Surprise
#21
(07-29-2024, 06:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: If the economic terrorists hadn't committed economic terrorism then this £20bn hole would not exist, but they did so it does. Your blame should be squared solely at the Tory front bench who directed Treasury officials to withhold information from the OBR so this hole would only be able to come to light after the General Election.

Arf. You could fill your £20bn "hole" by simply reversing the NI cut.

Economic terrorism. Oh my days. They've been chucking money at every one of us for the thick end of a decade - particularly the last 5 years. This is the reckoning. I may have mentioned it before, I forget.

As it is Reeves is just as political a Chancellor as every other. She had choices today, and chose the easy ones. Stuff the public sector workers mouths with gold, make an easy cut to pensioner benefits and trail the "othering" of tax rises for the budget.
Reply
#22
(07-29-2024, 11:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-29-2024, 06:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: If the economic terrorists hadn't committed economic terrorism then this £20bn hole would not exist, but they did so it does. Your blame should be squared solely at the Tory front bench who directed Treasury officials to withhold information from the OBR so this hole would only be able to come to light after the General Election.

Arf. You could fill your £20bn "hole" by simply reversing the NI cut.

Economic terrorism. Oh my days. They've been chucking money at every one of us for the thick end of a decade - particularly the last 5 years. This is the reckoning. I may have mentioned it before, I forget.

As it is Reeves is just as political a Chancellor as every other. She had choices today, and chose the easy ones. Stuff the public sector workers mouths with gold, make an easy cut to pensioner benefits and trail the "othering" of tax rises for the budget.

It's not a fiscal deficit of £20bn, it's a budgetary shortfall caused by the last government spending the reserves three times over and didn't disclose it to the OBR.

I'd suggest you read the IFS comment on yesterday.

The pay reviews were set the conditions by the last government, were the Tories going to reject them again despite saying they'd approve them? Do you want the economic damage caused by more strikes as well as the productivity hit of people working elsewhere or leaving the country? £15/hr for junior doctors is hilariously shit.
Reply
#23
I think I said what I wanted above BB. Cutting NI was akin to salting the earth.

It worries me that Labour agreed to it.
Reply
#24
(07-30-2024, 06:52 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I think I said what I wanted above BB. Cutting NI was akin to salting the earth.

It worries me that Labour agreed to it.

Why do you think I'm calling them economic terrorists? Regardless, the NICs cut has nothing to do with the cause as this is a result of spending money three times over what was available due to policy failings and then hiding that from the people that oversee the budget.

If Labour (and the Lib Dems) had said they'd reverse the cuts then that's a political attack line to be used against them especially with the tax burden already as it is. You could already see the priority of the Opposition front bench yesterday was "Labour are putting tax up" and the Chancellor apparently lying when he said that the OBR were aware. Zero desire to take responsibility for what they did like it's some sort of game for them.
Reply
#25
(07-29-2024, 06:38 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(07-29-2024, 06:13 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Today's the day Rachel Reeves tells us about the £20b Black hole in the nation's finances, which they have now discovered after opening the 'books'

Is it the same 20b the IFS warned us about during  the election campaign

Fluff
Really, why would anyone get upset about this? Wouldn't you expect it? Remember Cameron talking endlessly about the "structural deficit" and of course the "Labour caused the GFC by borrowing too much" Unchallenged by the media, particularly the BBC and for the record, Ed Miliband. The biggest political lie of the century, possibly ever. Then the infamous "There's no money left note"

Yes it is fluff and you make an excellent point about how the Conservatives successfully pinned a global financial meltdown on UK Govt spending. It demeans our politics when Governments behave this way.

Which brings us back to my point.

Labour's clichéd comments of having to look at the books once they were in Govt, was just a cynical strategy to avoid having to discuss the difficult decisions it would have to take once they were in Govt.

It's bad politics and this is Bourne out by the disappointing voter turnout in the election, especially in areas where there are higher rates of deprivation.

What worries me is, who the disillusioned turn to if they decide to get involved in the electoral process. And the brexit referendum shows that people will participate in democracy if you give them something to believe in...although in that case it was just a mirage.
Reply
#26
[Image: GTqlGndWQAAHj0Y?format=png&name=900x900]
Reply
#27
Even when they peep their heads up from behind the rock from the warmth of the opposition benches they still get a slap.

Hashtag still winning.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#28
I listened to Reeves this morning on R4. She's already a typical political Chancellor - the weasel words on funding the pay review bodies recommendations were actually hilarious, as if she has no agency in the highly political decisions she made yesterday.

I am also delighted that you all seem to be coming round to my point of view that public spending is far too high and that we're all going to have to get used to being a little bit poorer and take a little bit less for the common good.
Reply
#29
I’m off out hunting for some crumbs - I’ll let you all know if I find any
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#30
I'm sorry I'm still confused, is that letter from the OBR that Dekka has shown from the bad OBR who don't know anything or from the good OBR that we should listen to?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)