Jack Leach
#21
(06-05-2023, 10:16 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 10:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Injuries happen but to head into an Ashes series with the potential of Joe Root or Will Jacks as our premier spin bowler is criminal, goes back to my post on here a month or so back regarding our preparation.

Who are the other options? Ahmed is too young and raw yet, but you'd think he will be the option for the future that they're working on. As has been outlined by others in this thread, there's no other quality spinners at all.

Don't roget, 05 Ashes we had Ashley Giles as our main spinner. He was fine, but I think most would agree he was an average Test player at best. Take Swann out of the equation, who's our best spinner of the last 40 years?

Good point re Giles. There are similarities with Dawson (who is a better bat).

Domestic red-ball cricket does not prepare young spinners for Test cricket.  As you rightly say, Ahmed is not yet the answer (and he’s not bowling well currently), so on the basis they took Jacks (ahead of Bess) to Pakistan last winter and he took a 6-fer on debut, he’s the next offie cab on the rank, but with Root also able to do that, I have a sneaky feeling it will be Dawson. 

But for Edgbaston I think Woakes rather than a spinner will come in.

(06-05-2023, 10:08 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Bazball has been exciting, but we haven't developed the strength in depth. It relies on the Broad and Anderson magic, a spinner to hold one end up, the potential of mercurial batsmen like Stokes and Bairstow who can destroy an attack. But with Branderson being the age they are, Stokes' knee being bost, no back-up spinner even being developed to cover Leach (who has chronic illness problems anyway), it's always an injury or two away from disaster. I think the excitement of the gung-ho approach has masked an absence of strategic planning.

My guess is they'll add a fifth seamer (fourth actually 'cos I can't imagine Stokes will bowl much if at all) and let Root bowl plenty of overs.


A bit harsh on Ollie Robinson who has been superb over the past 2 years. He’s an automatic when fit.  

Very hard to plan ahead but England have blooded Potts and Tongue who are finding their feet.  Mark Wood is a huge plus if he stays fit.
Reply
#22
(06-05-2023, 10:35 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 10:16 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 10:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Injuries happen but to head into an Ashes series with the potential of Joe Root or Will Jacks as our premier spin bowler is criminal, goes back to my post on here a month or so back regarding our preparation.

Who are the other options? Ahmed is too young and raw yet, but you'd think he will be the option for the future that they're working on. As has been outlined by others in this thread, there's no other quality spinners at all.

Don't roget, 05 Ashes we had Ashley Giles as our main spinner. He was fine, but I think most would agree he was an average Test player at best. Take Swann out of the equation, who's our best spinner of the last 40 years?

Good point re Giles. There are similarities with Dawson (who is a better bat).

Domestic red-ball cricket does not prepare young spinners for Test cricket.  As you rightly say, Ahmed is not yet the answer (and he’s not bowling well currently), so on the basis they took Jacks (ahead of Bess) to Pakistan last winter and he took a 6-fer on debut, he’s the next offie cab on the rank, but with Root also able to do that, I have a sneaky feeling it will be Dawson. 

But for Edgbaston I think Woakes rather than a spinner will come in.

(06-05-2023, 10:08 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Bazball has been exciting, but we haven't developed the strength in depth. It relies on the Broad and Anderson magic, a spinner to hold one end up, the potential of mercurial batsmen like Stokes and Bairstow who can destroy an attack. But with Branderson being the age they are, Stokes' knee being bost, no back-up spinner even being developed to cover Leach (who has chronic illness problems anyway), it's always an injury or two away from disaster. I think the excitement of the gung-ho approach has masked an absence of strategic planning.

My guess is they'll add a fifth seamer (fourth actually 'cos I can't imagine Stokes will bowl much if at all) and let Root bowl plenty of overs.


A bit harsh on Ollie Robinson who has been superb over the past 2 years. He’s an automatic when fit.  

Very hard to plan ahead but England have blooded Potts and Tongue who are finding their feet.  Mark Wood is a huge plus if he stays fit.

I think fast bowlers, we're planning as best as we can. Ollie Robinson is the natural succesor to the "Anderson" role, and you'd hope one of Potts/Tongue/inserrt other bowler here, grows and can fill in the Broad role. Archer's overuse/injury was a massive blow.

It's sometimes easy to forget, but Anderson and Broad are the 1st and 2nd highest wicket taking fast bowlers in Test history. Their longevity, skill, experience, willpower etc is basically impossible to replace.
Reply
#23
(06-05-2023, 10:08 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Bazball has been exciting, but we haven't developed the strength in depth. It relies on the Broad and Anderson magic, a spinner to hold one end up, the potential of mercurial batsmen like Stokes and Bairstow who can destroy an attack. But with Branderson being the age they are, Stokes' knee being bost, no back-up spinner even being developed to cover Leach (who has chronic illness problems anyway), it's always an injury or two away from disaster. I think the excitement of the gung-ho approach has masked an absence of strategic planning.

My guess is they'll add a fifth seamer (fourth actually 'cos I can't imagine Stokes will bowl much if at all) and let Root bowl plenty of overs.

Nonsense. In the last 12 months we’ve blooded Potts, Brook, Ahmed and Tongue, and reinstated Duckett. All look like potential regulars in the side for years to come.
Being brutally honest 
Reply
#24
(06-05-2023, 11:09 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 10:08 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Bazball has been exciting, but we haven't developed the strength in depth. It relies on the Broad and Anderson magic, a spinner to hold one end up, the potential of mercurial batsmen like Stokes and Bairstow who can destroy an attack. But with Branderson being the age they are, Stokes' knee being bost, no back-up spinner even being developed to cover Leach (who has chronic illness problems anyway), it's always an injury or two away from disaster. I think the excitement of the gung-ho approach has masked an absence of strategic planning.

My guess is they'll add a fifth seamer (fourth actually 'cos I can't imagine Stokes will bowl much if at all) and let Root bowl plenty of overs.

Nonsense. In the last 12 months we’ve blooded Potts, Brook, Ahmed and Tongue, and reinstated Duckett. All look like potential regulars in the side for years to come.

Of those four, I'd say that only Brook has forced his way in. Potts needs to play so he can develop, but doesn't get many chances in competition with Anderson, Broad, Robinson. He could easily become the next Woakes, 30 odd Tests over 10 years. The other two are beginners, not ideal to be relying on them at this stage.

My doubts about Robinson are to do with fitness - he can't keep his pace up. Late in the day and second innings he's dropping below 83mph. Age for age, Broad was quicker. Pace is an essential differentiator, especially when Broad and Anderson's magic is delivered at a more gentle pace than it once was.
Reply
#25
(06-05-2023, 11:44 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 11:09 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 10:08 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Bazball has been exciting, but we haven't developed the strength in depth. It relies on the Broad and Anderson magic, a spinner to hold one end up, the potential of mercurial batsmen like Stokes and Bairstow who can destroy an attack. But with Branderson being the age they are, Stokes' knee being bost, no back-up spinner even being developed to cover Leach (who has chronic illness problems anyway), it's always an injury or two away from disaster. I think the excitement of the gung-ho approach has masked an absence of strategic planning.

My guess is they'll add a fifth seamer (fourth actually 'cos I can't imagine Stokes will bowl much if at all) and let Root bowl plenty of overs.

Nonsense. In the last 12 months we’ve blooded Potts, Brook, Ahmed and Tongue, and reinstated Duckett. All look like potential regulars in the side for years to come.

Of those four, I'd say that only Brook has forced his way in. Potts needs to play so he can develop, but doesn't get many chances in competition with Anderson, Broad, Robinson. He could easily become the next Woakes, 30 odd Tests over 10 years. The other two are beginners, not ideal to be relying on them at this stage.

My doubts about Robinson are to do with fitness - he can't keep his pace up. Late in the day and second innings he's dropping below 83mph. Age for age, Broad was quicker. Pace is an essential differentiator, especially when Broad and Anderson's magic is delivered at a more gentle pace than it once was.


So you think we should develop strength in depth yet we shouldn’t be playing beginners? How do we achieve the former without the latter?
Being brutally honest 
Reply
#26
(06-05-2023, 11:50 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 11:44 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 11:09 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 10:08 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Bazball has been exciting, but we haven't developed the strength in depth. It relies on the Broad and Anderson magic, a spinner to hold one end up, the potential of mercurial batsmen like Stokes and Bairstow who can destroy an attack. But with Branderson being the age they are, Stokes' knee being bost, no back-up spinner even being developed to cover Leach (who has chronic illness problems anyway), it's always an injury or two away from disaster. I think the excitement of the gung-ho approach has masked an absence of strategic planning.

My guess is they'll add a fifth seamer (fourth actually 'cos I can't imagine Stokes will bowl much if at all) and let Root bowl plenty of overs.

Nonsense. In the last 12 months we’ve blooded Potts, Brook, Ahmed and Tongue, and reinstated Duckett. All look like potential regulars in the side for years to come.

Of those four, I'd say that only Brook has forced his way in. Potts needs to play so he can develop, but doesn't get many chances in competition with Anderson, Broad, Robinson. He could easily become the next Woakes, 30 odd Tests over 10 years. The other two are beginners, not ideal to be relying on them at this stage.

My doubts about Robinson are to do with fitness - he can't keep his pace up. Late in the day and second innings he's dropping below 83mph. Age for age, Broad was quicker. Pace is an essential differentiator, especially when Broad and Anderson's magic is delivered at a more gentle pace than it once was.


So you think we should develop strength in depth yet we shouldn’t be playing beginners? How do we achieve the former without the latter?

We shouldn't find ourselves relying on rookies at the start of an Ashes series. Stokes and McCullum have fielded the strongest available side pretty much every time. There were opportunities to try a fringe player here and there if you ask me. As I said, a lack of strategic planning.
Reply
#27
(06-05-2023, 01:35 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 11:50 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 11:44 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 11:09 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 10:08 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Bazball has been exciting, but we haven't developed the strength in depth. It relies on the Broad and Anderson magic, a spinner to hold one end up, the potential of mercurial batsmen like Stokes and Bairstow who can destroy an attack. But with Branderson being the age they are, Stokes' knee being bost, no back-up spinner even being developed to cover Leach (who has chronic illness problems anyway), it's always an injury or two away from disaster. I think the excitement of the gung-ho approach has masked an absence of strategic planning.

My guess is they'll add a fifth seamer (fourth actually 'cos I can't imagine Stokes will bowl much if at all) and let Root bowl plenty of overs.

Nonsense. In the last 12 months we’ve blooded Potts, Brook, Ahmed and Tongue, and reinstated Duckett. All look like potential regulars in the side for years to come.

Of those four, I'd say that only Brook has forced his way in. Potts needs to play so he can develop, but doesn't get many chances in competition with Anderson, Broad, Robinson. He could easily become the next Woakes, 30 odd Tests over 10 years. The other two are beginners, not ideal to be relying on them at this stage.

My doubts about Robinson are to do with fitness - he can't keep his pace up. Late in the day and second innings he's dropping below 83mph. Age for age, Broad was quicker. Pace is an essential differentiator, especially when Broad and Anderson's magic is delivered at a more gentle pace than it once was.


So you think we should develop strength in depth yet we shouldn’t be playing beginners? How do we achieve the former without the latter?

We shouldn't find ourselves relying on rookies at the start of an Ashes series. Stokes and McCullum have fielded the strongest available side pretty much every time. There were opportunities to try a fringe player here and there if you ask me. As I said, a lack of strategic planning.

When we tried rotation and resting senior players in 2021/22 we won one test in 17. Since fielding the strongest team available we’ve won 11 in 13. I’d say that strategy has been pretty successful. England aren’t good enough to beat good teams with an under strength side, unless we’re up against the likes of Ireland. And sure enough we rested what is likely to be our first choice pace attack last week ie Anderson, Robinson and Wood. 
On the subject of Robinson, he’s ranked No 6 in the world at present so if you’ve got doubts about him you’re setting the bar pretty high!
Being brutally honest 
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: