Keeper scenario!?
#21
(02-13-2025, 07:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:29 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:18 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: We'd have lost last night with Palmer in goal. The GK position is not the issue.

Are we seriously writing off Wildsmith after two games, one of which he made two excellent saves to keep us in the game, which we went on to win!

He's been directly at fault for each of the last three goals we've conceded Josh.

That's not correct, is it. Even if it was, it's two games FFS. And are you conveniently ignoring the fact he kept us in the Sheffield U game with two superb saves?

It is correct. Go and watch the highlights. 

Sheff W - punched the ball straight back into danger.
Blackburn - threw the first in. Second cause chaos in the defence by coming, stopping and then retreating.

I've seen all 3 goals. I'm not sure he's at fault for either the Sheffield Wednesday goal (I can see why people see the initial save and see it fall to a striker and say it's poor 'keeping, but that initial save is a very good save, and it's on the defenders to not ball watch and stand still allowing a striker to have a free shot at goal) or the second Blackburn goal (hesitant, yes, but Blackburn had numbers, he didn't stand a chance, that goal is due to us giving the ball away too sloppily and not getting back quick enough. It was poor defending). I'd firmly point to the defence for both of those, rather than the GK. He should have done better for Blackburn's opener, granted. But that was a good finish from their point of view, too. 

Again, you have ignored the fact he had a good game v Wednesday and pulled off two very good saves to keep the score at 0-0 and then 1-0. Why won't you acknowledge that?

Don't get me wrong, I'd much prefer to have Griffiths between the sticks. I'm really not sure what Mowbray is playing at. That being said I'm not going to write off a GK who has had one good game and an average game in his first two games. That's ridiculous. 

There's plenty for Mowbray to work on. He's come into a very good team, has tried to tweak too much too fast, and we're looking far worse for it. Defeats to Plymouth, Boro and Blackburn, a win v the worst side I've seen at the Hawthorns for many a year, and a below par performance and a get-out-of-jail win v Wednesday. It's not encouraging, but he, of course, will need time to figure things out.
Reply
#22
(02-13-2025, 08:19 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:29 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:18 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: We'd have lost last night with Palmer in goal. The GK position is not the issue.

Are we seriously writing off Wildsmith after two games, one of which he made two excellent saves to keep us in the game, which we went on to win!

He's been directly at fault for each of the last three goals we've conceded Josh.

That's not correct, is it. Even if it was, it's two games FFS. And are you conveniently ignoring the fact he kept us in the Sheffield U game with two superb saves?

It is correct. Go and watch the highlights. 

Sheff W - punched the ball straight back into danger.
Blackburn - threw the first in. Second cause chaos in the defence by coming, stopping and then retreating.

I've seen all 3 goals. I'm not sure he's at fault for either the Sheffield Wednesday goal (I can see why people see the initial save and see it fall to a striker and say it's poor 'keeping, but that initial save is a very good save, and it's on the defenders to not ball watch and stand still allowing a striker to have a free shot at goal) or the second Blackburn goal (hesitant, yes, but Blackburn had numbers, he didn't stand a chance, that goal is due to us giving the ball away too sloppily and not getting back quick enough. It was poor defending). I'd firmly point to the defence for both of those, rather than the GK. He should have done better for Blackburn's opener, granted. But that was a good finish from their point of view, too. 

Again, you have ignored the fact he had a good game v Wednesday and pulled off two very good saves to keep the score at 0-0 and then 1-0. Why won't you acknowledge that?

Don't get me wrong, I'd much prefer to have Griffiths between the sticks. I'm really not sure what Mowbray is playing at. That being said I'm not going to write off a GK who has had one good game and an average game in his first two games. That's ridiculous. 

There's plenty for Mowbray to work on. He's come into a very good team, has tried to tweak too much too fast, and we're looking far worse for it. Defeats to Plymouth, Boro and Blackburn, a win v the worst side I've seen at the Hawthorns for many a year, and a below par performance and a get-out-of-jail win v Wednesday. It's not encouraging, but he, of course, will need time to figure things out.

Good saves mean nothing when you can't do the basics. Palmer was good because he rarely got the fundamentals wrong, not because he regularly made extraordinary saves.

Wildsmith is a fine number two, you can call on in emergencies for a couple of games a season. He's also paying the price now for the idiot in the dugout keeping him on the pitch when we have a young keeper who's been in the best form of his life rotting on the bench. Griffiths has to start on Saturday.
Reply
#23
Mowbray said when he came in referencing Caleb Taylor that he was going to rely on experience for the rest of the season. I can see him doing exactly the same with goalkeepers and sticking with the unconvincing Wildsmith over 'the kid'. I don't want to be too kneejerk here but already there have been certain decisions and attitudes which are worryingly reminiscent of Bruce.
Reply
#24
(02-13-2025, 08:26 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 08:19 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:29 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: He's been directly at fault for each of the last three goals we've conceded Josh.

That's not correct, is it. Even if it was, it's two games FFS. And are you conveniently ignoring the fact he kept us in the Sheffield U game with two superb saves?

It is correct. Go and watch the highlights. 

Sheff W - punched the ball straight back into danger.
Blackburn - threw the first in. Second cause chaos in the defence by coming, stopping and then retreating.

I've seen all 3 goals. I'm not sure he's at fault for either the Sheffield Wednesday goal (I can see why people see the initial save and see it fall to a striker and say it's poor 'keeping, but that initial save is a very good save, and it's on the defenders to not ball watch and stand still allowing a striker to have a free shot at goal) or the second Blackburn goal (hesitant, yes, but Blackburn had numbers, he didn't stand a chance, that goal is due to us giving the ball away too sloppily and not getting back quick enough. It was poor defending). I'd firmly point to the defence for both of those, rather than the GK. He should have done better for Blackburn's opener, granted. But that was a good finish from their point of view, too. 

Again, you have ignored the fact he had a good game v Wednesday and pulled off two very good saves to keep the score at 0-0 and then 1-0. Why won't you acknowledge that?

Don't get me wrong, I'd much prefer to have Griffiths between the sticks. I'm really not sure what Mowbray is playing at. That being said I'm not going to write off a GK who has had one good game and an average game in his first two games. That's ridiculous. 

There's plenty for Mowbray to work on. He's come into a very good team, has tried to tweak too much too fast, and we're looking far worse for it. Defeats to Plymouth, Boro and Blackburn, a win v the worst side I've seen at the Hawthorns for many a year, and a below par performance and a get-out-of-jail win v Wednesday. It's not encouraging, but he, of course, will need time to figure things out.

Griffiths has to start on Saturday.
I'd be surprised if he does. But I agree Griffiths should be our no.1. I don't understand Mowbray's decision there. But it is what it is. I don't think Wildsmith is as bad as people are making out.

(02-13-2025, 08:31 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: Mowbray said when he came in referencing Caleb Taylor that he was going to rely on experience for the rest of the season. I can see him doing exactly the same with goalkeepers and sticking with the unconvincing Wildsmith over 'the kid'. I don't want to be too kneejerk here but already there have been certain decisions and attitudes which are worryingly reminiscent of Bruce.

Wildsmith - 156 professional games (not including the two games for us, as I'm making this point about the decision to start him over Griffiths). 
Griffiths - 137 professional games. 

There really isn't much difference in experience between the two. You also need to factor in Griffiths has been playing, and playing very well, all season, while Wildsmith hasn't. It really is very much like Bruce playing Button over Palmer. 

I do agree about the bizarre decisions we've already seen from Mowbray. He deserves time to figure things out, and to write him off as a poor appointment is ridiculous, but I think there's some concerning signs at this very early stage.
Reply
#25
The warnings signs were there on Sat with Wildsmith - seemed rooted to his line and cost us the goal. It seemed like it was always going to be a case of how many points would he cost us before we switch to JG in a Button-type scenario.
Reply
#26
In a Mowbray team your defence is always going to be exposed and the keeper is a pivotal position and Wildsmith really isn’t the answer. He doesn’t command his area, the ball gets crossed in and he can’t or won’t claim the ball.
Reply
#27
Griffiths has now a heap of games under his belt. To add to this he's more physically imposing, than Wildsmith who is small by modern standards.

With a keeper it's more than saves, crosses etc, it's being vocal and spreading confidence in the team. I'm not sure with Palmer in goal we would have lost that last night.

I think we can't over read too much into last night though. It was just a night when the whole team were strangely flat.
Reply
#28
(02-12-2025, 10:57 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(02-12-2025, 10:54 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-12-2025, 10:50 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It's fine, he's the "senior pro" who's been in the squad as the first team number 2. He's had his go, and in both games he's been vulnerable and made errors.

Josh should be in on Saturday. But don't think he will.

After the two games we've seen from Wildsmith, there should rightly be serious questions of Mowbray if Griffiths doesn't start on Saturday.

(02-12-2025, 10:54 PM)MrBater Wrote: Just wait for the meltdown when JG turns out to be no / not much better.

How do you find out if the idiot manager doesn't put him on the pitch.

I'm going the last time he played for us and was dodgy as fuck. Just hoping he has improved a lot.

Congratulations, you proved why developing young players is pointless in fans eyes, you're making, an unfair judgment on a 21 year old 'keeper who played one game last season, played a few the year before that and generally did ok but was, shockingly, raw.

Do you expect kids to come in and be perfect and at the best they'll ever be straight away?
Reply
#29
According to this Joe has conceeded 90 goals in 66 championshp matches, with 17 clean sheets.
Not very good with stats meself though.     Rolleyes



https://footystats.org/players/england/joe-wildsmith
Reply
#30
A clean sheet in 25% of games isn't too bad, is it? (Actually asking, I've no idea what a bad or good % would be, but my initial thought is a clean sheet in around 25% of games played is OK?).

Also, he played for Derby and Sheffield Wednesday, teams struggling at the bottom, they're gonna concede more goals.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: