05-20-2021, 08:09 PM
(05-20-2021, 07:50 PM)Dumbo Wrote:(05-20-2021, 07:44 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:(05-20-2021, 03:29 PM)Dumbo Wrote:(05-20-2021, 03:26 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:(05-20-2021, 03:24 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Good luck to him.
Not a massive deal for me though, I think I’m one of the minority that rates Harper higher than Field.
If I could see what Harper is good at I might agree, but far too much a jack of all trades and is far too languid.
When Harper was getting rave reviews and man of the match awards, midway through the 18/19 season...he was very impressive. When we beat Villa away 0-2 in Feb of that season, his performance was outstanding. Granted he’s been nowhere near that form since.
Don’t forget the clamour for us to get him signed up and the clubs he was being linked to at the time.
For me, when I saw Harper at his best, he was better than when I’ve saw Field at his best.
Saying that, neither are currently at the level to play for us.
If that interest was genuine then he wouldn't have signed.
I seem to remember Andy McDermott being linked to Juventus when his contract was up with us. Which appeared to be the usual bullshit game of "Give this player a new contract because he is really good - honest".
It was reported by local and respected journos at the time that he had serious interest. Whether they turned in to serious offers, we don’t know. But the interest was there and that was based of his performances. He then signed a new contract here and we were all delighted.
Unfortunately for us, he’s regressed since then. Hopefully we can get him going again.
I've never been a fan of Harper myself. I used to watch him in the reserves prior to his breaking into the first team and he always looked clueless, in my opinion.
I saw him Iin the youth cup game against Chelsea when we lost 7-0. He was on loan at Blackburn at the time so was getting some first team experience. Again, he looked clueless.
I thought he played well in that Villa match you mention but I don't see that there is a player there. Certainly not without a decent coach who can teach him the fundamentals of midfield play.


