That nice Mr Starmer...
#21
And not a mention of QE.

Nor do I absolve the Tories of fiscal insanity
Reply
#22
Why would I mention QE? The BoE had wound down its bond purchases by the time Carney became governor in 2013 and the only rounds of bond purchases during his time time as governor were made in relation to price stability - which again goes back to managing the target - around late-2016 (when inflation started spiking above the target) and then mid-2020 (Covid).

What you can complain about is not engaging with QT, but I would posit that was because the fiscal environment didn't enable that again because of inflation being below the target and any QT would have required further rate cuts to balance. So, again, the issue relates to Number 11.
Reply
#23
(10-09-2023, 09:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-09-2023, 06:42 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-08-2023, 09:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It is a fact that Starmer has jettisoned every aspect of the platform he was elected on. He has also changed his mind (apparently) on Brexit. If trust is what you’re after, we’ll…

Really 

1, Tax- not jetisoned  (the manifesto has not been written yet anyway the facts have changed)
2. Social Justice - diito
3. Climate - Ditto
4. Peace - ditto
5. Common Ownership - Public services should be in public hands. I see this as an aim/aspiration not an objective not possible or desirable anyway. I doubt he was ever serious about it.
6. Migrants rights - he won't ditch that. Free movement may give him a headache but if he seeks a different relationship with the EU it's on the cards 
7. Unions - workers rights he'll keep that one
8. Devolution - we'll see
9. Equality - he'll do that
10 - Effective opposition to the Tories - Corbyn gone, AS gone, 2 Tory PMs gone

Yes, really:

1. The top rate of income tax will not be increased for the top 5% of earners. There are no Corporation Tax cuts to reverse. Private Schools Charitable Status remains - fuck knows how they'll apply VAT.
2. The two child limit will remain, Universal Credit will be reformed not abolished, Tuition Fees certainly won't be abolished.
3. £28bn annual funding junked and no becomes an aspiration. Decarbonising the energy system by 2030 is simply impossible.
4. Don't expect he mooted Prevention of Military Intervention Act.
5. Then why mention it? Rail is the only industry mentioned these days - and that's effectively nationalised already anyway. Plans to end outsourcing in the NHS have also been scrapped.
6. Free movement is dead in the water. Labour hasn't mentioned anything about ending indefinite immigration detention.
7. What workers rights is he looking to add? I'll bet you a tenner that zero hours contracts aren't banned at any point.
8. Indeed, we will see. Devolution without any resources to support it.
9. He'll do what? exactly, to “pull down obstacles that limit opportunities and talent”?
10. The Tories implosion is as much to do with that

It is a fact that Starmer has jettisoned every aspect of the platform he was elected on. He has also changed his mind (apparently) on Brexit. If trust is what you’re after, we’ll…

That statement is just bollox, as is most of your reply. I can't even be arsed to argue about it. How can someone like you, who joined the Torys to change them into something they never were (Tory Momentum) and then fuck off when it all goes wrong talk about trust. You openly admit to not being a Tory. It's been an utter disaster and all you say is if it was done my way we would have been fine. Politics is before economics and you just don't get it. If you did you wouldn't belong with the idealogical cranks that have basically ruined the two main political parties and the UK
Reply
#24
(10-09-2023, 10:50 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-09-2023, 10:11 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-09-2023, 09:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-09-2023, 06:42 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-08-2023, 09:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It is a fact that Starmer has jettisoned every aspect of the platform he was elected on. He has also changed his mind (apparently) on Brexit. If trust is what you’re after, we’ll…

Really 

1, Tax- not jetisoned  (the manifesto has not been written yet anyway the facts have changed)
2. Social Justice - diito
3. Climate - Ditto
4. Peace - ditto
5. Common Ownership - Public services should be in public hands. I see this as an aim/aspiration not an objective not possible or desirable anyway. I doubt he was ever serious about it.
6. Migrants rights - he won't ditch that. Free movement may give him a headache but if he seeks a different relationship with the EU it's on the cards 
7. Unions - workers rights he'll keep that one
8. Devolution - we'll see
9. Equality - he'll do that
10 - Effective opposition to the Tories - Corbyn gone, AS gone, 2 Tory PMs gone

Yes, really:

1. The top rate of income tax will not be increased for the top 5% of earners. There are no Corporation Tax cuts to reverse. Private Schools Charitable Status remains - fuck knows how they'll apply VAT.
2. The two child limit will remain, Universal Credit will be reformed not abolished, Tuition Fees certainly won't be abolished.
3. £28bn annual funding junked and no becomes an aspiration. Decarbonising the energy system by 2030 is simply impossible.
4. Don't expect he mooted Prevention of Military Intervention Act.
5. Then why mention it? Rail is the only industry mentioned these days - and that's effectively nationalised already anyway. Plans to end outsourcing in the NHS have also been scrapped.
6. Free movement is dead in the water. Labour hasn't mentioned anything about ending indefinite immigration detention.
7. What workers rights is he looking to add? I'll bet you a tenner that zero hours contracts aren't banned at any point.
8. Indeed, we will see. Devolution without any resources to support it.
9. He'll do what? exactly, to “pull down obstacles that limit opportunities and talent”?
10. The Tories implosion is as much to do with that

Proth in long winded attempt at saying ‘they’re all as bad as each other’ post. He’s run out of excuses for his beloved party and is now in damage limitation mode.

I note you haven't disagreed with anything in the post though.

It's not a question of them being as bad as each other, it's a question of balance - Starmer is just as capable of changing his mind as anyone else. I commend him for much of it. He's a realist. He might well end up being #leastworst.

Changing your mind when situations change is a sensible position to take. 

Lying on such a huge and blatant scale, gaslighting and blaming everyone but yourselves isn’t and that’s the major difference currently between the two parties. 

I don’t support either party, I have just seen the damage your ex-party has done to the country and particularly the weakest (tantamount to bullying) and I can’t help coming to the conclusion that I can’t ever vote for a bunch of vain, selfish, egotistical, self serving, out of touch, jingoistic beeps that your party has become. There were decent politicians in the Conservative Party but now it’s just UKIP with a bigger budget.
Reply
#25
(10-10-2023, 10:37 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-09-2023, 09:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-09-2023, 06:42 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-08-2023, 09:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It is a fact that Starmer has jettisoned every aspect of the platform he was elected on. He has also changed his mind (apparently) on Brexit. If trust is what you’re after, we’ll…

Really 

1, Tax- not jetisoned  (the manifesto has not been written yet anyway the facts have changed)
2. Social Justice - diito
3. Climate - Ditto
4. Peace - ditto
5. Common Ownership - Public services should be in public hands. I see this as an aim/aspiration not an objective not possible or desirable anyway. I doubt he was ever serious about it.
6. Migrants rights - he won't ditch that. Free movement may give him a headache but if he seeks a different relationship with the EU it's on the cards 
7. Unions - workers rights he'll keep that one
8. Devolution - we'll see
9. Equality - he'll do that
10 - Effective opposition to the Tories - Corbyn gone, AS gone, 2 Tory PMs gone

Yes, really:

1. The top rate of income tax will not be increased for the top 5% of earners. There are no Corporation Tax cuts to reverse. Private Schools Charitable Status remains - fuck knows how they'll apply VAT.
2. The two child limit will remain, Universal Credit will be reformed not abolished, Tuition Fees certainly won't be abolished.
3. £28bn annual funding junked and no becomes an aspiration. Decarbonising the energy system by 2030 is simply impossible.
4. Don't expect he mooted Prevention of Military Intervention Act.
5. Then why mention it? Rail is the only industry mentioned these days - and that's effectively nationalised already anyway. Plans to end outsourcing in the NHS have also been scrapped.
6. Free movement is dead in the water. Labour hasn't mentioned anything about ending indefinite immigration detention.
7. What workers rights is he looking to add? I'll bet you a tenner that zero hours contracts aren't banned at any point.
8. Indeed, we will see. Devolution without any resources to support it.
9. He'll do what? exactly, to “pull down obstacles that limit opportunities and talent”?
10. The Tories implosion is as much to do with that

It is a fact that Starmer has jettisoned every aspect of the platform he was elected on. He has also changed his mind (apparently) on Brexit. If trust is what you’re after, we’ll…

That statement is just bollox, as is most of your reply. I can't even be arsed to argue about it. How can someone like you, who joined the Torys to change them into something they never were (Tory Momentum) and then fuck off when it all goes wrong talk about trust. You openly admit to not being a Tory. It's been an utter disaster and all you say is if it was done my way we would have been fine. Politics is before economics and you just don't get it. If you did you wouldn't belong with the idealogical cranks that have basically ruined the two main political parties and the UK

Oh do behave, I was a member of the Tory Party under Dear Margaret when most of what I believe were the common principles in the party. I haven't changed, they have. I left a party unrecognisable from what it was.

But you're right politics does trump economics, it's why we're in the state we're in.

And I know you don't want to admit that Starmer has rowed back from virtually everything he stood for just a few years ago.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: