Public spending in a nutshell
#21
You're going to have to do better than that - these stats are based on FTE rather than headcount and appear to be adjusted to within an inch of a very different reality. I'll let you go away and find out the headcount figures but you'll only be disappointed.

As an example, if a nurse works a 75 hour week that counts as two nurses in your drastically adjusted figures. Total public sector workers, in headcount terms, was 5,410k in 1999 and 5,741k in 2022
Reply
#22
So not a precipitous collapse in employment, a modest rise.

When over the same period technology has transformed service industries, their headcount and productivity.
Reply
#23
Whilst the population increases at a greater rate? And if you really want me to dive into the stats to show the detail and where the shortfalls are, will you accept that and say fair enough. Will you bollocks.

Just as a quick example - Public sector employment excluding effects of major reclassifications shows 2022 figures as 5,601k and not the reclassified figure of 5,741k shown above.

Or that employment has actually fallen in 6 of the 12 areas measured since 2008, no guesses for the correct identification of the only area that has grown more than 10% (In a period of time where the population of London has increased by 20%). Our own region falling from 470k to 449k since 2008.

And how exactly could technology transform eduction in a way that less teachers would be needed. Stop me when you get to the 'fair enough' point.
Reply
#24
(02-08-2023, 09:51 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-07-2023, 11:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: There absolutely has

Gaslight me again that there have been attempts to reduce the size of the state. 

https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabo...s/g6nq/pse
https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabo...tember2022

https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabo.../march2019

On the topic of gaslighting...

(02-08-2023, 10:40 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Whilst the population increases at a greater rate? And if you really want me to dive into the stats to show the detail and where the shortfalls are, will you accept that and say fair enough. Will you bollocks.

Just as a quick example - Public sector employment excluding effects of major reclassifications shows 2022 figures as 5,601k and not the reclassified figure of 5,741k shown above.

Or that employment has actually fallen in 6 of the 12 areas measured since 2008, no guesses for the correct identification of the only area that has grown more than 10% (In a period of time where the population of London has increased by 20%). Our own region falling from 470k to 449k since 2008.

And how exactly could technology transform eduction in a way that less teachers would be needed. Stop me when you get to the 'fair enough' point.

They could teach kids from home to reduce admin staff at schools.

Something tells me Proth wouldn't like that though...
Reply
#25
There are so many angles here that Proth should look at and realise what the actual problem is, it's incredible. Take for example his own chart showing FTE and not headcount whilst it's been highlighted that actual numbers are falling. This translates to having less staff doing more hours, think of the simple overtime figure when you try and wonder where all of the money's gone. Consider the burnout of those staff leading to an increased amount leaving the profession even though they stuck it out without the pay rises. It's endless, but for some reason he keeps coming out with the party line he's been fed on his twitter or WhatsApp groups to merrily spread the gospel around.
Reply
#26
(02-08-2023, 12:29 PM)baggy1 Wrote: There are so many angles here that Proth should look at and realise what the actual problem is, it's incredible. Take for example his own chart showing FTE and not headcount whilst it's been highlighted that actual numbers are falling. This translates to having less staff doing more hours, think of the simple overtime figure when you try and wonder where all of the money's gone. Consider the burnout of those staff leading to an increased amount leaving the profession even though they stuck it out without the pay rises. It's endless, but for some reason he keeps coming out with the party line he's been fed on his twitter or WhatsApp groups to merrily spread the gospel around.

How dare you l, he’s left the party!
Reply
#27
Least worst, nuance.

Sink estate.

Buy gold.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#28
One of the major angles missed by public sector fetishists is that the adoption of technology has transformed every other service industry in the country, and enabled any competent firm to do far more with far less.

Whereas productivity in the Public Sector is heading south again after a brief respite. Public bureaucracy and public bureaucrats in this country are by and large fucking hopeless - as illustrated by the OP.

As an example the DVLA has as many employees as it did in 2008 - today I've put a plate on retention on the internet, tomorrow I could renew my licence online and the following day I could tax my new car online after transferring ownership online. None of these things were possible just a few years ago - yet the DVLA still employs the same number of people and is constantly criticised for not even being able to deal with driving licence applications. Why?

(02-08-2023, 12:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: How dare you l, he’s left the party!

I've also departed the cesspit that is Twitter and the only WhatsApp groups I'm left on are about Cheltenham.
Reply
#29
Change in tack there I see and focussed criticism of one very small department in context of the state. Did you get around to explaining how the adoption of technology could help schools or improve nurses conditions. The Police took a very specific approach to focussing on cyber crime and took coppers off the streets, that didn't work very well.

I'll repeat what I said earlier, you keep focussing on outsourcing state services which will ultimately cost more and you'll arrive at a point where the services that are left can't do the basic things well. When the DVLA has had pay freezes for the last decade, they will have lost the staff that were any good to the private sector, don't spend your time promoting reduced budgets and then complain at the outcome that was always going to be so.
Reply
#30
Not really a change in tack, just an example.

If the DVLA's paper based work has fallen precipitously (it has) then they could halve the workforce and pay them double. It could be an experiment in whether paying people more makes them more productive. Somehow, I doubt it would.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)