Corberan's opinion on latest transfer needs
#21
(08-25-2023, 01:54 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(08-25-2023, 01:41 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: We’ve currently got 20 senior players, excluding the likes of Ingram and Malcolm. Two more would make 22 and I reckon that’s about right. Four minimum? That would mean our youths having virtually no chance of game time, which no doubt we’d be moaning about

Strange situation Carlos gave the youngsters at Huddersfield game time and played them as part of the team. Not quite sure why he doesn't select ours more. He must believe they're not good enough or not ready to step up yet. Any idea what's happened to Tulloch after his loan spell in Ireland.

Tulloch is back and featuring for the reserves. He scored in the first match at Villa. May play tonight.
Reply
#22
Really feel for Carlos he’s been dealt a shit hand obviously been told
He may get somebody on a free if at least another 3 of the higher earners leave

It’s fucking shocking how we have been run by the Chinese.
Reply
#23
Lia and his cronies have been abysmal, that’s why why I’m utterly and completely behind Corberan he’s been dealt a shit hand, but I really think he loves this club and wants us to do well so that when/if we get new owners he is the first man any new owners will want onboard to take us forward.
Reply
#24
(08-25-2023, 02:18 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(08-25-2023, 01:45 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-25-2023, 01:32 PM)wba13 Wrote: Another thread more negativity. Repeat, Repeat,Repeat.

How can it be anything other than negative when we know players have to leave and the manager can sign 1, 2 at a push.

We need:
RB/RWB & LB/LWB to at least challenge Furlong/Townsend 
Centre Forward
CB - we have numbers but not the quality. Ideally Taylor out on loan and a genuine first choice centre half in.
CM or ACM.  We have Swift who can play the central attacking role and no one else.  We’re a red card away from Chalobah starting for us in the other 2 midfield roles.  Maybe the Brighton kid can play there( not sure yet.  He looked a world away from first team football at Leeds but I’ll reserve judgement for match sharpness and us tying to actually attack the opposition. 

So I’d say a minimum 4/5 players as we stand.  That’s before the outgoings that simply have to happen.

I’d expect Bartley,Mowatt, Diang to go. If not Diang then a couple of others to make up for his transfer fee income. 

We all know it has to happen due to financial constraints, doesn’t mean the manager has to like it or the fan base.

As for Carlos I’m not shite he can afford to walk, career-wise not financially.

2 seasons at Huddersfield and lost the play-off and 10 games or so in Greece.  If he walks again his stock may not be that high, however he may also not want to be tarnished by our mess and cold be thinking these will only make me look bad.

So with all our well documented financial constraints you think we need a squad with circa 26 senior players - minimum? That’s 6 players not even making the bench every match day.

Read what I've put ffs.

The squad would ideally have competition in those areas, yes.  We would also clear out some of the deadwood Reach & Kelly for starters, again, in an ideal world along with one or 2 others. Instead we'll end up still lopsided and still with players not part of CC's plans.  I'm sure he'd much rather have parted company with any other centre back than O'Shea, but that's the mess we're in. 

The comments were in the context of CC /fanbase being unhappy and WBA13 commenting about negativity.  Of course it's negative with only 1 incoming when we all know there's probably another 3-4 players to go yet.  I'm sure CC would want much more.  He's likely to have about 19 outfield players (plus kids), that will likely include a few that no one wold want near a starting XI.

CC doesn't have to accept the financial constraints, if he doesn't like it he can walk.  I doubt he will though, he has something to prove based on walking from Huddersfield and only getting 10 games in Greece.  He's not achieved anything as yet to get that next, bigger, job so walking now wouldn't look great on his CV (i do accept he's quite highly thought of within the game).

As a fan base we are allowed to be negative about knowing we need so much more than we're going to get thanks to our wonderful owners.

So I don't think we need 26 players in our current circumstances, nor did I say we should have them if you'd read it properly.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#25
(08-25-2023, 06:14 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-25-2023, 02:18 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(08-25-2023, 01:45 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-25-2023, 01:32 PM)wba13 Wrote: Another thread more negativity. Repeat, Repeat,Repeat.

How can it be anything other than negative when we know players have to leave and the manager can sign 1, 2 at a push.

We need:
RB/RWB & LB/LWB to at least challenge Furlong/Townsend 
Centre Forward
CB - we have numbers but not the quality. Ideally Taylor out on loan and a genuine first choice centre half in.
CM or ACM.  We have Swift who can play the central attacking role and no one else.  We’re a red card away from Chalobah starting for us in the other 2 midfield roles.  Maybe the Brighton kid can play there( not sure yet.  He looked a world away from first team football at Leeds but I’ll reserve judgement for match sharpness and us tying to actually attack the opposition. 

So I’d say a minimum 4/5 players as we stand.  That’s before the outgoings that simply have to happen.

I’d expect Bartley,Mowatt, Diang to go. If not Diang then a couple of others to make up for his transfer fee income. 

We all know it has to happen due to financial constraints, doesn’t mean the manager has to like it or the fan base.

As for Carlos I’m not shite he can afford to walk, career-wise not financially.

2 seasons at Huddersfield and lost the play-off and 10 games or so in Greece.  If he walks again his stock may not be that high, however he may also not want to be tarnished by our mess and cold be thinking these will only make me look bad.

So with all our well documented financial constraints you think we need a squad with circa 26 senior players - minimum? That’s 6 players not even making the bench every match day.

Read what I've put ffs.

The squad would ideally have competition in those areas, yes.  We would also clear out some of the deadwood Reach & Kelly for starters, again, in an ideal world along with one or 2 others. Instead we'll end up still lopsided and still with players not part of CC's plans.  I'm sure he'd much rather have parted company with any other centre back than O'Shea, but that's the mess we're in. 

The comments were in the context of CC /fanbase being unhappy and WBA13 commenting about negativity.  Of course it's negative with only 1 incoming when we all know there's probably another 3-4 players to go yet.  I'm sure CC would want much more.  He's likely to have about 19 outfield players (plus kids), that will likely include a few that no one wold want near a starting XI.

CC doesn't have to accept the financial constraints, if he doesn't like it he can walk.  I doubt he will though, he has something to prove based on walking from Huddersfield and only getting 10 games in Greece.  He's not achieved anything as yet to get that next, bigger, job so walking now wouldn't look great on his CV (i do accept he's quite highly thought of within the game).

As a fan base we are allowed to be negative about knowing we need so much more than we're going to get thanks to our wonderful owners.

So I don't think we need 26 players in our current circumstances, nor did I say we should have them if you'd read it properly.

I’m saying negativity because that is what virtually every thread at present turns into.
As for only 1 incoming from what I’ve read and know is we have had 2 In coming + a young striker.  Also you have no idea who were going to sell,release or bring in. I also no we’re allowed to be negative but about everything Albion.
Reply
#26
(08-25-2023, 06:37 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(08-25-2023, 06:14 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-25-2023, 02:18 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(08-25-2023, 01:45 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-25-2023, 01:32 PM)wba13 Wrote: Another thread more negativity. Repeat, Repeat,Repeat.

How can it be anything other than negative when we know players have to leave and the manager can sign 1, 2 at a push.

We need:
RB/RWB & LB/LWB to at least challenge Furlong/Townsend 
Centre Forward
CB - we have numbers but not the quality. Ideally Taylor out on loan and a genuine first choice centre half in.
CM or ACM.  We have Swift who can play the central attacking role and no one else.  We’re a red card away from Chalobah starting for us in the other 2 midfield roles.  Maybe the Brighton kid can play there( not sure yet.  He looked a world away from first team football at Leeds but I’ll reserve judgement for match sharpness and us tying to actually attack the opposition. 

So I’d say a minimum 4/5 players as we stand.  That’s before the outgoings that simply have to happen.

I’d expect Bartley,Mowatt, Diang to go. If not Diang then a couple of others to make up for his transfer fee income. 

We all know it has to happen due to financial constraints, doesn’t mean the manager has to like it or the fan base.

As for Carlos I’m not shite he can afford to walk, career-wise not financially.

2 seasons at Huddersfield and lost the play-off and 10 games or so in Greece.  If he walks again his stock may not be that high, however he may also not want to be tarnished by our mess and cold be thinking these will only make me look bad.

So with all our well documented financial constraints you think we need a squad with circa 26 senior players - minimum? That’s 6 players not even making the bench every match day.

Read what I've put ffs.

The squad would ideally have competition in those areas, yes.  We would also clear out some of the deadwood Reach & Kelly for starters, again, in an ideal world along with one or 2 others. Instead we'll end up still lopsided and still with players not part of CC's plans.  I'm sure he'd much rather have parted company with any other centre back than O'Shea, but that's the mess we're in. 

The comments were in the context of CC /fanbase being unhappy and WBA13 commenting about negativity.  Of course it's negative with only 1 incoming when we all know there's probably another 3-4 players to go yet.  I'm sure CC would want much more.  He's likely to have about 19 outfield players (plus kids), that will likely include a few that no one wold want near a starting XI.

CC doesn't have to accept the financial constraints, if he doesn't like it he can walk.  I doubt he will though, he has something to prove based on walking from Huddersfield and only getting 10 games in Greece.  He's not achieved anything as yet to get that next, bigger, job so walking now wouldn't look great on his CV (i do accept he's quite highly thought of within the game).

As a fan base we are allowed to be negative about knowing we need so much more than we're going to get thanks to our wonderful owners.

So I don't think we need 26 players in our current circumstances, nor did I say we should have them if you'd read it properly.

I’m saying negativity because that is what virtually every thread at present turns into.
As for only 1 incoming from what I’ve read and know is we have had 2 In coming + a young striker.  Also you have no idea who were going to sell,release or bring in. I also no we’re allowed to be negative but about everything Albion.

The 1 incoming relates to CC’s comments today matey. I.e. as it stands now, 1 more player is likely to come in, maybe 2.  If we offload more players before the deadline, then we may bring in more than 1 or 2. 


/
Reply
#27
If we don’t offload this coming week then it’s either a January fire sale, administration or new owners.

I don’t see what other options there are?

I guess we could be 16 points clear at the top, but I tend not to listen to the fairies at the bottom of the garden and then we may get support from the owners to sell as a PL club.

Imagine bing/the first club promoted whilst in administration! Is it even allowable?
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#28
(08-25-2023, 09:23 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: If we don’t offload this coming week then it’s either a January fire sale, administration or new owners. 

I don’t see what other options there are?

I guess we could be 16 points clear at the top, but I tend not to listen to the fairies at the bottom of the garden and then we may get support from the owners to sell as a PL club.

Imagine bing/the first club promoted whilst in administration! Is it even allowable?

It is allowed but the 10 point penalty may well see promotion missed, and the subsequent 10 point deduction the following season would also kill any survival hopes…. Nice problems to have though. 

Doubt we need to concern ourselves with that eventuality.
Reply
#29
Corboran wants 22 seniors, not counting the academy players pushing for a place. So maybe 2 more in.
Reply
#30
(08-25-2023, 03:14 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(08-25-2023, 03:08 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Sounds like he's after an all rounder who can play everywhere...

Pearce is on it and got a shortlist of Richard Hadlee and Kapil Dev

You get an ARF for that one Big Grin

I'm really disappointed we haven't tapped into the lower leagues and or stolen some other clubs kids.
Pearce is IMO stealing a living.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: