Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
Do you think decades of idiocy on energy policy and the associated infrastructure issues that has made us so reliant on gas can be fixed overnight?
The things that help us in the immediate term are Eurasian gas prices collapsing and good weather, both are very much wishful thinking and not within the realm of the UK government to make happen. Even an Arabian gas pipeline would take years, you're essentially relying on sunny weather with plenty of wind (but not so much wind that it overloads our transmission infrastructure) and the capitulation of Russia.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(04-24-2025, 12:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Fantastic. What do we do overnight?
You'll have to set fire to another wad of twenties champ.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
04-24-2025, 01:21 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-24-2025, 01:22 PM by Protheroe.)
(04-24-2025, 12:42 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you think decades of idiocy on energy policy and the associated infrastructure issues that has made us so reliant on gas can be fixed overnight?
The things that help us in the immediate term are Eurasian gas prices collapsing and good weather, both are very much wishful thinking and not within the realm of the UK government to make happen. Even an Arabian gas pipeline would take years, you're essentially relying on sunny weather with plenty of wind (but not so much wind that it overloads our transmission infrastructure) and the capitulation of Russia.
No, I don't think it'll be fixed overnight.
But Miliband promising us lower bills (at some indeterminate point in the future) when all bills are doing in the meantime is rising, when all our heavy industry is leaving actually constitutes gaslighting on a scale way above anything the Tories managed over 14 years.
And for what? To make no material difference whatsoever to climate change, that's what.
(04-24-2025, 12:57 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-24-2025, 12:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Fantastic. What do we do overnight?
You'll have to set fire to another wad of twenties champ.
The new plastic ones don't burn half as well.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
04-24-2025, 01:52 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-24-2025, 01:54 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(04-24-2025, 01:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-24-2025, 12:42 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you think decades of idiocy on energy policy and the associated infrastructure issues that has made us so reliant on gas can be fixed overnight?
The things that help us in the immediate term are Eurasian gas prices collapsing and good weather, both are very much wishful thinking and not within the realm of the UK government to make happen. Even an Arabian gas pipeline would take years, you're essentially relying on sunny weather with plenty of wind (but not so much wind that it overloads our transmission infrastructure) and the capitulation of Russia.
No, I don't think it'll be fixed overnight.
But Miliband promising us lower bills (at some indeterminate point in the future) when all bills are doing in the meantime is rising, when all our heavy industry is leaving actually constitutes gaslighting on a scale way above anything the Tories managed over 14 years.
And for what? To make no material difference whatsoever to climate change, that's what.
Do you think he's got the powers to suddenly lower the price of gas or something?
We're upgrading our transmission infrastructure by spending billions in order to drag it into the 21st century, connections reform is currently underway to prioritise necessary grid connections to quickly ramp up generation capacity, the tender is out for SMRs, the first of four EPRs are due to come online in the early 2031s with plans to cut red tape and restart the new nuclear plans scrapped by Cameron after the 2015 GE, we're investing in floating wind to be able to put offshore wind farms deeper into the North Sea, we're looking at new pumped hydro sites in Scotland, the three TOs have been given the green light be DESNZ and Ofgem to plow on with pylons starting in the Scottish borders and East of England, the ban on onshore wind has been scrapped, enough solar has been installed now for it to push gas off marginal pricing and infrastructure planning is being streamlined. What more are they supposed to do exactly? You don't fix 46 years of idiocy in less than 12 months.
And one of the objectives of our current electricity plans is to be a net exporter through leveraging our geographic advantages - namely being a fucking island with loads of wind. That will help decarbonise Europe while bringing in more tax revenue, green energy is one of our strongest growing economic sectors and companies set up here to take advantage of our position will be able to use what they have learned here to deploy it elsewhere.
I find it astonishingly ironic that you of all people are whining about energy costs quite frankly given your political positions have been in support of the very policies that have put us in this mess. You, people like you and the politics that you supported have dug this hole and now people like me are trying to get us out of it and you're complaining, it's infuriating.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
04-24-2025, 02:31 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-24-2025, 02:33 PM by Protheroe.)
Personally I was all for a massive expansion in large scale and small modular reactors in areas where we wouldn't need a huge investment in transmission infrastructure. Suggesting I "supported" the energy policies of the last government is akin to suggesting I "supported" the their housing policies and tax policies.
I didn't. But you knew that. If I had my way GB Energy would be facilitating drilling in the North Sea and fracking the North West to fuck.
I know you get excitable about renewable electricity and the potential that it offers. But potential doesn't matter NOW to people freezing their bollocks off and being lied to that their energy bills will "come down by £300".
Posts: 7,444
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
04-24-2025, 03:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-24-2025, 03:04 PM by tHEgLASSdOORS.)
(04-24-2025, 01:52 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (04-24-2025, 01:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-24-2025, 12:42 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you think decades of idiocy on energy policy and the associated infrastructure issues that has made us so reliant on gas can be fixed overnight?
The things that help us in the immediate term are Eurasian gas prices collapsing and good weather, both are very much wishful thinking and not within the realm of the UK government to make happen. Even an Arabian gas pipeline would take years, you're essentially relying on sunny weather with plenty of wind (but not so much wind that it overloads our transmission infrastructure) and the capitulation of Russia.
No, I don't think it'll be fixed overnight.
But Miliband promising us lower bills (at some indeterminate point in the future) when all bills are doing in the meantime is rising, when all our heavy industry is leaving actually constitutes gaslighting on a scale way above anything the Tories managed over 14 years.
And for what? To make no material difference whatsoever to climate change, that's what.
Do you think he's got the powers to suddenly lower the price of gas or something?
We're upgrading our transmission infrastructure by spending billions in order to drag it into the 21st century, connections reform is currently underway to prioritise necessary grid connections to quickly ramp up generation capacity, the tender is out for SMRs, the first of four EPRs are due to come online in the early 2031s with plans to cut red tape and restart the new nuclear plans scrapped by Cameron after the 2015 GE, we're investing in floating wind to be able to put offshore wind farms deeper into the North Sea, we're looking at new pumped hydro sites in Scotland, the three TOs have been given the green light be DESNZ and Ofgem to plow on with pylons starting in the Scottish borders and East of England, the ban on onshore wind has been scrapped, enough solar has been installed now for it to push gas off marginal pricing and infrastructure planning is being streamlined. What more are they supposed to do exactly? You don't fix 46 years of idiocy in less than 12 months.
And one of the objectives of our current electricity plans is to be a net exporter through leveraging our geographic advantages - namely being a fucking island with loads of wind. That will help decarbonise Europe while bringing in more tax revenue, green energy is one of our strongest growing economic sectors and companies set up here to take advantage of our position will be able to use what they have learned here to deploy it elsewhere.
I find it astonishingly ironic that you of all people are whining about energy costs quite frankly given your political positions have been in support of the very policies that have put us in this mess. You, people like you and the politics that you supported have dug this hole and now people like me are trying to get us out of it and you're complaining,
(04-24-2025, 01:52 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (04-24-2025, 01:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-24-2025, 12:42 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you think decades of idiocy on energy policy and the associated infrastructure issues that has made us so reliant on gas can be fixed overnight?
The things that help us in the immediate term are Eurasian gas prices collapsing and good weather, both are very much wishful thinking and not within the realm of the UK government to make happen. Even an Arabian gas pipeline would take years, you're essentially relying on sunny weather with plenty of wind (but not so much wind that it overloads our transmission infrastructure) and the capitulation of Russia.
No, I don't think it'll be fixed overnight.
But Miliband promising us lower bills (at some indeterminate point in the future) when all bills are doing in the meantime is rising, when all our heavy industry is leaving actually constitutes gaslighting on a scale way above anything the Tories managed over 14 years.
And for what? To make no material difference whatsoever to climate change, that's what.
Do you think he's got the powers to suddenly lower the price of gas or something?
We're upgrading our transmission infrastructure by spending billions in order to drag it into the 21st century, connections reform is currently underway to prioritise necessary grid connections to quickly ramp up generation capacity, the tender is out for SMRs, the first of four EPRs are due to come online in the early 2031s with plans to cut red tape and restart the new nuclear plans scrapped by Cameron after the 2015 GE, we're investing in floating wind to be able to put offshore wind farms deeper into the North Sea, we're looking at new pumped hydro sites in Scotland, the three TOs have been given the green light be DESNZ and Ofgem to plow on with pylons starting in the Scottish borders and East of England, the ban on onshore wind has been scrapped, enough solar has been installed now for it to push gas off marginal pricing and infrastructure planning is being streamlined. What more are they supposed to do exactly? You don't fix 46 years of idiocy in less than 12 months.
And one of the objectives of our current electricity plans is to be a net exporter through leveraging our geographic advantages - namely being a fucking island with loads of wind. That will help decarbonise Europe while bringing in more tax revenue, green energy is one of our strongest growing economic sectors and companies set up here to take advantage of our position will be able to use what they have learned here to deploy it elsewhere.
I find it astonishingly ironic that you of all people are whining about energy costs quite frankly given your political positions have been in support of the very policies that have put us in this mess. You, people like you and the politics that you supported have dug this hole and now people like me are trying to get us out of it and you're complaining, Spot on
We are similarly working hard to recover the health and education sectors from vast destructions suffered via Proth and his acolytes. It’s a daily grind and uphill battle but at least with some competent governance and strategic planning finally.
Expressions of support are not required but the gall to stand and complain from sidelines is quite something
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
04-24-2025, 03:11 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-24-2025, 03:15 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
Fracking wouldn't do shit. There's extreme uncertainty as to the amount of shale gas in the UK but even the extremely optimistic estimates from 10 years ago wouldn't make a dent in Eurasian gas supplies to alter the market price at peak output, and peak output is 2 to 3 decades away from exploration as with every single gas field or shale well. That wouldn't solve anything. It doesn't buy time to transition to nuclear and renewables, it doesn't solve regional pricing fluctuations. It's pointless, we are not the United States - we do not have our own regional gas market that's insulated from global shocks and we don't have huge amounts of unoccupied land to scale up production. The only time it would be useful is either well into the future purely for industrial purposes for gas or if we stupidly decide to isolate ourselves from all the global markets - neither of which solves anything.
And what the hell are you on about "massive expansion in SMR"? The in-construction EPRs are not due to come online yet, there's only two operational SMRs (China and Russia) in the world, when was that supposed to happen? Do you think you just moor nuclear subs on land and plug them in or something? Meanwhile, you voted to abandon insulation support, abandon PV on new builds, voted to abandon the EPR strategy and voted to introduce the moratorium on onshore wind. So yes, you did actually support the policies that dug that hole. Maybe next time look into what you're actually voting for?
What is fucking us NOW is decades of policy fuck-ups that made us reliant on gas. You don't fix that overnight, the only time we've tried to address that until very recently was 2008-2015 but then the Tories won a majority and fucked everything up. The person you have in your profile picture was PM when every single idiotic energy policy position began for crying out loud. Not to mention your hero worship of the 1980s which is the exact short-sighted idiocy that got us into the mess, first by scrapping new nuclear plans, then scrapping grid upgrades, then selling off grid and nuclear power when they have such high CAPEX requirements and massive timescales to see a return that the private sector does not want to invest in.
The ONLY thing we can do in the immediate term to bring down energy prices is hope that we have enough renewable capacity and good weather to knock out gas from marginal pricing while also hoping that the regional price of gas collapses because of things outside of our control as we do not have enough supply to affect things. Do you think I want to be relying on an intermittent generation source that could easily overload our woefully out of date grid if it generates too much power? No, but that's all we've got over the next 5 years if we want energy bills to come down.
As for transmission infrastructure, you don't understand the problem. You can't build an EPR in the middle of London or Manchester - our grid is really fucking old, London isn't even switched to 400kV yet which is 1970s tech, it's stuck to 1950s tech.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
That may well be correct. But my complaint is that Ed promised my bills would come down by £300. He didn’t mention that I’d be paying over £3,000 for my energy each year before that happened - which doesn’t exactly make it the saving I was hoping for.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(04-24-2025, 03:40 PM)Protheroe Wrote: That may well be correct. But my complaint is that Ed promised my bills would come down by £300. He didn’t mention that I’d be paying over £3,000 for my energy each year before that happened - which doesn’t exactly make it the saving I was hoping for.
Exactly.
If the Tories gaslighted like this, the resident Commies on this bored would be the first to shout.
I
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(04-24-2025, 03:40 PM)Protheroe Wrote: That may well be correct. But my complaint is that Ed promised my bills would come down by £300. He didn’t mention that I’d be paying over £3,000 for my energy each year before that happened - which doesn’t exactly make it the saving I was hoping for.
That's the point of CP2030 though and connections reform getting more renewables online closer to demand areas and enabling more export potential to sell to other countries.
Other than that what exactly are they supposed to do? It's going to be more meaningful doing that than just sitting on our hands until HPC is online.
|