BTA
#21
(10-22-2025, 08:39 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 08:09 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 07:21 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-21-2025, 09:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: [Image: Krabbenkutter_Ivonne_Pellworm_P5242390jm.JPG]

Ah, the FF Manoeuvre - say something stupid, get called on it and respond with “ah it was just a bit and you all fell for it!!!”

What exactly did I say that was stupid? A sarky comment about stats and board experts seems to have got peoples knickers in a twist. 

I have always been an advocate of BTA on work rate and contribution to a team, the fact he’s scoring regularly this season has only reaffirmed that he’s a far better player than some gave him credit for when he was with us. We certainly don’t have better at the club currently and yes he did offer a decent profit but I’m not sure he was the player to sell.

Don’t think anyone’s knickers are particularly twisted. Just an odd excuse for a snipe.

You’re not on the politics board now young man.

If nothing else this thread has allowed people to see a fishing trawler at work several times Wink
Reply
#22
Hold on, are you saying BTA is better than Maja, Dike, Heggebø, or Grant?

You're not saying that, seriously?! Big Grin

Get the fishing boat back out.
Reply
#23
Was I the only one not whooshed by Dekka's little joke? Chill out, some of you!

Great to see BTA adding goals to his game.
Reply
#24
BTA always reminded me of Din Woodman when he first arrived. Plenty of pace, endeavour, but couldn't hit a varn door with a banjo. He obviously worked on his finishing,and became a very good all round striker. I think the same route will follow BTA. He will probably score enough goals in this league to be classed as very good, but will fall short of being Premier League class
Reply
#25
(10-22-2025, 08:59 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Hold on, are you saying BTA is better than Maja, Dike, Heggebø, or Grant?

You're not saying that, seriously?! Big Grin

Get the fishing boat back out.

Dike cost millions that should have been spent on two or three players at the time (not hindsight) and has contributed less than BTA, not his fault but sadly currently true. 
Maja is again injury prone and contributed nothing at all for half a season, better? Not on current form. 
Grant scores more goals historically but imo doesn’t offer much if anymore than BTA does to a team.  
Heggebo is a very different type of player, both contribute a lot to teams, but difficult to compare, it would be a nice problem/option for our current manager to have them both playing for us. 

BTA is a seven out of ten player, who works hard and is rarely injured. He’s now either in a purple patch of goals or he’s in a team, with a manager getting the best out of him, either way if you asked me if I’d swap him for the players you mentioned, apart from Heggebo then yes. Not much point in having more talented players if they can’t stay fit.
Reply
#26
If someone said to me "do you want to swap BTA for Dike", I'd snap your hand off, but only due to fitness. When Dike is fit and healthy, there is absolutely no way BTA is on the same level.

I honestly wouldn't have BTA over Maja, Heggebø or Grant.

I really liked BTA, but other than the last few weeks he doesn't add goals to your team, he is a willing runner & causes havoc for the defending team, I don't think he adds to your team in a way that our current options do.

Want a hold up player, which BTA can do? You'd select Heggebø. 

Want a finisher to get you goals, which BTA can also do, as he's showing now, and showed at times here? You'd select Maja. 

Want a good around player that gets your team forward, works hard, and contributes defensively, which BTA can do? You'd select Grant. 

In short, he's kind of a jack if all trades but master of none sort of player. I have nothing but praise for BTA from his time here, and I'm buzzing for him to attain the success he is seeing now. But let's not put him on some pedestal and make outlandish claims just because he's scored a handful of goals early on this season, after a fairly fruitless 2024/25 campaign.
Reply
#27
(10-22-2025, 09:21 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: If someone said to me "do you want to swap BTA for Dike", I'd snap your hand off, but only due to fitness. When Dike is fit and healthy, there is absolutely no way BTA is on the same level.

I honestly wouldn't have BTA over Maja, Heggebø or Grant.

I really liked BTA, but other than the last few weeks he doesn't add goals to your team, he is a willing runner & causes havoc for the defending team, I don't think he adds to your team in a way that our current options do.

Want a hold up player, which BTA can do? You'd select Heggebø. 

Want a finisher to get you goals, which BTA can also do, as he's showing now, and showed at times here? You'd select Maja. 

Want a good around player that gets your team forward, works hard, and contributes defensively, which BTA can do? You'd select Grant. 

In short, he's kind of a jack if all trades but master of none sort of player. I have nothing but praise for BTA from his time here, and I'm buzzing for him to attain the success he is seeing now. But let's not put him on some pedestal and make outlandish claims just because he's scored a handful of goals early on this season, after a fairly fruitless 2024/25 campaign.

For once I’m with you Josh.
Reply
#28
It’s hardly a shock that a striker who plays in an attacking side that creates plenty of chances and scores more goals.
Reply
#29
(10-22-2025, 09:57 AM)Duffers Wrote: It’s hardly a shock that a striker who plays in an attacking side that creates plenty of chances and scores more goals.

Indeed. The top 3 scorers in the Championship currently are all Coventry players
Reply
#30
Isn’t that a manager playing to the strengths of the players he has?

(10-22-2025, 09:21 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: If someone said to me "do you want to swap BTA for Dike", I'd snap your hand off, but only due to fitness. When Dike is fit and healthy, there is absolutely no way BTA is on the same level.

I honestly wouldn't have BTA over Maja, Heggebø or Grant.

I really liked BTA, but other than the last few weeks he doesn't add goals to your team, he is a willing runner & causes havoc for the defending team, I don't think he adds to your team in a way that our current options do.

Want a hold up player, which BTA can do? You'd select Heggebø. 

Want a finisher to get you goals, which BTA can also do, as he's showing now, and showed at times here? You'd select Maja. 

Want a good around player that gets your team forward, works hard, and contributes defensively, which BTA can do? You'd select Grant. 

In short, he's kind of a jack if all trades but master of none sort of player. I have nothing but praise for BTA from his time here, and I'm buzzing for him to attain the success he is seeing now. But let's not put him on some pedestal and make outlandish claims just because he's scored a handful of goals early on this season, after a fairly fruitless 2024/25 campaign.

I haven’t made any outlandish claims. You can’t just judge a player on ability, when Dike or Maja play for more than half a season for us, putting in 7 out of ten performances consistently, rather than a 9/10 one week then a five the next then I’d take their natural ability over a player who is more consistent but with lesser ability.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: