Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between?
#21
(05-21-2024, 10:41 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(05-21-2024, 10:23 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Best since Roy for me.

Tactically astute, understands clean sheets are more important than possession and scoring lots of goals while conceding just as many. Improves the players at his disposal, works on match plans thoroughly including the substitutes rather than just being reactive.

I have very few criticisms of him, fans never, ever like it when a manager is in any way cautious if the team doesn't win, always rather "have a go" which makes no sense with the money involved in modern football.

Be interesting to see what this summer brings since the squad will be overhauled somewhat, then we'll see what he really wants to work with a bit more. We do need to get at least one reliable striker, arguably two, and that's a challenge.

If you draw one or go for it and win there you have the scenario  you could win 2 out of the three and be better off .

Could lose all three, as Bruce did.
Reply
#22
He has a good mentality and possibilities Big Grin
Reply
#23
Not sure how you can set up to be more attacking on a consistent basis without any strikers.
Reply
#24
Done a great job, one fit striker, an ageing squad, no money, 15months under a crap owner, getting us to play offs.
This man is well in credit, yes he has made mistakes, but he is human and well trusted by Patel.lets see how he gets on with recruitment and setting up his own team with younger players. Also agree with rich cannot go to attacking because we don’t have the strikers.
Reply
#25
He's a fantastic coach, tactically astute, young and eager to learn and develop. He bases his approach on facts and stats, and focusses on the things he can control. He does more work behind the scenes than anyone in teh game by all accounts and the job hes done with the disjointed and unbalanced squad which we have has been superb. 

All in all he's superb and we are lucky to have him. He will go on to manage a much bigger club than us no doubt.

Still doesn't mean I wont call him out on his errors though...  Big Grin
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#26
(05-21-2024, 10:36 AM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote: Agree with Birdie, best Manager since Roy. The last thing we should be doing is looking to replace him. I'm hoping he can build a team / squad over the summer that will allow us to continue our progression under him.

He's not above criticism, but in King Carlos we should trust.
Is anyone seriously advocating that? No one that I know of is.
If this is to be a genuine thread, however, it has to balanced and consider his shortcomings, as well as his strengths.

We have had a terrific season, where we have over-achieved, and I would say a good 70% of that is solely down to his man-management, tactical astuteness and his unwaivering commitment and enthusiasm, no man is an island however, so some of the credit has to be shared. If you compare to Bruce though, who barely turned up for training and pretty much left them to their own devices, then Carlos is the polar opposite. The players clearly respect him and buy into his ethics, but that is because he leads by example of hard work and striving to improve.

There are clear areas for improvement though, the first of which has to be away form. There is clearly a bit of a disconnect with his approach, and the player's interpretation of it, and I'm sure this will be top of his list for the coming season. If we had been anywhere close to being as good away as our home form suggested we could be, then top 2 would have been realistic and we may have been more competitive in the play off.

Second area has to be recruitment. He clearly has a big say on who comes in, so we can't just lambast Pearce for the likes of Pipa, Marshall and M'Vila or the fact that we didn't get a striker in Jan.

All said and done, I don't think we've had a manger with greater potential in my lifetime and I'm hoping we have got him at just the right time, where he is finetuning his trade. He's still raw enough to keep the predators at bay, but his incredible work ethic, and commitment to improve, is the most positive thing we've had in years.

Going to be an exciting summer and I am 100% convinced we have the right man to face it.
Reply
#27
(05-21-2024, 10:53 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Not sure how you can set up to be more attacking on a consistent basis without any strikers.

Setting up just to try and stay in the game and nick it ain't the way forward rich ....

I really don't enjoy it I've not just said it on this post I've told you privately how I feel ......especially away no wonder I've walked out long before the end and gone back to the pub .
Reply
#28
(05-21-2024, 10:53 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Not sure how you can set up to be more attacking on a consistent basis without any strikers.

Doesn't help the one time he really let the brakes.off against Leicester when they looked there for the taking and we were on top, we lost. Hardly fills him or the squad with confidence to go out and attack teams to death.
Reply
#29
(05-21-2024, 10:58 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-21-2024, 10:53 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Not sure how you can set up to be more attacking on a consistent basis without any strikers.

Doesn't help the one time he really let the brakes.off against Leicester when they looked there for the taking and we were on top, we lost. Hardly fills him or the squad with confidence to go out and attack teams to death.

We do the same by trying to stay in the game and we lose
Reply
#30
(05-21-2024, 10:57 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(05-21-2024, 10:53 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Not sure how you can set up to be more attacking on a consistent basis without any strikers.

Setting up just to try and stay in the game and nick it ain't the way forward rich ....

I really don't enjoy it I've not just said it on this post I've told you privately how I feel ......especially away no wonder I've walked out long before the end and gone back to the pub .

How do you set up to be consistently more attacking if you don't have the tools to do it? You might get one off successes with makeshift forwards but not in a consistent basis.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)