Wenger's proposed change to offside rule.
#21
The most sensible approach for football in general is just to stick to the current rules and apply them. So that means tugging on a shirt in the area is a pen/free kick, obstruction when defenders are blocking attackers completely when letting the ball go out for a goal kick, goalies holding the ball for more than six seconds etc. what’s so fuggin hard about that?
Reply
#22
Fido knows
Reply
#23
(05-07-2025, 09:13 PM)Fido Wrote: The most sensible approach for football in general is just to stick to the current rules and apply them. So that means tugging on a shirt in the area is a pen/free kick, obstruction when defenders are blocking attackers completely when letting the ball go out for a goal kick, goalies holding the ball for more than six seconds etc. what’s so fuggin hard about that?

How much of a shirt tug is too much?

Blocking an attacker is allowed providing you're in playing distance of the ball, unless we're making it a non-contact sport and completely removing the ability of a player to use their body.

Goalies holding the ball is an easy one I'll give you that.
Reply
#24
(05-07-2025, 09:56 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-07-2025, 09:13 PM)Fido Wrote: The most sensible approach for football in general is just to stick to the current rules and apply them. So that means tugging on a shirt in the area is a pen/free kick, obstruction when defenders are blocking attackers completely when letting the ball go out for a goal kick, goalies holding the ball for more than six seconds etc. what’s so fuggin hard about that?

How much of a shirt tug is too much?

Blocking an attacker is allowed providing you're in playing distance of the ball, unless we're making it a non-contact sport and completely removing the ability of a player to use their body.

Goalies holding the ball is an easy one I'll give you that.

The first one should be zero tolerance, there’s no need for you pull a shirt although “collisions” are trickier, granted. I’d say use the same judgement in the penalty area for a foul as you would do anywhere else on the pitch. As for obstruction I can’t remember where I last saw that rule applied.
Reply
#25
Offside for me should only be about the feet. None of this offside for a little finger or a shirt sleeve nonsense. There is absolutely no advantage gained. If replay shows clear daylight between one of the attackers feet and the defender then it's offside. No daylight he's onside.

I hate seeing goals ruled out due to someones nose being offside. Unless it's Villa. But we all know that would get given anyway.....
Reply
#26
Remember the infamous Dirty Leeds game in 72?
Brown received the ball in his own half, so couldn't be offside.
Suggett was trotting back from well in their half, miles offside - but crucially not interfering with play.
So no offside given, quite correctly. Wouldn't be an issue today.
Ray Tinkler - a man ahead of his time.
Reply
#27
(05-08-2025, 07:09 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: Remember the infamous Dirty Leeds game in 72?
Brown received the ball in his own half, so couldn't be offside.
Suggett was trotting back from well in their half, miles offside - but crucially not interfering with play.
So no offside given, quite correctly. Wouldn't be an issue today.
Ray Tinkler - a man ahead of his time........

........... and still going at the age of 96  Cool .
Reply
#28
(05-08-2025, 07:09 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: Remember the infamous Dirty Leeds game in 72?
Brown received the ball in his own half, so couldn't be offside.
Suggett was trotting back from well in their half, miles offside - but crucially not interfering with play.
So no offside given, quite correctly. Wouldn't be an issue today.
Ray Tinkler - a man ahead of his time.

Wasn't an issue then (I nerded out on changes to the offsite law one day, specifically researching this matter) - but some Leeds fans still can't accept it, 50 years on...
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#29
What happens if the game is played at night?
Reply
#30
(05-08-2025, 06:43 AM)Peachy Wrote: Offside for me should only be about the feet. None of this offside for a little finger or a shirt sleeve nonsense. There is absolutely no advantage gained. If replay shows clear daylight between one of the attackers feet and the defender then it's offside. No daylight he's onside.

I hate seeing goals ruled out due to someones nose being offside. Unless it's Villa. But we all know that would get given anyway.....

Pedant alert, your finger can't be offside, no one, even under VAR has been given offside due to their finger.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: