Dean Smith - would love him at Albion
#21
SW4Baggie Wrote:I don’t want the bitter, cash spunking, excuse making, gammon faced Seal prick anywhere near our dugout!

same here.
Got lucky one time.  Inherited a good system at Brentford who have since improved massively since Smith left. 
Got lucky two times.  Inherited a very good player at villa that carried them to promotion, his best other midfielder was
signed by Bruce.   He, meanwhile has squandered millions on the likes of Wesley, Engels, Bastion (what a shocker!), Reina, Sansom and Drinkwater (seals the argument!)…..
Reply
#22
(11-07-2021, 01:42 PM)Duffers Wrote: Season one: Took a team from mid table to promotion.

Season two: Kept them up and reached a cup final.

Season three: Comfortably mid-table.

Nah, we don’t want that do we?

They were only mid-table because they had been crap due to Smith, then Greasy came back from injury and spearheaded their charge. Still only squeezed through the play-offs though due to a dodgy-ref against us, the shameful cheating antics of their players and a Fulham f-up due to an inept Parker in the final.

Last season they stayed up, nothing more, and only after spending more money than the GDP of many small countries.

This season they are crap.
Reply
#23
(11-07-2021, 01:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: So much disrespect to Moore too.

Moore did a miraculous job that summer he was appointed. He completely turned the squad around and kept them with the club, he bought in Townsend, Gayle and Barnes, the people in power at the club had no real shortlist to buy players from.

Smith would not have done a better job overall imo because of how bad we were that summer. We should have gone into free fall, as so many relegated clubs do, as Stoke did. Moore stopped that.

Moore was, and still is, a massive hero of mine.  He did a fantastic job as caretaker and once appointed I was not only fully behind him but also gutted and somewhat disgusted by the way both some fans and the club treated him:  watching that team of Barnes and Gayle was a joy at times (Sheff Wed is the first score I check at FT and I'd love to see him back in some capacity).  However, at that point before his appointment I felt that Smith had the right experience and would have been a good fit for the club. Not any more.
Reply
#24
(11-07-2021, 01:52 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-07-2021, 01:42 PM)Duffers Wrote: Season one: Took a team from mid table to promotion.

Season two: Kept them up and reached a cup final.

Season three: Comfortably mid-table.

Nah, we don’t want that do we?

He spent £350m and was entirely reliant on McGinn and Grealish who were there before he arrived.

No thanks.

Yet Grealish wasn’t bossing things before Smith arrived was he? Would be pretty churlish to suggest Smith hasn’t had some impact on his development.
Reply
#25
Not for me end of.
Reply
#26
(11-07-2021, 01:59 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
(11-07-2021, 01:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: So much disrespect to Moore too.

Moore did a miraculous job that summer he was appointed. He completely turned the squad around and kept them with the club, he bought in Townsend, Gayle and Barnes, the people in power at the club had no real shortlist to buy players from.

Smith would not have done a better job overall imo because of how bad we were that summer. We should have gone into free fall, as so many relegated clubs do, as Stoke did. Moore stopped that.

Moore was, and still is, a massive hero of mine.  He did a fantastic job as caretaker and once appointed I was not only fully behind him but also gutted and somewhat disgusted by the way both some fans and the club treated him:  watching that team of Barnes and Gayle was a joy at times.  However, at that point before his appointment I felt that Smith had the right experience and would have been a good fit for the club.

Moore was let down by his choice of staff, it makes me laugh people say he had to go because we weren't looking like getting promoted easily, but then say Bilic had 2 years to get us up. 

I know a Brebtford fan, they don't love Smith much at all really. Defensively they played like a pub team so often, if they went behind first, they weren't winning that game. If Woods or Sawyers was injured he might as well as thrown the game for it was as good as certain loss.
Reply
#27
(11-07-2021, 01:44 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(11-07-2021, 01:42 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Love him at The Albion?

No.

Would "accept" him at the Albion be, er, acceptable?

No.

Maybe he could do some cleaning.
Reply
#28
(11-07-2021, 01:42 PM)Duffers Wrote: Season one: Took a team from mid table to promotion.

Season two: Kept them up and reached a cup final.

Season three: Comfortably mid-table.

Nah, we don’t want that do we?

Grealish pretty much won them promotion single handed in his first season. When he was out injured from December to March, Vile couldn't buy a win and were miles off the play off places. As soon as he returns, they win ten on the bounce, get in the play offs and go up. He's been pretty much carrying them since as well until his move to City. Smith's not for me.
Reply
#29
(11-07-2021, 02:03 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(11-07-2021, 01:59 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
(11-07-2021, 01:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: So much disrespect to Moore too.

Moore did a miraculous job that summer he was appointed. He completely turned the squad around and kept them with the club, he bought in Townsend, Gayle and Barnes, the people in power at the club had no real shortlist to buy players from.

Smith would not have done a better job overall imo because of how bad we were that summer. We should have gone into free fall, as so many relegated clubs do, as Stoke did. Moore stopped that.

Moore was, and still is, a massive hero of mine.  He did a fantastic job as caretaker and once appointed I was not only fully behind him but also gutted and somewhat disgusted by the way both some fans and the club treated him:  watching that team of Barnes and Gayle was a joy at times.  However, at that point before his appointment I felt that Smith had the right experience and would have been a good fit for the club.

Moore was let down by his choice of staff, it makes me laugh people say he had to go because we weren't looking like getting promoted easily, but then say Bilic had 2 years to get us up. 

I know a Brebtford fan, they don't love Smith much at all really. Defensively they played like a pub team so often, if they went behind first, they weren't winning that game. If Woods or Sawyers was injured he might as well as thrown the game for it was as good as certain loss.

Yep, think it's been proven since that any success he did have at Brentford was as much to do with the model as his own coaching ability.
Reply
#30
Duffers Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:
Duffers Wrote:Season one: Took a team from mid table to promotion.

Season two: Kept them up and reached a cup final.

Season three: Comfortably mid-table.

Nah, we don’t want that do we?

He spent £350m and was entirely reliant on McGinn and Grealish who were there before he arrived.

No thanks.

Yet Grealish wasn’t bossing things before Smith arrived was he? Would be pretty churlish to suggest Smith hasn’t had some impact on his development.
Wrong there Duffers. Grealish was always outstanding among peers, I know people at villa and they think he made it in spite of successive managements. Hence my constantly pointing out previously, he doesn't affect the game enough. Arguably, a bit of stern management and he may have avoided the many (often mysterious) injuries and been on the back pages of the Brum Mail more often than he was on the front ones.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: