Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(01-11-2022, 12:54 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: I would hope we give Morton a go next season (he is older than Dike), Fellows and Taylor will hopefully get a chance as well
I like Clarke but we are well covered in defence and would spend the money , which will be in short supply, on midfielders and attackers unless any defenders leaves.
Would let Livermore go if he is out of contract and Phillips because he is injury prone. I assume (and hope) Hugill, Snodgrass and Zohore will be gone and we have learnt our lesson in signing journeymen player on the way down, I am sure we have not!
Would only sign players to whom WBA represents a move up, together with a few young loanees from premier clubs (like Barnes)
Simply has to be the centre of our recruitment philosophy.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Also, we should reverse the policy of the last few years and only sign players that are better than the ones they replace.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
In the case of Hugill and Zohore is that not setting the bar a bit low!
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
Well, this is all well and good, but what if we get promoted?
In many ways this will hamper the development of many of the youngsters being mentioned and we end up with a heap of loans like we had last season with Gallagher, Maitland-Niles, Diane and Yokuslu.
Posts: 1,372
Threads: 13
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
A lot depends on which league we are in, but I'd be interested in signing Clarke permanently, I think overall he has done well and contributed to a much stronger defence. I'd sign Molumby if we stayed in the championship and he was cheap, but let him go back if we went up. I think we will sign him either way though.
I've never been a fan of Furlong, he isn't great defensively in a 4 and he isn't good enough going forwards as a RWB. An OK squad player but we would be so much more dangerous with a proper attacking RWB who can cross. I'm annoyed we haven't tested Philips in that position personally.
We need a creative midfielder, but I'm not sure we will target one. The midfield 2 is here to stay and I'd imagine Val will want someone similar to Mowatt to play on the right hand side. Someone like Mulumbu would be perfect
I'd also be hesitant to give Griffiths/Palmer/Button the no1 shirt. Especially if we ended up getting promoted. I'd be tempted to give Griffiths one final loan spell perhaps to a lower championship side. Palmer hasn't had a look in all season which is worrying and if he's behind Button now then I'd imagine he will be off.
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
01-11-2022, 02:23 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-11-2022, 02:30 PM by Lillwall's left foot.)
(01-11-2022, 10:19 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: A few of us have consistently said that we need another window to sort the squad out so it can be competitive. What do you see us needing and who would be the core of the squad that remains? I genuinely don't think what league we are in matters, as it will just effect the quality of the incomings require.
For me:
GK - SJ, Palmer/Griffiths (one out on loan), Button
No signings needed, SJ I think will be gone regardless. Button as back up, one of the promising lads as #1
CB - Kipre, Bartley, O'Shea, Ajayi, Kean Bryan, Clarke
Ajayi seems to have lost his way and always seems to have a clanger in him. Lost his place to Kipre who has improved game upon game. If Clarke is available at the right price I wouldn't be against signing him as the replacement for Bartley in the middle fo the back 3, but not to play LCB. I think we need at least 1 or potentially 2 new players with the right profile here as none of the younger players seem able to me. +1
LB/LWB - Townsend, Reach
I think we need a new LWB in this system, somebody in the Rico Henry, Anthonee Robinson mould. Lots of pace, ability to dribble and cross. +1
RB/RWB - Furlong
A real weak area of the squad. Furlong is a capable squad player and I think could make a good RCB, but as on the left we need a more capable attacking full/wingback. +1
CM - Mowatt, TGH, Snoddy, Livermore, Molumby
Real issue for us and where some real money will be spent in close season. The 3 left above need to be complimented by 2 new signings. +2
FW,L/R - Grant, Robinson, Phillips, Diangana
We need an out and out right sided forward, with blistering pace and power. +1
CF - Dike, Hugill, Zahore, Cleary
As long as DK is as good as we all hope, we will only need one other signing. Hopefully we will see the emergence of Cleary if/when he signs his new contract as the 3rd option. +1
I look at Reach and Livermore as utility players and 2 perfect subs, as between them they can pretty much fill in all over the pitch bar in goal and CF, and regardless of the hate Jake gets he is a passionate advocate of the club and is a positive influence around the place and rarely lets us down.
So in my opinion we need 7 ins/outs. Hopefully the Cleary for Hugill will happen this month, and perhaps a CM in for Snoddy. That would leave 5 lots of ins and outs for the summer, which is more than doable.
Agree with a lot of that, although im struggling to look past this year A few additional onions....
GK - Totally dependent on how the management view Griffiths. Is he ready?
Defence - I'd also let Semi go for a fee and keep Clarke. After that it's all about how good O'shea can be.
Townsend is a decent LB and arguably our most saleable asset. Wouldn't want to lose him but if a value was matched he could be replaced with a more dynamic wing back.
Furlong is an odd one. Looks a good athlete, a decent defender and gets into some really good positions but his crossing and finishing needs much improvement to say the least. Good squad player but could be replaced by a specialist WB.
Midfield - hmmm. Probably need one to come in, but needs to be a GOOD one. A Mowatt mk2 with engine and attacking ability. Snodders no longer wanted here needs to go. Jake has another year? But shouldn't be immediate choice next year.
Wide players - With Phillips extending out to 2024 I can't see where there is room to make an addition? Grant and Robbo first choice. Then Phillips and Grady. Fellows and Tulloch. Grady is still the puzzle. We have a lot wrapped up in him financially but I'm worried we may never see the same player again from that 6 month purple patch. I think a loan back to London next year?
CF- We need support for Dike but Zahore is a financial handicap. He is taking up the wages of an top championship CF. Cleary is yet to sign and Val has made it clear he is not ready or able to play that role. Reliant on loans to back up Dike until Zahore's contract ends in summer 23. Bottom line is that w ith Zahore hogging wages and Huggy Bear still around we are reliant on Dike for the remainder of the season.
If we do fail to get promotion this year I would expect just a few ins and outs as above and for us to be ready to challenge again next year. We have few saleable assets so it should be this group that make up the nucleus.
If we get promoted? TBH fuck knows. The mind truly boggles as to what we might need to be genuinely competetive? After that first promotion we didn't actually worry too much and were quite content yo-yoing and taking the parachute money. Maybe that is where we are again?
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
01-11-2022, 02:42 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-11-2022, 02:43 PM by Hopalong.)
(01-11-2022, 10:52 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: (01-11-2022, 10:31 AM)MrFizz Wrote: Pretty decent assessment there. But i think Molumby is loan to perm, he'll be here. I think Jake might still be around but as CB cover. It seems to suit him.
As good a fullback as Townsend is he aint no wing-back. Might get some decent money for him to fund a couple.
I would have thought it's a loan to perm if both parties want to make it one? So far, other than a couple of decent cameos from the bench, I've been very underwhelmed with him. I think the fee is around £1m if I recall correctly? I'd like to think we could invest that amount more prudently with a lower league or overseas player. (Don't ask me who as don't watch enough footy these days - Someone on this forum has mentioned Kamara from Plymouth as an option?)
There's more than the usual number of Bosmans kicking around this coming summer. If we go up I suspect that's where our focus will be.
Sam will go so we'd need a new keeper, probably two as Button is nowhere near good enough and neither is Palmer (he needs to go) and too soon for Griffiths but he can take Palmer's place.
If we're playing 3-4-3 we'll need a left sided centre half, two proper wing-backs, two central midfielders (Yokuslu one hopefully) at least one striker and a right winger.
Out:
Johnstone (in Jan if we can, will never sign a contract)
Button
Palmer
Ajayi
Clarke (unless we can sign him - not convinced he's good enough!)
Sawyers
Livermore (but you just know we'll give him a new contract!
Molumby (not good enough for Prem)
Snodgrass (hopefully he'll be gone in the next couple of weeks but doubt it)
Zohore (just cancel his contract, doesn't look as if he's ever going to play football again, heart of a pea)
Diangana ( just cut our losses, simply not good enough - MLS maybe)
Tulloch - loan maybe to see if he develops (but looking like another Leko)
Most of the above are fringe players so no great loss and many can be replaced from the academy.
Posts: 9,616
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(01-11-2022, 01:06 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Well, this is all well and good, but what if we get promoted?
In many ways this will hamper the development of many of the youngsters being mentioned and we end up with a heap of loans like we had last season with Gallagher, Maitland-Niles, Diane and Yokuslu.
Doesn't change anything. The same weaknesses are there. But the calibre of incoming will obviously increase.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
I'm puzzled at how many don't rate Clarke. He is way better than anything else we have (not including O,Shea as he is out).
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(01-11-2022, 04:56 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'm puzzled at how many don't rate Clarke. He is way better than anything else we have (not including O,Shea as he is out).
Likewise, he's not perfect but he's still young-ish for a centre half. I can't see how we'd find a better left sided centre half to come and play for us at present. He's played his part in us being massively improved at the back this season.
|