How did Val survive today and what now?
#21
(01-29-2022, 11:09 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: I have never seen such wishful thinking across the same posters time after time.

Rightly or wrongly Val has been given a long contract and tasked with overhauling the squad.  He has been given his first choice £7million pound striker.  That striker has got injured so the board have sanctioned the signing of Carroll to play that role whilst Dike recovers.  They did this AFTER an utterly abject performance which lost a number of fans and Val pretty much admitted was a nadir in his career to date.

Despite these facts some posters seem to think his job is at risk if we lose today??  That Val has allready been sacked but Carrol has been left for the incoming like a 6"4 booby prize!

I think it was obvious they wouldn’t sack him and have said so a number of times but that doesn’t mean it’s the right decision. 

Results judged against resources should be the only factor that determines a managers tenure. Currently he’s doing a very poor job in this respect. 

It’s easy to hide behind ‘projects’ it kicks the can down the road with no guarantee of success. Some, it could be argued are exhibiting wishful thinking that simply allowing a manager time is some guarantee of success. 

If fans don’t see an improvement in results and to a lesser extent entertainment from now on they won’t accept any notion of a long term plan. Why should they? It’s not reactionary to worry about our short term future when it’s linked directly to TV money, which in turn is linked directly to the clubs medium and long term future. Personally I have seen little over the last few months that the manager can turn things around.
Reply
#22
I think the empty seats and emptying ground tell ts own story. I didn't know whether we've been spoiled over the years or have unrealistic expectations but lack of decent results coupled to an abject footballing style do not bode well. Many people could forgive Val's methods when we were winning but now we're sliding I cannot see how he can survive the season if we end up with a team that hate the way he wants them to play, and a support base that sees even less point in it. Whether the players are not good enough or not it's still a recipe for disaster.

We've been told the players are behind him, that they're not behind him, that they're confused, unhappy with his style or if they question it they're in the stiffs. Whatever the truth of any of these one thing's for sure it isn't pretty and it isn't working.
Reply
#23
(01-29-2022, 11:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-29-2022, 11:09 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: I have never seen such wishful thinking across the same posters time after time.

Rightly or wrongly Val has been given a long contract and tasked with overhauling the squad.  He has been given his first choice £7million pound striker.  That striker has got injured so the board have sanctioned the signing of Carroll to play that role whilst Dike recovers.  They did this AFTER an utterly abject performance which lost a number of fans and Val pretty much admitted was a nadir in his career to date.

Despite these facts some posters seem to think his job is at risk if we lose today??  That Val has allready been sacked but Carrol has been left for the incoming like a 6"4 booby prize!

I think it was obvious they wouldn’t sack him and have said so a number of times but that doesn’t mean it’s the right decision. 

Results judged against resources should be the only factor that determines a managers tenure. Currently he’s doing a very poor job in this respect. 

It’s easy to hide behind ‘projects’ it kicks the can down the road with no guarantee of success. Some, it could be argued are exhibiting wishful thinking that simply allowing a manager time is some guarantee of success. 

If fans don’t see an improvement in results and to a lesser extent entertainment from now on they won’t accept any notion of a long term plan. Why should they? It’s not reactionary to worry about our short term future when it’s linked directly to TV money, which in turn is linked directly to the clubs medium and long term future. Personally I have seen little over the last few months that the manager can turn things around.

Can't say I disagree Dekka.  I'm wasnt commenting on those who think he should be sacked.  That's their personal opinion, and a more than fair one given results and performance.

I was commenting more on those who think he has been sacked allready or that this is a must win game for him to keep his job when ALL the evidence suggests otherwise.   

Of course, I could be, and often am wrong on more than just football Smile
Reply
#24
I do think that the number injuries and covid cases in the team mean that the judgment of the last few months is very harsh. We have gone into games missing 10 starters at times, other clubs have managed to postpone games but we haven't done so.

We were never going to piss the league, but we should be closer to Fulham and Bournemouth.

Falling out with players hasn't helped and if Val goes it will be due to poor decisions made well before he came here, these players will be taking home cash without having to sweat for it for years to come.
Reply
#25
(01-29-2022, 11:56 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
(01-29-2022, 11:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-29-2022, 11:09 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: I have never seen such wishful thinking across the same posters time after time.

Rightly or wrongly Val has been given a long contract and tasked with overhauling the squad.  He has been given his first choice £7million pound striker.  That striker has got injured so the board have sanctioned the signing of Carroll to play that role whilst Dike recovers.  They did this AFTER an utterly abject performance which lost a number of fans and Val pretty much admitted was a nadir in his career to date.

Despite these facts some posters seem to think his job is at risk if we lose today??  That Val has allready been sacked but Carrol has been left for the incoming like a 6"4 booby prize!

I think it was obvious they wouldn’t sack him and have said so a number of times but that doesn’t mean it’s the right decision. 

Results judged against resources should be the only factor that determines a managers tenure. Currently he’s doing a very poor job in this respect. 

It’s easy to hide behind ‘projects’ it kicks the can down the road with no guarantee of success. Some, it could be argued are exhibiting wishful thinking that simply allowing a manager time is some guarantee of success. 

If fans don’t see an improvement in results and to a lesser extent entertainment from now on they won’t accept any notion of a long term plan. Why should they? It’s not reactionary to worry about our short term future when it’s linked directly to TV money, which in turn is linked directly to the clubs medium and long term future. Personally I have seen little over the last few months that the manager can turn things around.

Can't say I disagree Dekka.  I'm wasnt commenting on those who think he should be sacked.  That's their personal opinion, and a more than fair one given results and performance.

I was commenting more on those who think he has been sacked allready or that this is a must win game for him to keep his job when ALL the evidence suggests otherwise.   

Of course, I could be, and often am wrong on more than just football Smile

Point taken LLF, I am guilty of quoting one person but answering / being argumentative / contrary with regards to a number of posters points. It’s a bad habit I need to get out of and with regards to your point I completely agree the club will not wanting to admit they’ve made a mistake until it’s absolutely obvious for all to see they have or it’s really fecking their ‘investment’ up. Sacking today even if we lose, I doubt will see the manager leaving.
Reply
#26
I'm so proud.

My pro Pulis, anti project and philosophy bot has gained self awareness. A breakthrough in Computer Science!







Sorry Derek...
Reply
#27
(01-29-2022, 01:09 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm so proud.

My pro Pulis, anti project and philosophy bot has gained self awareness. A breakthrough in Computer Science!







Sorry Derek...

I’ve always had self awareness hence my username Wink
Reply
#28
(01-29-2022, 12:02 PM)sickParrot Wrote: I do think that the number injuries and covid cases in the team mean that the judgment of the last few months is very harsh. We have gone into games missing 10 starters at times, other clubs have managed to postpone games but we haven't done so.

We were never going to piss the league, but we should be closer to Fulham and Bournemouth.

Falling out with players hasn't helped and if Val goes it will be due to poor decisions made well before he came here, these players will be taking home cash without having to sweat for it for years to come.

I was of a similar mindset. I felt injuries and suspensions were derailing us but once these cleared up we’d be back. I cut him that slack. 
However, seemingly falling out with Johnstone, which I suspect demotivated the players, leading to the Preston shocker finished me with him. 
There’s bad luck and then creating your bad luck. 
That said if he’s eaten humble pie and got the players backing again let’s see where we go from here. 
I’m desperate for him to prove all of us wrong.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: