England v South Africa
#21
(09-11-2022, 06:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: A mockery of test cricket. I appreciate that conditions were favourable to bowlers, especially yesterday but the pathetic batting of the first 3 innings would have curdled Boycott's blood. Whilst not advocating his approach it seems worldwide test batting has succumbed to the saturation of limited over cricket.

5 day tests are a rarity and the art of test cricket is gradually wilting. A 4 innings test virtually done and dusted in 2 days! Farcical. Cricket as a whole is doing nothing to stop the erosion of the ultimate form of the sport by allowing more and more of the short form.

In the "olden days" often 100 overs were bowled in a day.  Now they struggle to get 80 overs
Reply
#22
(09-11-2022, 06:58 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(09-11-2022, 06:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: A mockery of test cricket. I appreciate that conditions were favourable to bowlers, especially yesterday but the pathetic batting of the first 3 innings would have curdled Boycott's blood. Whilst not advocating his approach it seems worldwide test batting has succumbed to the saturation of limited over cricket.

5 day tests are a rarity and the art of test cricket is gradually wilting. A 4 innings test virtually done and dusted in 2 days! Farcical. Cricket as a whole is doing nothing to stop the erosion of the ultimate form of the sport by allowing more and more of the short form.

Sorry have to disagree I’m old school but this form of test cricket is what was needed. It’s great to watch instead of Boycott and Barrington making 175 in a day. Most fans nowadays want entertainment and I love it. Brendon McCullan and Ben Stokes are the best thing to happen to Test cricket in generations. Well done to Rob Key. You only have to see the the look on the players faces. As you can see I’m all for it.

I already stated that I am not advocating Boycott's approach but we are getting to the stage where we struggle even to get 50 overs per innings. The game has to evolve but not to the stage where it becomes a homogenised product right across the board.
Reply
#23
(09-11-2022, 07:01 PM)Baggybenny Wrote:
(09-11-2022, 06:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: A mockery of test cricket. I appreciate that conditions were favourable to bowlers, especially yesterday but the pathetic batting of the first 3 innings would have curdled Boycott's blood. Whilst not advocating his approach it seems worldwide test batting has succumbed to the saturation of limited over cricket.

5 day tests are a rarity and the art of test cricket is gradually wilting. A 4 innings test virtually done and dusted in 2 days! Farcical. Cricket as a whole is doing nothing to stop the erosion of the ultimate form of the sport by allowing more and more of the short form.

In the "olden days" often 100 overs were bowled in a day.  Now they struggle to get 80 overs

That only makes it worse 100 overs and 175 runs much prefere today’s cricket. So do the players.
Reply
#24
(09-11-2022, 07:30 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(09-11-2022, 07:01 PM)Baggybenny Wrote:
(09-11-2022, 06:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: A mockery of test cricket. I appreciate that conditions were favourable to bowlers, especially yesterday but the pathetic batting of the first 3 innings would have curdled Boycott's blood. Whilst not advocating his approach it seems worldwide test batting has succumbed to the saturation of limited over cricket.

5 day tests are a rarity and the art of test cricket is gradually wilting. A 4 innings test virtually done and dusted in 2 days! Farcical. Cricket as a whole is doing nothing to stop the erosion of the ultimate form of the sport by allowing more and more of the short form.

In the "olden days" often 100 overs were bowled in a day.  Now they struggle to get 80 overs

That only makes it worse 100 overs and 175 runs much prefere today’s cricket. So do the players.

You're easily pleased. I hope test cricket can be recovered because as many would agree it is the ultimate test of the sport.  Limited overs cricket provides necessary variety but it has its own place in the sport.. hopefully not to the detriment of the ultimate form.
Reply
#25
Seems to me that Bazball is the future. if we can play all our matches in England, if Stokes can win the toss and bowl first every time, if Broad and Anderson can play forever, if Stokes' knee doesn't lock permanently, if opposing captains can always make perplexingly self-destructive decisions about matters such as team selection, whether to bat or bowl and when to review umpires' calls - well we're pretty much unbeatable.

The not-very-likeable Ben Stokes has walked on water this summer. I wonder if it can last in Pakistan, or when the Aussies get here?
Reply
#26
(09-11-2022, 06:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: A mockery of test cricket. I appreciate that conditions were favourable to bowlers, especially yesterday but the pathetic batting of the first 3 innings would have curdled Boycott's blood. Whilst not advocating his approach it seems worldwide test batting has succumbed to the saturation of limited over cricket.

5 day tests are a rarity and the art of test cricket is gradually wilting. A 4 innings test virtually done and dusted in 2 days! Farcical. Cricket as a whole is doing nothing to stop the erosion of the ultimate form of the sport by allowing more and more of the short form.

Here she goes again

I’m sure If India had pulled this off you would be waxing lyrical?

The series is 1-1 and you’ve got 3 days to try and win a test match and the series, how the hell are you meant to approach it? 

Needs must, if you’re 2-1 down in extra time you don’t keep playing around the back four do you FFS?

Massive credit to the team for winning the series, especially after being hammered in the first test

Im no real fan of ODI, 20/20, IPL or The Hundred, test cricket all day long for me but if you have to get a result in 3 days this is a massive mission accomplished in my book and as hard as it always is for you a bit of credit where credits due eh?

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#27
Good post Cuser. I thought yesterday that a gentlemanly declaration with scores level-ish could give the fans a result. I was wrong. I love Test match cricket.
Reply
#28
(09-11-2022, 10:59 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(09-11-2022, 06:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: A mockery of test cricket. I appreciate that conditions were favourable to bowlers, especially yesterday but the pathetic batting of the first 3 innings would have curdled Boycott's blood. Whilst not advocating his approach it seems worldwide test batting has succumbed to the saturation of limited over cricket.

5 day tests are a rarity and the art of test cricket is gradually wilting. A 4 innings test virtually done and dusted in 2 days! Farcical. Cricket as a whole is doing nothing to stop the erosion of the ultimate form of the sport by allowing more and more of the short form.

Here she goes again

I’m sure If India had pulled this off you would be waxing lyrical?

The series is 1-1 and you’ve got 3 days to try and win a test match and the series, how the hell are you meant to approach it? 

Needs must, if you’re 2-1 down in extra time you don’t keep playing around the back four do you FFS?

Massive credit to the team for winning the series, especially after being hammered in the first test

Im no real fan of ODI, 20/20, IPL or The Hundred, test cricket all day long for me but if you have to get a result in 3 days this is a massive mission accomplished in my book and as hard as it always is for you a bit of credit where credits due eh?

Cuzer
First of all show a little respect. If you know how. 

Seems no matter what i post you will reply with dergatory tones. I think I know why.

The first thing a captain does is try not to lose the series ... clearly Saffers batting was awful, the bowling was good on both sides and England will not waiver from Bazball. But if you can call that test cricket then it's differentt to how I see it. It's a matter of opinion so no need to be rude and condescending ... but that is your default setting it seems .

Even the commentators were critical of the approach tobatting. But of course you know better ...in all matters you are the font of all knowledge.

As for if India doing the same, I would be delighted they won but as an earlier post intimated you would worry how long this approach can be maintained when factors do not fall in your favour.
Reply
#29
(09-12-2022, 06:50 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(09-11-2022, 10:59 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(09-11-2022, 06:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: A mockery of test cricket. I appreciate that conditions were favourable to bowlers, especially yesterday but the pathetic batting of the first 3 innings would have curdled Boycott's blood. Whilst not advocating his approach it seems worldwide test batting has succumbed to the saturation of limited over cricket.

5 day tests are a rarity and the art of test cricket is gradually wilting. A 4 innings test virtually done and dusted in 2 days! Farcical. Cricket as a whole is doing nothing to stop the erosion of the ultimate form of the sport by allowing more and more of the short form.

Here she goes again

I’m sure If India had pulled this off you would be waxing lyrical?

The series is 1-1 and you’ve got 3 days to try and win a test match and the series, how the hell are you meant to approach it? 

Needs must, if you’re 2-1 down in extra time you don’t keep playing around the back four do you FFS?

Massive credit to the team for winning the series, especially after being hammered in the first test

Im no real fan of ODI, 20/20, IPL or The Hundred, test cricket all day long for me but if you have to get a result in 3 days this is a massive mission accomplished in my book and as hard as it always is for you a bit of credit where credits due eh?

Cuzer
First of all show a little respect. If you know how. 

Seems no matter what i post you will reply with dergatory tones. I think I know why.

The first thing a captain does is try not to lose the series ... clearly Saffers batting was awful, the bowling was good on both sides and England will not waiver from Bazball. But if you can call that test cricket then it's differentt to how I see it. It's a matter of opinion so no need to be rude and condescending ... but that is your default setting it seems .

Even the commentators were critical of the approach tobatting. But of course you know better ...in all matters you are the font of all knowledge.

As for if India doing the same, I would be delighted they won but as an earlier post intimated you would worry how long this approach can be maintained when factors do not fall in your favour.

I think that's the difference though, RS. Stokes and McCullum are trying their best to find a way to win games on the front foot as opposed to blocking and eventually getting out and losing anyway. You're right, we'll have to see how this pans out on other climates but I would prefer we go out to win than not to lose otherwise, what's the point?
Reply
#30
England could have won it by a innings by now if they'd have adapted their game to the situation whilst batting.

I've nothing against any form of cricket, attacking or defending but play the situation in front of you. It's not one size fits all and there will be times the situation calls for a different approach. Stokes has had some woeful dismissals this summer advancing down the wicket to good bowlers. Show a little respect and earn some decent runs, he's one of three decent batsmen we've got. He can't keep getting 20 in 10 balls and getting out.

As for the decision to come off for light. If the South Africans were that desperate to get home they should have stayed on for another twenty minutes and they could have been on this mornings flight to Jo'burg! Test cricket is a brilliant game but it really doesn't help itself sometimes.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: