Lai - loan - report - stuff
#21
(03-31-2023, 03:23 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:12 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:59 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:50 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: It hasn’t been written off.  It’s been impaired - which means the value of the loan as an asset has been written down in our books, but it still exists and is still repayable.  Standard accounting practice applies by the auditors to write down the loan on grounds of prudence, because of the risk of the asset not being recovered.

So many people are getting confused by the difference between writing off the debt and writing down the value of the asset.


I disagree.  The asset of Holdings (via the Jersey company) is the capital value of the 88% holding in Group.  Whether consolidated or not, if Holdings sells then 88% of the sale proceeds go to Holdings, and that’s when we would get repaid (if not already repaid by then).  It’s not true to say that the guarantee is worthless.

The only assets that Holdings has is the share capital of the subsidiaries. There isn't £5M of cash (or any other assets) that can be liquidated to repay this. If the club is sold, then this is another situation similar to the Peace loan (though legally different) in that the club will be ultimately liable for the repayment of the debt. Whilst this means that any negotiated sale may take this into effect, this loan has gone B&D, and many of us could be forgiven for thinking that whilst the guarantee liability exists, this will be the last we see of the cash.

I think the guarantee is worthless, because if Holdings pays this back, it is effectively coming from either up-streamed dividends (S4A will get excited) or the sale of the shares. The only thing this may do is suppress the sale value by c£5M, but the cash has left anyway.

No that’s not correct.  Holdings is Yunyai.  If the club is sold, Holdings receives the proceeds and the guarantee is enforced.   It doesn’t suppress the sale value to anybody other than Yunyai.  It doesn’t affect anybody else.

Yunwai is the shareholder, not the guarantor, Prag. The liability with Shareholder rests with the equity invested, no more than this. Yunwai won't be paying anyyhing. Anybody buying Holdings will have a Guarantee liability as a Contingent Obligation to consider, and this will be factored into the sale price negotiations.

Holdings has entered into a specific guarantee to pay the debt.  I know that Yunyai is not the guarantor.  Holdings will not be able to pay away the net sale proceeds without settling the guarantee obligation.  

Nobody will be buying Holdings!   They will be buying the new clean Jersey company in between.  That’s specifically why it was put there to make it a lot cleaner for the purchaser in a sale without having to buy any murkiness and history re Holdings.   Holdings will sell
JerseyCo to a new owner, and Holdings will receive the sale proceeds.

Holdings will only pay the guarantee if it is determined. I would certainly want it settled as part of the sale contract. You wouldn't want to have to chase this through a court in PRC once the funds had been distributed from Holdings to Yunwai.

More likely (sadly) is that we fail to achieve promotion before the MSD loan is repaid, and we are forced into Administration. It is interesting that MSD have a Debenture as a Fixed and Floating charge, without specific Fixed Charges, and there is no security taking over Holdings. It would be interesting to know if they have any Security over JerseyCo.
Reply
#22
(03-31-2023, 03:37 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:23 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:12 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:59 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:50 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The only assets that Holdings has is the share capital of the subsidiaries. There isn't £5M of cash (or any other assets) that can be liquidated to repay this. If the club is sold, then this is another situation similar to the Peace loan (though legally different) in that the club will be ultimately liable for the repayment of the debt. Whilst this means that any negotiated sale may take this into effect, this loan has gone B&D, and many of us could be forgiven for thinking that whilst the guarantee liability exists, this will be the last we see of the cash.

I think the guarantee is worthless, because if Holdings pays this back, it is effectively coming from either up-streamed dividends (S4A will get excited) or the sale of the shares. The only thing this may do is suppress the sale value by c£5M, but the cash has left anyway.

No that’s not correct.  Holdings is Yunyai.  If the club is sold, Holdings receives the proceeds and the guarantee is enforced.   It doesn’t suppress the sale value to anybody other than Yunyai.  It doesn’t affect anybody else.

Yunwai is the shareholder, not the guarantor, Prag. The liability with Shareholder rests with the equity invested, no more than this. Yunwai won't be paying anyyhing. Anybody buying Holdings will have a Guarantee liability as a Contingent Obligation to consider, and this will be factored into the sale price negotiations.

Holdings has entered into a specific guarantee to pay the debt.  I know that Yunyai is not the guarantor.  Holdings will not be able to pay away the net sale proceeds without settling the guarantee obligation.  

Nobody will be buying Holdings!   They will be buying the new clean Jersey company in between.  That’s specifically why it was put there to make it a lot cleaner for the purchaser in a sale without having to buy any murkiness and history re Holdings.   Holdings will sell
JerseyCo to a new owner, and Holdings will receive the sale proceeds.

Holdings will only pay the guarantee if it is determined. I would certainly want it settled as part of the sale contract. You wouldn't want to have to chase this through a court in PRC once the funds had been distributed from Holdings to Yunwai.

More likely (sadly) is that we fail to achieve promotion before the MSD loan is repaid, and we are forced into Administration. It is interesting that MSD have a Debenture as a Fixed and Floating charge, without specific Fixed Charges, and there is no security taking over Holdings. It would be interesting to know if they have any Security over JerseyCo.

The guarantee will I am sure be enforceable and it would be a breach of company law for Holdigs to distribute the proceeds prior to settling its obligations. 

The chances of administration are far less likely with MSD involved.  They are in a great position. Any event of default under the loan agreement puts them in a great position to force a sale in the market regardless of what price Yunyai would like.  I see that as a huge positive and the likeliest way to secure a new owner.
Reply
#23
(03-31-2023, 04:33 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:37 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:23 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:12 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:59 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: No that’s not correct.  Holdings is Yunyai.  If the club is sold, Holdings receives the proceeds and the guarantee is enforced.   It doesn’t suppress the sale value to anybody other than Yunyai.  It doesn’t affect anybody else.

Yunwai is the shareholder, not the guarantor, Prag. The liability with Shareholder rests with the equity invested, no more than this. Yunwai won't be paying anyyhing. Anybody buying Holdings will have a Guarantee liability as a Contingent Obligation to consider, and this will be factored into the sale price negotiations.

Holdings has entered into a specific guarantee to pay the debt.  I know that Yunyai is not the guarantor.  Holdings will not be able to pay away the net sale proceeds without settling the guarantee obligation.  

Nobody will be buying Holdings!   They will be buying the new clean Jersey company in between.  That’s specifically why it was put there to make it a lot cleaner for the purchaser in a sale without having to buy any murkiness and history re Holdings.   Holdings will sell
JerseyCo to a new owner, and Holdings will receive the sale proceeds.

Holdings will only pay the guarantee if it is determined. I would certainly want it settled as part of the sale contract. You wouldn't want to have to chase this through a court in PRC once the funds had been distributed from Holdings to Yunwai.

More likely (sadly) is that we fail to achieve promotion before the MSD loan is repaid, and we are forced into Administration. It is interesting that MSD have a Debenture as a Fixed and Floating charge, without specific Fixed Charges, and there is no security taking over Holdings. It would be interesting to know if they have any Security over JerseyCo.

The guarantee will I am sure be enforceable and it would be a breach of company law for Holdigs to distribute the proceeds prior to settling its obligations. 

The chances of administration are far less likely with MSD involved.  They are in a great position. Any event of default under the loan agreement puts them in a great position to force a sale in the market regardless of what price Yunyai would like.  I see that as a huge positive and the likeliest way to secure a new owner.

Far too many assumptions are going on here.
We are talking about billionaires here not market traders, they could simply take out an additional loan and pay MSD off, or even increase the MSD loan and terms. 
The owners certainly don't play by the rules as we know. 
Who knows what the future holds. IMO administration and or new owners are not on the agenda for the foreseeable.
Reply
#24
(03-31-2023, 05:33 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 04:33 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:37 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:23 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:12 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Yunwai is the shareholder, not the guarantor, Prag. The liability with Shareholder rests with the equity invested, no more than this. Yunwai won't be paying anyyhing. Anybody buying Holdings will have a Guarantee liability as a Contingent Obligation to consider, and this will be factored into the sale price negotiations.

Holdings has entered into a specific guarantee to pay the debt.  I know that Yunyai is not the guarantor.  Holdings will not be able to pay away the net sale proceeds without settling the guarantee obligation.  

Nobody will be buying Holdings!   They will be buying the new clean Jersey company in between.  That’s specifically why it was put there to make it a lot cleaner for the purchaser in a sale without having to buy any murkiness and history re Holdings.   Holdings will sell
JerseyCo to a new owner, and Holdings will receive the sale proceeds.

Holdings will only pay the guarantee if it is determined. I would certainly want it settled as part of the sale contract. You wouldn't want to have to chase this through a court in PRC once the funds had been distributed from Holdings to Yunwai.

More likely (sadly) is that we fail to achieve promotion before the MSD loan is repaid, and we are forced into Administration. It is interesting that MSD have a Debenture as a Fixed and Floating charge, without specific Fixed Charges, and there is no security taking over Holdings. It would be interesting to know if they have any Security over JerseyCo.

The guarantee will I am sure be enforceable and it would be a breach of company law for Holdigs to distribute the proceeds prior to settling its obligations. 

The chances of administration are far less likely with MSD involved.  They are in a great position. Any event of default under the loan agreement puts them in a great position to force a sale in the market regardless of what price Yunyai would like.  I see that as a huge positive and the likeliest way to secure a new owner.

Far too many assumptions are going on here.
We are talking about billionaires here not market traders, they could simply take out an additional loan and pay MSD off, or even increase the MSD loan and terms. 
The owners certainly don't play by the rules as we know. 
Who knows what the future holds. IMO administration and or new owners are not on the agenda for the foreseeable.

Going to go out on a limb here and suggest not a single person involved in any of this is a billionaire.
Reply
#25
(03-31-2023, 05:33 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 04:33 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:37 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:23 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:12 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Yunwai is the shareholder, not the guarantor, Prag. The liability with Shareholder rests with the equity invested, no more than this. Yunwai won't be paying anyyhing. Anybody buying Holdings will have a Guarantee liability as a Contingent Obligation to consider, and this will be factored into the sale price negotiations.

Holdings has entered into a specific guarantee to pay the debt.  I know that Yunyai is not the guarantor.  Holdings will not be able to pay away the net sale proceeds without settling the guarantee obligation.  

Nobody will be buying Holdings!   They will be buying the new clean Jersey company in between.  That’s specifically why it was put there to make it a lot cleaner for the purchaser in a sale without having to buy any murkiness and history re Holdings.   Holdings will sell
JerseyCo to a new owner, and Holdings will receive the sale proceeds.

Holdings will only pay the guarantee if it is determined. I would certainly want it settled as part of the sale contract. You wouldn't want to have to chase this through a court in PRC once the funds had been distributed from Holdings to Yunwai.

More likely (sadly) is that we fail to achieve promotion before the MSD loan is repaid, and we are forced into Administration. It is interesting that MSD have a Debenture as a Fixed and Floating charge, without specific Fixed Charges, and there is no security taking over Holdings. It would be interesting to know if they have any Security over JerseyCo.

The guarantee will I am sure be enforceable and it would be a breach of company law for Holdigs to distribute the proceeds prior to settling its obligations. 

The chances of administration are far less likely with MSD involved.  They are in a great position. Any event of default under the loan agreement puts them in a great position to force a sale in the market regardless of what price Yunyai would like.  I see that as a huge positive and the likeliest way to secure a new owner.

Far too many assumptions are going on here.
We are talking about billionaires here not market traders, they could simply take out an additional loan and pay MSD off, or even increase the MSD loan and terms. 
The owners certainly don't play by the rules as we know. 
Who knows what the future holds. IMO administration and or new owners are not on the agenda for the foreseeable.

Our owner(s) assets are predominantly tied to China (not even HK but China proper), they can't get money out of China and I'm unsure about the viability of securing a loan against assets based in China from a lender outside of China personally.

I imagine one of the reasons we were bought was to act as an asset outside of China for them to secure business against because the landscape in China is volatile.
Reply
#26
(03-31-2023, 04:33 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:37 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:23 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:12 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:59 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: No that’s not correct.  Holdings is Yunyai.  If the club is sold, Holdings receives the proceeds and the guarantee is enforced.   It doesn’t suppress the sale value to anybody other than Yunyai.  It doesn’t affect anybody else.

Yunwai is the shareholder, not the guarantor, Prag. The liability with Shareholder rests with the equity invested, no more than this. Yunwai won't be paying anyyhing. Anybody buying Holdings will have a Guarantee liability as a Contingent Obligation to consider, and this will be factored into the sale price negotiations.

Holdings has entered into a specific guarantee to pay the debt.  I know that Yunyai is not the guarantor.  Holdings will not be able to pay away the net sale proceeds without settling the guarantee obligation.  

Nobody will be buying Holdings!   They will be buying the new clean Jersey company in between.  That’s specifically why it was put there to make it a lot cleaner for the purchaser in a sale without having to buy any murkiness and history re Holdings.   Holdings will sell
JerseyCo to a new owner, and Holdings will receive the sale proceeds.

Holdings will only pay the guarantee if it is determined. I would certainly want it settled as part of the sale contract. You wouldn't want to have to chase this through a court in PRC once the funds had been distributed from Holdings to Yunwai.

More likely (sadly) is that we fail to achieve promotion before the MSD loan is repaid, and we are forced into Administration. It is interesting that MSD have a Debenture as a Fixed and Floating charge, without specific Fixed Charges, and there is no security taking over Holdings. It would be interesting to know if they have any Security over JerseyCo.

The guarantee will I am sure be enforceable and it would be a breach of company law for Holdigs to distribute the proceeds prior to settling its obligations. 

The chances of administration are far less likely with MSD involved.  They are in a great position. Any event of default under the loan agreement puts them in a great position to force a sale in the market regardless of what price Yunyai would like.  I see that as a huge positive and the likeliest way to secure a new owner.

I'm not so sure on MSD. We only have the Debenture on  Companies House, not the loan agreement. If you want to sell on the  market you either need co-operation of the shareholders, Admin or control of the shares. It would suit MSD not to follow Admin process, but I think they would want total control of the asset.

The guarantee is only enforceable if the loan defaults again. I'm sure it will have indemnification clauses in it, but you need the borrower to commit an Event of Default before you can call it in. Either way, I don't see the loan being paid until the club is sold.
Reply
#27
(03-31-2023, 06:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 04:33 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:37 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:23 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 03:12 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Yunwai is the shareholder, not the guarantor, Prag. The liability with Shareholder rests with the equity invested, no more than this. Yunwai won't be paying anyyhing. Anybody buying Holdings will have a Guarantee liability as a Contingent Obligation to consider, and this will be factored into the sale price negotiations.

Holdings has entered into a specific guarantee to pay the debt.  I know that Yunyai is not the guarantor.  Holdings will not be able to pay away the net sale proceeds without settling the guarantee obligation.  

Nobody will be buying Holdings!   They will be buying the new clean Jersey company in between.  That’s specifically why it was put there to make it a lot cleaner for the purchaser in a sale without having to buy any murkiness and history re Holdings.   Holdings will sell
JerseyCo to a new owner, and Holdings will receive the sale proceeds.

Holdings will only pay the guarantee if it is determined. I would certainly want it settled as part of the sale contract. You wouldn't want to have to chase this through a court in PRC once the funds had been distributed from Holdings to Yunwai.

More likely (sadly) is that we fail to achieve promotion before the MSD loan is repaid, and we are forced into Administration. It is interesting that MSD have a Debenture as a Fixed and Floating charge, without specific Fixed Charges, and there is no security taking over Holdings. It would be interesting to know if they have any Security over JerseyCo.

The guarantee will I am sure be enforceable and it would be a breach of company law for Holdigs to distribute the proceeds prior to settling its obligations. 

The chances of administration are far less likely with MSD involved.  They are in a great position. Any event of default under the loan agreement puts them in a great position to force a sale in the market regardless of what price Yunyai would like.  I see that as a huge positive and the likeliest way to secure a new owner.

I'm not so sure on MSD. We only have the Debenture on  Companies House, not the loan agreement. If you want to sell on the  market you either need co-operation of the shareholders, Admin or control of the shares. It would suit MSD not to follow Admin process, but I think they would want total control of the asset.

The guarantee is only enforceable if the loan defaults again. I'm sure it will have indemnification clauses in it, but you need the borrower to commit an Event of Default before you can call it in. Either way, I don't see the loan being paid until the club is sold.

I agree with your last sentence.
Reply
#28
Longest thread ever and I still don’t understand a word.
Reply
#29
(03-31-2023, 10:15 PM)Pipes of Peace Wrote: Longest thread ever and I still don’t understand a word.

Not just me then!
Reply
#30
(04-01-2023, 01:16 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 10:15 PM)Pipes of Peace Wrote: Longest thread ever and I still don’t understand a word.

Not just me then!

I'm waiting for the Netflix adaptation.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: