Swift….
#21
(04-20-2023, 09:18 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Whether or not someone thinks John Swift is good is an excellent litmus test for identifying people who don't know what they're on about.

There really are some strange comments made on this bored
Reply
#22
(04-19-2023, 06:02 PM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote: I think he's one of those players that would thrive in the Premiership, as he's technically very good, but he's not suited so much to the hustle and bustle of the Championship. Let's hope we get to see if I'm right next season!

I thought we'd dispelled this myth many years ago.  There's less time to play in the PL than there is in the EFL, players have a much better touch and quicker thought process which gives the illusion of more time.

As for the work ethic in tracking back etc, it's partly what stopped Koumas playing at a much higher level than West Brom and Wigan.  If Scholes and Beckham with their skillset could still work as hard as they did off the ball then there's no excuse for Swift, nor for Koumas back in the day,

The difference between top and also-ran players can often be the mental attitude of application.  Undoubtedly Swift is a quality player on the ball and this part of his game is PL standard, but you need the other parts too to be a great player.

The fact that he doesn't have those extra bits is why he's playing for us.  I think all fanbases find it hard to take when the "missing" aptitude appears to be hardwork and effort.  It just appears lazy which I'm sure he's not, but if someone could just unlock that extra bit off the ball from he then he'd become a decent PL player.  Not top 6 (IMO) but could have a PL career instead of a Champo career.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#23
(04-20-2023, 09:11 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(04-20-2023, 09:03 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: His running stats are fine. We press as a front 2 and he is the second. He is tasked with pressing the CBs and counter pressing the holding midfielder. Not tracking the attacking players back into our box. 
If he were to 'bust a gut' he would often not be where he needs to be to be effective on the transition, and to create our attacks.
The "bust a gut" referred to training on his deficiencies not his in-game positioning.

No-one suggested he should constantly track back to our box either, but he should track back if he loses the ball (see Wallace against Blackpool).

To be fair I don't want him too far inside our half, too often. 

I also, in fairness to him, never see the "laziness" that some do. He just looks less energetics next to Wallace, BTA and Molumby.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#24
(04-20-2023, 09:36 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(04-20-2023, 09:11 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(04-20-2023, 09:03 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: His running stats are fine. We press as a front 2 and he is the second. He is tasked with pressing the CBs and counter pressing the holding midfielder. Not tracking the attacking players back into our box. 
If he were to 'bust a gut' he would often not be where he needs to be to be effective on the transition, and to create our attacks.
The "bust a gut" referred to training on his deficiencies not his in-game positioning.

No-one suggested he should constantly track back to our box either, but he should track back if he loses the ball (see Wallace against Blackpool).

To be fair I don't want him too far inside our half, too often. 

I also, in fairness to him, never see the "laziness" that some do. He just looks less energetics next to Wallace, BTA and Molumby.

Not every player needs to run around like a blue arsed fly. It's not a kids birthday party.
Reply
#25
(04-20-2023, 09:36 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(04-20-2023, 09:11 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(04-20-2023, 09:03 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: His running stats are fine. We press as a front 2 and he is the second. He is tasked with pressing the CBs and counter pressing the holding midfielder. Not tracking the attacking players back into our box. 
If he were to 'bust a gut' he would often not be where he needs to be to be effective on the transition, and to create our attacks.
The "bust a gut" referred to training on his deficiencies not his in-game positioning.

No-one suggested he should constantly track back to our box either, but he should track back if he loses the ball (see Wallace against Blackpool).

To be fair I don't want him too far inside our half, too often. 

I also, in fairness to him, never see the "laziness" that some do. He just looks less energetics next to Wallace, BTA and Molumby.
Fully agree there. I would rather see him in their box more often, especially coming in from the left when Wallace is pumping balls in. a bit like Gera and Brunt.

Laziness is probably unfair, but he does lack a bit of oomph at times, especially when he loses the ball. I take Anelka's point about the technicalities of Wallace being out of position due to his tracking back, but a moment like "that" tackle lifts the whole fanbase and shows that there is passion within the squad.

No-one is saying he's rubbish, his stats prove that to be untrue, it's more frustration that he's not as good as he could be or probably should be. Sadly, players are often judged more harshly on what they don't do, than what they do.
Reply
#26
(04-20-2023, 06:08 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: How you can say Swift is -not- a good footballer is utterly beyond me.

He's probably one of the best footballers we have when it comes to skill and ability, he just drifts in and out of games too much.

You're forgetting to factor in, that Nick's a troll & a piss poor WUM, once everyone realises that, then it all makes sense.
Reply
#27
(04-20-2023, 09:35 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(04-19-2023, 06:02 PM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote: I think he's one of those players that would thrive in the Premiership, as he's technically very good, but he's not suited so much to the hustle and bustle of the Championship. Let's hope we get to see if I'm right next season!

I thought we'd dispelled this myth many years ago.  There's less time to play in the PL than there is in the EFL, players have a much better touch and quicker thought process which gives the illusion of more time.

As for the work ethic in tracking back etc, it's partly what stopped Koumas playing at a much higher level than West Brom and Wigan.  If Scholes and Beckham with their skillset could still work as hard as they did off the ball then there's no excuse for Swift, nor for Koumas back in the day,

The difference between top and also-ran players can often be the mental attitude of application.  Undoubtedly Swift is a quality player on the ball and this part of his game is PL standard, but you need the other parts too to be a great player.

The fact that he doesn't have those extra bits is why he's playing for us.  I think all fanbases find it hard to take when the "missing" aptitude appears to be hardwork and effort.  It just appears lazy which I'm sure he's not, but if someone could just unlock that extra bit off the ball from he then he'd become a decent PL player.  Not top 6 (IMO) but could have a PL career instead of a Champo career.

This isn’t far off

Swift was Readings best player in a bad team.  He’s been on and off for us - it’s a matter of debate whether he is a top Champo player or decent Champo player.  He’s certainly not a PL player overall

For a no 10, the biggest problem is that he doesn’t attack the box enough when we are attacking/crosses come in.  A few on here including me have mentioned it at various times all season - I watched a home game around New Year with Mick Halsall (when Swift was playing well) and he said exactly that.  

He may be carrying a slight injury as TJ mentioned. I do think he is still carrying the timber he had at the start of the season.  

The thing is that in terms of starting - he is probably the best no 10 we have. I just thought he was a touch better than he has shown
Reply
#28
(04-20-2023, 09:35 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(04-19-2023, 06:02 PM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote: I think he's one of those players that would thrive in the Premiership, as he's technically very good, but he's not suited so much to the hustle and bustle of the Championship. Let's hope we get to see if I'm right next season!

I thought we'd dispelled this myth many years ago.  There's less time to play in the PL than there is in the EFL, players have a much better touch and quicker thought process which gives the illusion of more time.

As for the work ethic in tracking back etc, it's partly what stopped Koumas playing at a much higher level than West Brom and Wigan.  If Scholes and Beckham with their skillset could still work as hard as they did off the ball then there's no excuse for Swift, nor for Koumas back in the day,

The difference between top and also-ran players can often be the mental attitude of application.  Undoubtedly Swift is a quality player on the ball and this part of his game is PL standard, but you need the other parts too to be a great player.

The fact that he doesn't have those extra bits is why he's playing for us.  I think all fanbases find it hard to take when the "missing" aptitude appears to be hardwork and effort.  It just appears lazy which I'm sure he's not, but if someone could just unlock that extra bit off the ball from he then he'd become a decent PL player.  Not top 6 (IMO) but could have a PL career instead of a Champo career.
I get where you're coming from, but would argue that there aren't many Millwall like teams in the Premiership, and physicality is less prevalent. I think Swift would thrive in the Prem.due to this, but only my opinion of course.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)