Posts: 13,574
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(03-03-2023, 05:10 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I think on paper there was room for better phased and less extremes but certainly the jan 2021 lockdown was a circus at least part in poor preparation. But there was no easy answer to a better system. My kids were out of school because I was under shielding and their gran was terminally ill. If schools had gone for a wider face to face approach it would’ve substantially effected the online learning and millions of similar cases would’ve received no education at all. You only have to look at the effect that maybe 30% on strike in a school has this week. It doesn’t mean 70% of it can operate. So the fairly most in or most out model was undesirable but not always anything but the only real choice
Maybe for primary schools but I can't agree for secondary schools especially towards the older age groups. The biggest problem from my point of view is the gap between how secondary schools responded vs how universities responded, it highlighted the huge gulf in how our schools are prepared to deal with disruption owing to how old fashioned (and in my opinion how much more we've gone backward under the Tories in relation to modernising education. See the issue of no modular exams and the return of rote learning, there's a reason unis have moved towards open book exams). Those issues have been known for years but ignored, digitising common resources to a national curriculum and utilisation of recorded lessons/lectures as a reference is hardly novel yet we failed at doing that. Not to mention the effects on higher performing groups were substantially lower than for lower performing groups (widening the gaps, pointing to the same resources being utilised more effectively by different groups for various reasons).
We've seen data from Switzerland pointing out that the learning impact was substantially lower for secondary school children than primary schools, Dutch primary aged kids also had less impact to their learning than Belgian and English kids. So there's some evidence out there that says other countries had their act together more than we did.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
(03-03-2023, 05:32 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-03-2023, 05:10 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I think on paper there was room for better phased and less extremes but certainly the jan 2021 lockdown was a circus at least part in poor preparation. But there was no easy answer to a better system. My kids were out of school because I was under shielding and their gran was terminally ill. If schools had gone for a wider face to face approach it would’ve substantially effected the online learning and millions of similar cases would’ve received no education at all. You only have to look at the effect that maybe 30% on strike in a school has this week. It doesn’t mean 70% of it can operate. So the fairly most in or most out model was undesirable but not always anything but the only real choice
Maybe for primary schools but I can't agree for secondary schools especially towards the older age groups. The biggest problem from my point of view is the gap between how secondary schools responded vs how universities responded, it highlighted the huge gulf in how our schools are prepared to deal with disruption owing to how old fashioned (and in my opinion how much more we've gone backward under the Tories in relation to modernising education. See the issue of no modular exams and the return of rote learning, there's a reason unis have moved towards open book exams). Those issues have been known for years but ignored, digitising common resources to a national curriculum and utilisation of recorded lessons/lectures as a reference is hardly novel yet we failed at doing that. Not to mention the effects on higher performing groups were substantially lower than for lower performing groups (widening the gaps, pointing to the same resources being utilised more effectively by different groups for various reasons).
We've seen data from Switzerland pointing out that the learning impact was substantially lower for secondary school children than primary schools, Dutch primary aged kids also had less impact to their learning than Belgian and English kids. So there's some evidence out there that says other countries had their act together more than we did.
Enjoy reading your views and understand them a bit more clearly now. Prior preparation/better investment/development a huge hindrance for sure and yes years of decay made things a lot worse
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 11,315
Threads: 420
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(03-03-2023, 03:27 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I would ask, what do you think would have happened if there had been no lockdown.
Is the argument on here always so binary?
My core beef with Lockdown was the closure of schools. It was the main contributory factor in my deciding to leave the Tory Party, but by Christ there's been tens of other contributory factors since.
I believe everything should have been done to keep schools open. It wasn't. The results are visible everyday. 100,000 kids disappeared from school rolls. The attitude to school attendance in all areas has altered beyond belief - almost all schools report attendance levels significantly below those Pre-Covid. It's visible in the socialisation (or not) of the current cohort of Year 9s and year 10s and in the inability of may younger kids to communicate effectively.
So whilst I think lockdown ought to have been more selective and aimed at those in greatest risk (and I really don't want to get into a pointless after the event argument about that again) I believe the legacy of betraying our kids will last decades for them, and the life chances of the most vulnerable kids will have been in some cases ruined for good.
Posts: 13,574
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
03-03-2023, 05:39 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-03-2023, 05:43 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(03-03-2023, 05:20 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Sounds great in theory BB. As someone who actually experienced it all, I can tell you unequivocally that the more anyone tried to complicate the model the more ineffectual it was sure to be
It was only complicated because there was no coherent strategy, if there was a coherent strategy it would have streamlined things through a) making sure the resources were there (they weren't, and this wasn't a novel thing either it's just something that wasn't planned for) and b) making sure people knew what they were supposed to do with digital resourcing instead of winging it (my mates were a little better as they are my age and so naturally are more experienced with tech and also at the very least their PGCE year had a template to follow and even they were ranting about it, older teachers I do not for the life of me understand what they were supposed to do without guidance). That is obviously compounded on by poor educational planning pre-Covid with the cracks widening.
Having that for the start of the pandemic I understand but by October 2020 I do not sympathise with.
And they've still not learnt their lesson on modular exams.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
03-03-2023, 05:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-03-2023, 05:42 PM by CaptainFantastico.)
The socialisation point you make is very valid. Yet you still outline nothing about overcoming the huge range of complexities that were present at the time. What do you think all the furloughed catering companies would’ve been replaced with? Magic food? What would all the kids that were half online and half in school have done to manage such a timetable? As ever, it’s wonderful on paper from the sidelines.
(03-03-2023, 05:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-03-2023, 05:20 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Sounds great in theory BB. As someone who actually experienced it all, I can tell you unequivocally that the more anyone tried to complicate the model the more ineffectual it was sure to be
It was only complicated because there was no coherent strategy, if there was a coherent strategy it would have streamlined things through a) making sure the resources were there (they weren't, and this wasn't a novel thing either it's just something that wasn't planned for) and b) making sure people knew what they were supposed to do with digital resourcing instead of winging it.
Having that for the start of the pandemic I understand but by October 2020 I do not sympathise with.
As I said, I totally agree with you that the Jan 2021 closures had far more scope for having been handled far more effectively. You are completely right on that.
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(03-03-2023, 05:38 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (03-03-2023, 03:27 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I would ask, what do you think would have happened if there had been no lockdown.
Is the argument on here always so binary?
My core beef with Lockdown was the closure of schools. It was the main contributory factor in my deciding to leave the Tory Party, but by Christ there's been tens of other contributory factors since.
I believe everything should have been done to keep schools open. It wasn't. The results are visible everyday. 100,000 kids disappeared from school rolls. The attitude to school attendance in all areas has altered beyond belief - almost all schools report attendance levels significantly below those Pre-Covid. It's visible in the socialisation (or not) of the current cohort of Year 9s and year 10s and in the inability of may younger kids to communicate effectively.
So whilst I think lockdown ought to have been more selective and aimed at those in greatest risk (and I really don't want to get into a pointless after the event argument about that again) I believe the legacy of betraying our kids will last decades for them, and the life chances of the most vulnerable kids will have been in some cases ruined for good.
The biggest restriction on implementing that was the lack of joined up thinking in how to do it whilst protecting staff, I think we recognised early on that children weren't as vulnerable to he virus. This came partly from piss poor planning especially as a pandemic was highlighted as a real threat in the 2015 report, and the investment in making schools work until we had some form of vaccine in place.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
Also very true
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 17,082
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
If they had put in place a child vaccine program months / up to a year before they actually did, like other countries did, rather than stubbornly let the JCVI ideologically deny this to people, then school lockdowns would have been a lot quicker to be lifted.
Posts: 11,315
Threads: 420
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(03-03-2023, 05:41 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The socialisation point you make is very valid. Yet you still outline nothing about overcoming the huge range of complexities that were present at the time. What do you think all the furloughed catering companies would’ve been replaced with? Magic food? What would all the kids that were half online and half in school have done to manage such a timetable? As ever, it’s wonderful on paper from the sidelines.
I am not the PM or the Education Secretary, but I can tell you this - instead of indiscriminately spunking money on Furlough, SEISS, CBILLS, BBLs I'd have ensured the all powerful state had developed something that would have kept our kids at school.
Posts: 13,574
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(03-03-2023, 05:38 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I believe everything should have been done to keep schools open.
That line of thinking was the problem when the schools had to inevitably close though. If you try to keep the schools open then when they have to close you have no redundancy and you're winging it. And in the end we winged it.
As I think my comments above relating to younger age groups make my position on socialisation clear I don't need to reiterate how I think that was a problem but when it came to exams or just things like assigned worksheets there was so much missed opportunity.
|