only 2 came back and then only as casual fans. I have not seen any other manager able to drive fans away at such a rate.
Plus Man from Delmonte's point about Pulis's ability to portray himself as a down to earth, hard working individual competing in the football world of wealthy owners and fancy foreign names, when we all know he has been dragged through court on a number of occasions for various improprieties.
Then there was the national perception of the Albion. We went from being the fondly remembered, free scoring club with Cyril, Laurie, Astle and Bomber into being the game you turn off the TV and go and paint the fence.
If anyone is in any doubt as to the character of TP, just speak to some of the staff as you go around The Hawthorns. The man would take the fillings out of your teeth if given a chance.
Posts: 3,622
Threads: 253
Joined: Apr 2025
Reputation:
1
10-29-2025, 12:42 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-29-2025, 12:45 PM by CIM.)
(10-29-2025, 12:28 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: (10-29-2025, 10:00 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: I was a STH for 18 years up until Pulis, it wasn’t the football that did for me it was the toxicity his dull shit football created in the stands. A fight broke out between “ support the team” and “ Tony Pulis get out of our club” fans in the BRE right next to me, my daughter and my nephew and I thought I just can’t be arsed with this. Wonder how many others gave up during his regime? Still go, was there against Preston and will be there Saturday, but haven’t had a season ticket since Pulis.
This completely. There was a huge group of us met up in West Brom or JQ every game, many had been season ticket holders for donkeys years. Apart from my family, they all packed in under Pulis, more than a dozen in our group alone. Only 2 came back and then only as casual fans. I have not seen any other manager able to drive fans away at such a rate.
Plus Man from Delmonte's point about Pulis's ability to portray himself as a down to earth, hard working individual competing in the football world of wealthy owners and fancy foreign names, when we all know he has been dragged through court on a number of occasions for various improprieties.
Then there was the national perception of the Albion. We went from being the fondly remembered, free scoring club with Cyril, Laurie, Astle and Bomber into being the game you turn off the TV and go and paint the fence.
If anyone is in any doubt as to the character of TP, just speak to some of the staff as you go around The Hawthorns. The man would take the fillings out of your teeth if given a chance.
Listened to couple of ex players like Brunty who said while they respected him they couldn't stand him as a person and he ruled by fear.
I guess similar could be said for Meggo, who ironically in his final season he had as his assistant
The only thing I miss about Pulis is our set pieces. We've been shite at corners mostly since he left.
Posts: 8,085
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
I also jacked in my ST during the Pulis era. It didn’t help much that I was flying all over the place for work at the time, but when home I just couldn’t be arsed to make the time. I reckon I only attended a handful of games the one season.
Meanwhile it became quite clear that our new owners were morons, and I didn’t renew again until they sold to Patel. I’m not sure I’d even be going again if my lad wasn’t quite so into it, but he loves going, and it’s better he grows up a Baggie than anything else.
|