Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
06-17-2021, 12:16 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2021, 12:19 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
Things don't look good at the minute, but depending on what camp you're in then it's a completely different lookout the future.
You could say the Chinese lost confidence in Dowling as he allowed poor recruitment last summer and then advised them Sam Allardyce will save us guaranteed.
They might think he's crap.
Alternatively, you could think the Chinese are idiots not able to run a piss up in a brewery and they are the fault.
I, like virtually all of us, haven't a clue.
Whatever way you look at it though it's a crossroads. If the right infrastructure is put in place then we can move on well as we have a lot of good things at the club, with still a strong Championship squad and strong finances.
However, if it's handled bad then this will soon go and we'll be trapped in the championship.
I'm just hoping for the best, because as Blues up the road have shown if it does go wrong there's little you can do.
I'll ignore the idiots on here who have never had to make any business decisions in their life and say it'll go to crap, because that's what the Albion are like.
All I'll say, is the one thing I'd welcome most now is Mark Jenkins rocking up.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(06-17-2021, 10:25 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Just said I'm worried.
Right now we're closer to doing a Stoke than going for promotion.
Completely agree.
We have some excellent players for this level, and as it stands, we still have Pereira and Johnstone, who the remaining board are making the right noises in terms of fees, but there are plenty of squads who've failed to realise their ability at this level despite having the talent to do well.
The one positive is that with it being a tournament summer, we have a little bit more of a grace period to get someone in. The market will be incredibly slow until mid July, and with pre-season being disrupted for a lot of clubs with tournament players being given additional time off, we can afford to take a bit more time without being left behind.
On paper, we need 2-3 first team players to get this side top-6 ready and we ought to be able to do that without too much fuss given the budget we have at our disposal. Also, the highly publicised manner of our relegation last season will mean any potential coach willl be incredibly aware of the deficiencies in the squad and will no doubt have a roadmap for fixing those gaping holes.
I'd like us to be a lot more unified than we currently are, but I'm not overly worried yet. We have enough money and enough talent in the squad to ride this out unless our owners get it spectacularly wrong (which they are more than capable of doing!)
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(06-17-2021, 11:52 AM)Squid Wrote: (06-17-2021, 11:16 AM)Duffers Wrote: (06-17-2021, 11:13 AM)wba13 Wrote: But we’re not the only ones without a manager, Crystal Palace, no nearer, Everton possible with Benitez, Bournemouth been without manager longer than us. We will hopefully get this right in the end. Just remember Wagner used us. The Wilder situation there must be something wrong when you see other clubs are not trying to employ him. I wanted Wider but I am somehow glad that Lai vetoed this appointment I’m also glad to see the back of Dowling, something just wasn’t right because of the liked Instagram posts when he left. We have to hope the club get it right in the end but on that only time will tell.
Those clubs haven’t sacked the guy in charge of looking for the manager.
How peculiar that this was the main concern of the article.
This particular quote jumped out at me:
"That Dowling stayed in his position after such a decision was made above his head is testament to how much he wanted to get West Brom into a stronger position than that in which he found them."
What a wonderful, dedicated employee that Luke Dowling sounds! Absolutely not at all a technical director who presided over an atrocious PL season and who the ex-academy staff clearly despise.
Wording this carefully, but I do not think it beyond the bounds of possibility that Dowling has been leaking our woes to the press to make himself look better prior to his inevitable departure.
I am not one of those who hated Dowling. I thought he did some things well and others less so. But he shares in the blame for last season and this painting himself as a victim because the boss did what bosses do (make the final decision) is very foolish.
We could always replace him with Matt Hancock.
Posts: 8,078
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
06-17-2021, 01:54 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2021, 02:10 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
"That Dowling stayed in his position"? He hasn't - instead he's run off!
I've been unconvinced by Dowling for a while, and the more I'm reading doesn't really change that. He presided over an awful Prem campaign, before which he and Bilic clearly struggled with a unanimous brief. As stated elsewhere, if had he better ideas than Bilic on who we should sign, then he should have exercised greater authority. He didn't. It's arguable that he allowed Bilic to fail by mismanaging the summer at a boardroom level.
Once Bilic was determined not good enough (too late to make a meaningful difference) then he appointed another failure; having quite unceremoniously sacked Bilic on the same night he achieved one of his best results at City. Let's not forget what an embarrassing fuck-up this was. He and Allardyce slowly improved us, but who was pulling the reigns more to identify and get the right players in? And - in any case - it ultimately turned out to be a failure.
He's then basically sought-out Wilder and all but agreed to get him in despite not doing due-diligence with the owners, and been hung out to dry by his second choice in Wagner. Furthermore the reports from ex-youth system coaches is hardly flattering.
So there isn't a great deal of success he can point to with us really. It's certainly a blow that his role is vacant, but the bigger fuck-up was allowing us to be in this position. Which is one that he's helped to engineer.
A shambles of a situation that doesn’t reflect well upon us. But I’m hardly going to look back on him fondly. We’re worse off now than when he joined. Whether or not that’s all his fault is another issue, of course; but he took the role after all, and let two popular managers fail before failing not once but twice to secure long-term replacements for either.
Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
I reckon you've just about nailed it there, Hawks.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Wouldn't argue with that Hawks.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(06-17-2021, 01:54 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: "That Dowling stayed in his position"? He hasn't - instead he's run off!
I've been unconvinced by Dowling for a while, and the more I'm reading doesn't really change that. He presided over an awful Prem campaign, before which he and Bilic clearly struggled with a unanimous brief. As stated elsewhere, if had he better ideas than Bilic on who we should sign, then he should have exercised greater authority. He didn't. It's arguable that he allowed Bilic to fail by mismanaging the summer at a boardroom level.
Once Bilic was determined not good enough (too late to make a meaningful difference) then he appointed another failure; having quite unceremoniously sacked Bilic on the same night he achieved one of his best results at City. Let's not forget what an embarrassing fuck-up this was. He and Allardyce slowly improved us, but who was pulling the reigns more to identify and get the right players in? And - in any case - it ultimately turned out to be a failure.
He's then basically sought-out Wilder and all but agreed to get him in despite not doing due-diligence with the owners, and been hung out to dry by his second choice in Wagner. Furthermore the reports from ex-youth system coaches is hardly flattering.
So there isn't a great deal of success he can point to with us really. It's certainly a blow that his role is vacant, but the bigger fuck-up was allowing us to be in this position. Which is one that he's helped to engineer.
A shambles of a situation that doesn’t reflect well upon us. But I’m hardly going to look back on him fondly. We’re worse off now than when he joined. Whether or not that’s all his fault is another issue, of course; but he took the role after all, and let two popular managers fail before failing not once but twice to secure long-term replacements for either.
Fair post Hawks.
The biggest success of his career feels like managing to prevent the appointment of Alex Neil and holding out for Bilic who delivered success under a lot of pressure.
Sadly, the fact that his departure may well result in us appointing Alex Neil shows just how much of a failure his tenure has ultimately been.
Posts: 516
Threads: 23
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
1
Midfield is really weak at the moment ,I think the standard of midfield players brought in will define our season
Posts: 1,372
Threads: 13
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
The decision to get rid of Dowling is probably the correct one, but the reasoning and timings are way off. If they didn't rate him, why let him lead the search for a manager and not ditch him back in May. It now just looks like amateur hour and that nobody has a clue what they're doing. It can all be put to bed with 2 decent appointments, but I don't blame anyone for being sceptical that they will deliver them. This should be one of the most attractive jobs in the league, we have some very decent players for this level with a healthy budget, which will likely be even higher once Johnstone and Pereira move on. We're doing a great job at the moment of pissing away any advantage we should have over the others in the division.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
I don't think it's exactly pant wetting to have concerns at the paucity of options available to manage us, nor the fact we haven't anyone in place on the football side to help them out. Then the fact our two outstanding performers from last season are likely to leave and I wouldn't back anyone at the club to adequately replace them. Add to that the uncertainty of ownership and chuck in the constant streams of bad news coming out of the Academy and I understand perfectly why I feel pissed off with the club.
|