NI Fund Surplus
#21
"They should be able to do what they want"

What can they do with no money?

"I don't know I'm just a bloke on a football message board"

This really has become student protest hour. "What do we want", "Something better", "When do we want it", "Now"
Reply
#22
(08-07-2025, 01:59 PM)baggy1 Wrote: "They should be able to do what they want"

What can they do with no money?

"I don't know I'm just a bloke on a football message board"

This really has become student protest hour. "What do we want", "Something better", "When do we want it", "Now"
That's about it. Further, the last time the red hot favourite to win an election pointed out he'd need to raise taxes, the tories swept to power from distinctly 2nd place. There's so little money in the tin, the tories didn't even bother trying to win.
Reply
#23
No money? Because of the self inflicted fiscal rules? Or because of the sclerotic growth? Or because they haven’t found any ways to tax the rich? Or because they’re about to piss £2bn up the wall in redundancy payments for public sector workers?

You say they have no money but really they have no competence, vision or guile. Poundshop tories.

Their majority means they don’t have to follow their manifesto to the word - as Reeves will prove imminently when she raises taxes.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#24
I know that it has gone under the radar but adding pensions into inheritance tax is taxing the 'rich'. And as for taxing 'wealth' - good luck with that, how wealth is measured is impossible to tax effectively and it's been tried and failed many times. It's a myth that the rich aren't being taxed.

And 'vision'? What would you do CC? "Don't ask me I'm just a bloke on a football message board", OK, what have you seen that would work as described by someone else?
Reply
#25
A manifesto is supposed to set out a vision of the next government, Labour made an extremely vague manifesto that snookered themselves because the party leadership are too scared to do anything and the ideas they do have they end up watering down or scrapping because, again, they're too scared to do anything.
Reply
#26
You mean like the Corbyn manifesto that I liked a lot but scared the public shitless because the press told them it would mean the world will end as we know it.
Reply
#27
(08-07-2025, 07:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You mean like the Corbyn manifesto that I liked a lot but scared the public shitless because the press told them it would mean the world will end as we know it.

Corbyn lost because of him not his policies, they were popular with the general public. I know it suits Labour centrists to think Starmer is the only way for Labour to go but frankly the Labour Party’s Tory tribute act is seeing them tank in the polls with a leader about as popular as a Wolves fan in the middle of the Brummie Road taking a dump. 

They are rolling out the red carpet to Reform at worst at best a hung parliament.
Reply
#28
It’s pointless to debate. It’s clear that if Labour had called for raised taxes before the election they would have lost votes in the same way that Corbyn lost votes. It’s lovely to think that there could be a better way but we have to stabilise before we can move further left. You moaning that things aren’t right is like moving into a new house and expecting it to be finished.
Reply
#29
(08-07-2025, 07:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You mean like the Corbyn manifesto that I liked a lot but scared the public shitless because the press told them it would mean the world will end as we know it.

No. The 2017 and 2019 Labour manifestos were complete bullshit. 

The 2001 Labour manifesto is a good start on what a solid Labour manifesto looks like, 23 years ago it was more bold on productivity investment and renewables growth than the one at the time where Britain has a major comparative advantage on renewables and a serious productive problem that needs addressing.
Reply
#30
(08-07-2025, 06:35 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I know that it has gone under the radar but adding pensions into inheritance tax is taxing the 'rich'. And as for taxing 'wealth' - good luck with that, how wealth is measured is impossible to tax effectively and it's been tried and failed many times. It's a myth that the rich aren't being taxed.

And 'vision'? What would you do CC? "Don't ask me I'm just a bloke on a football message board", OK, what have you seen that would work as described by someone else?

You ask me what I'd do yet haven't read the bits where I complained about a) fiscal rules b) stagnant growth c)taxing the rich d) not paying £2bn in redundancy costs 

Have a guess where I think the army of politicians, advisors and civil servants should look.

"Good luck with taxing the rich" exposes you eloquently in one post. I'm starting to think you're a Protheroe Troll account - blindly loyal, politically and economically Conservative, accusing folk of 6th form politics... quack!
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)