Mogga Transfers
#21
(01-20-2025, 08:50 PM)Boinger Wrote: Score out of 5

06/07
- Robert Koren. 5
- Dean Kiey.     4
- Sam Sodje.    2

07/08 (Near a whole new starting 11)
- Shelton Martis.  1
- Craig Beattie.  3
- Filipe Teixeira.   5
- Leon Barnett.  4
- Tininho.  1
- Boštjan Cesar.  1
- Carl Hoefkens.  2
- James Morrison.   5
- Pelé.  3
- Chris Brunt.   5
- Ishmael Miller.  4
- Bartosz Ślusarski.  2
- Michal Daněk.   1
- Roman Bednář.   3


08/09
- Luke Moore.    1
- Kim Do-heon.   3
- Gianni Zuiverloon.   3
- Graham Dorrans.    5
- Marek Čech.   3
- Scott Carson.    4
- Abdoulaye Méïté.    3
- Borja Valero (still out on loan at Mallorca).   2
- Jonas Olsson.    5
- Ryan Donk.   2
- Jay Simpson.    2
- Marc-Antoine Fortuné.    4
- Youssouf Mulumbu.     5
- Juan Carlos Menseguez.    1


My onions.

So a total of 94 out of 155...

More like 2/3 good, which ain't bad.
Reply
#22
(01-19-2025, 03:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-19-2025, 03:42 PM)Baggie Alan Wrote: Jara?

He tailgated me up the Queslett.

Hope you had some KY  handy
Reply
#23
Not sure this is the best way to judge them - I think it's better to look at the cost/the job they were brought in to do.

Freebies/Loans/<£500k
- Koren
- Sodje
- Kiely
- Martis
- Tininho
- Cesar
- Danek
- Donk
- Dorrans
- Simpson
- Molumbu
- Fortune
- Menseguez

Generally our loans and cheap singings were squad fillers that did a job (Martis, Sodje, Cesar), with some turning out to be absolute bargains. A couple players like Tininho and Danek never got on the pitch, but they were hardly ever signed to be first teamers.   

500k - £2m
- Beattie
- Tex
- Hoefkens
- Bednar
- Slusarski
- Miller
- Morrison
- Pele
- Do-heon
- Cech
- Meite
- Olsson

Slusarski aside, all of these signings played a part. Again they generally weren't signed signed as the big star and most filled their role more than adequately. We also found decent homes for them and made some money back on the sales. Generally effective squad evolution.

£2m+

- Barnett
- Brunt
- Moore
- Zuiverloon
- Carson
- Valero

The big signings were far more hit and miss - managed to bring in a couple of club legends, but also wasted a lot of money on Valero (admittedly we got our money back and he went on to be a top player) but Moore as a complete howler. Zuiverloon, Carson and Barnett all failed to deliver vs what we spent considering the value we found elsewhere.

Overall, I'd say it was one of our more successful periods in the market. We identified the right profile of player and had a good global remit, if we can recreate the hit rate we got in the late noughties the firesale shouldn't give too many concerns!
Reply
#24
Added in the transfer fees / reported values in the OP.
Reply
#25
Zuiverloon one of our strangest ever signings. Looked like a world beater for a few months, then turned into Graham Harbey
Reply
#26
£32,165,000 wow

Average fee for the 20 we bought was £1,608,250

That drops the scores a bit, but it was very different financial times. Heck Villa would spunk £30m on a one legged rocking horse from Everton to sort out FFP these days.
Reply
#27
(01-21-2025, 12:04 PM)MrBater Wrote: £32,165,000 wow

Average fee for the 20 we bought was £1,608,250

That drops the scores a bit, but it was very different financial times. Heck Villa would spunk £30m on a one legged rocking horse from Everton to sort out FFP these days.

Zuvi is still available.
Reply
#28
Hoefkens too low, should be 3.
Carson too high, should be 3 also.
Luke Moore too high.
Reply
#29
(01-21-2025, 12:09 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: Luke Moore too high.

Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: