Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
03-21-2022, 08:05 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-21-2022, 08:07 PM by backsidebaggie.)
(03-21-2022, 07:53 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not taking waning of those jabs into account at all there. My missus had her booster in November and has got covid now, not pleasant but not hospital worthy so she built up her immunity somehow. The only way was by being jabbed. Also I haven’t caught it off her despite living in the same house, I’m in the spare room whilst she’s got this. How would I have built up such immunity without having had the jab?
And before you say that I’ve probably had it and was asymptomatic it’s probably worth pointing out that because the MIL has COPD I’ve been testing weekly since they have been dishing out the test kits.
I don’t think anecdotal evidence like that means a lot to be fair. I know a shit load of people who have had no vaccines and had mild covid (all somewhere between very mild and not pleasant but not hospital similar to your mrs). Some family members didn’t get it in their cases too despite being under the same roof. In most cases they all got it and all were okay anyhow. Granted they were all under 55, and it may have been different if they’d have been 70-80. But they haven’t had the vaccine to build up immunity like your mrs yet some were less ill than your description of her. So to say the only way she’s okay is by being jabbed is totally wrong. Most people under 55 are fine within a week, jabbed or not. That’s the stats saying that, not me. But likewise that doesn’t mean the vaccine does nothing.
It doesnt seem very good at stopping transmission to be fair. It’s better at preventing very serious illness from the statistics I can see.
Posts: 994
Threads: 36
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
03-21-2022, 08:09 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-21-2022, 08:11 PM by baggiebuckster.)
I don't think that proves anything to be honest. I don't know her general health status but I saw that you mentioned she was in bed with it so must not be feeling too great. I hope that she soon feels better.
I must have had some form of immunity too as I caught it last week but it barely touched me. In fact all 4 of us caught it and it took nearly two weeks before it got me having initially infected my two lads and then my wife. I don't think it is so easy to explain as none of us were really impacted beyond an initial 12 hour period of either a temperature or in my case feeling cold. My two lads are not jabbed, my wife has had two and as you know I have had one.
Waning immunity must play a part but we seem to have hit a time where millions will need boosting again to reduce transmission but how many will do that? There are plenty who stopped on two jabs and plenty more will stop on three.
Anyhow as I said I am not here to argue - I hope your wife recovers soon and you manage to avoid it.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
03-21-2022, 08:13 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-21-2022, 08:14 PM by backsidebaggie.)
It’s just a weird illness. You can have no immunity and get it very mild (like literally hundreds of thousands did in the first 10 months of the pandemic). Others get poleaxed and it attacks their organs. It’s a weird unpredictable virus for sure.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
I think we have to view it like this, whatever your views on the jab it is pretty clear that it has spread the time that everyone gets covid by delaying infection in a large number of people. I wish people would stop saying that it doesn’t stop transmission, it was never meant to do that, it was to reduce transmission and it has succeeded in that.
I’m of the view also that it’s too early to say if it’s a good idea to stop dishing it out yet, we have an unusually high number of cases for the time of year, and just having had the original superspreader event again the next couple of weeks should be watched carefully.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(03-21-2022, 08:22 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I think we have to view it like this, whatever your views on the jab it is pretty clear that it has spread the time that everyone gets covid by delaying infection in a large number of people. I wish people would stop saying that it doesn’t stop transmission, it was never meant to do that, it was to reduce transmission and it has succeeded in that.
I’m of the view also that it’s too early to say if it’s a good idea to stop dishing it out yet, we have an unusually high number of cases for the time of year, and just having had the original superspreader event again the next couple of weeks should be watched carefully.
I don’t think the statistics suggest it’s good at reducing transmission. It’s probably had some effect though, but not huge.
I think it was hoped it would be way better.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
You’ll have to point out theses stats to me because everything I’ve read and have seen since we’ve had the jab had shown a big improvement in the way we have been able to get about.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(03-21-2022, 08:32 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You’ll have to point out theses stats to me because everything I’ve read and have seen since we’ve had the jab had shown a big improvement in the way we have been able to get about.
Compring countries for a start. Transimission has gone through the roof in Oz and NZ, as they have little natural immunity, but massive vaccine rates. So is natural immunity imprrving things more here? Or just the fact its now milder? A combination probably.
Countries with jab passports in the summer didn't fair any better than us (in fact most were worse), and the idea of that was that those jabbed were safer to mingle in places as it reduces transmission. Didn't work round Europe. Scotland's own study found they had no positive effect, and the passports were based on exactly the point that they reduced transmission.
I certainly haven't seen that its made a huge difference in stopping transmission. Some perhaps, but not huge. And very disappointing compared to what was originally hoped by many people.
The fact we're now free to get about is about way way more factors than their reduction in transmission. Partly partygate for a start!
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
There are a 7 day average of less than 50k in Australia and over 100k in the UK, which do you think is doing better? Of course they were going to go ‘through the roof’, they started from zero. Now its about half the population and a bit of the UK so being fair that pretty much balances out the figures, so basically an area that had next to no transmission and the jab is the same as an area that had lots of transmission and the jab which surely indicates that the transmission isn’t the key figure here its the jab which has worked well.
If you can seriously say that the jab didn’t slow down the spread of covid then you seriously need to stop looking at this because you’ve got lost down the rabbit hole. The jab meant that we slowed down the transmission which slowed down the hospitalisation, which slowed down the death rate from covid, that also gave our bodies time to deal with the virus and build up a natural immunity. If you want to believe it was just a coincidence that the virus just weakened at exactly the same time that we introduce jabs then you really need to stop looking for reasons to argue against the jab and simply get on with your life and leave the rest of us in our blissful ignorance thinking it did.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(03-21-2022, 09:57 PM)baggy1 Wrote: There are a 7 day average of less than 50k in Australia and over 100k in the UK, which do you think is doing better? Of course they were going to go ‘through the roof’, they started from zero. Now its about half the population and a bit of the UK so being fair that pretty much balances out the figures, so basically an area that had next to no transmission and the jab is the same as an area that had lots of transmission and the jab which surely indicates that the transmission isn’t the key figure here its the jab which has worked well.
If you can seriously say that the jab didn’t slow down the spread of covid then you seriously need to stop looking at this because you’ve got lost down the rabbit hole. The jab meant that we slowed down the transmission which slowed down the hospitalisation, which slowed down the death rate from covid, that also gave our bodies time to deal with the virus and build up a natural immunity. If you want to believe it was just a coincidence that the virus just weakened at exactly the same time that we introduce jabs then you really need to stop looking for reasons to argue against the jab and simply get on with your life and leave the rest of us in our blissful ignorance thinking it did.
I didn’t say it didn’t slow it down, I said it’s not been very good at it. I also provided examples relating to the use of covid passports round Europe which were precisely based on it slowing transmission. They didn’t work.
I believe it slowed hospitalisation and death rate through having an effect on severe cases, not because it’s good against transmission. I think many would agree with me. That’s not arguing against it in the slightest. I’m not looking for reasons to argue against it. I’m not against it. I firmly believe it reduces severe cases. The rabbit hole comment is silly IMO, I’ll ignore that.
I don’t particularly look at it very deeply any more because like most people I just get on with life. My experience in Birmingham is that the majority (certainly under 50 years old) don’t give covid much thought any more, and haven’t for over a year now. Barely a mask in sight, low booster take up in under 40s. Again, I’m not arguing the rights and wrongs of that, that’s just the impression I get.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Sorry bb but you don't make sense with what you are saying. On one hand you say you don't look at it very deeply anymore and on the other hand you say that you know enough to state that the vaccines haven't been very effective. Then to support your statement you quote Australia as an example of where they have a high vaccination rate and cases are 'through the roof'. When we dive into that it shows that Australia has half the number of cases of the UK and by your own admission very little natural immunity, they also have a current death rate which is half the rate of England - how can this be with so little natural immunity. The answer is very simple in that the vaccine does work and it is very effective in slowing transmission, if it wasn't a country with little to no natural immunity, and completely reliant on the vaccine would be in a much worse position than a country, such as the UK, with lots of vaccinations plus the natural immunity.
|