Roy
#21
(05-15-2021, 07:22 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: People have short memories of Roy’s time with us in that we were boring to watch at home and better on the road.

Never go back. It never ends well.

Never go back. It never ends well.

I told you I'd be back.
Reply
#22
I'd love Roy as DoF.
Reply
#23
(05-15-2021, 07:24 AM)DJPunkRoc Wrote:
(05-15-2021, 07:22 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: People have short memories of Roy’s time with us in that we were boring to watch at home and better on the road.

Never go back. It never ends well.

Never go back. It never ends well.

I told you I'd be back.

Big Grin
Reply
#24
(05-15-2021, 07:51 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I'd love Roy as DoF.

This
Reply
#25
(05-15-2021, 08:01 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(05-15-2021, 07:51 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I'd love Roy as DoF.

This

Why? 

Roy is as much of a coach as any manager around currently. He’s never really wanted to deal with the signings, scouting, medical projects... he’s happiest out on the training ground.

Just because Roy has been around a long time, managed in a lot of countries and knows how to set up a team to survive in the PL doesn’t mean he’s right for a DoF position at all... and all this talk about a wise older hand helping a young coach, that’s not the remit of a DoF... it’s to be at the forefront of football innovation and plot a long term strategy for a club.

We tried the old, experienced coach with a decent black book approach in Terry Burton. 

If Roy is coming back it’s as our Head Coach, or it’s as an advisor to someone like Appleton, but even then I can’t see the latter standing for that.
Reply
#26
Strangely enough, one of the things I remember about Roy's tenure is the 1-0 home defeat by Everton on New Years Day 2012. We conceded a Victor Anichebe goal after 87 minutes. Roy made one substitution (Dorrans for Brunt) at 90+2 minutes.

In the after match interview he was asked why he didn't make any substitutions to try and win the match. He replied "I didn't think there was any change I could make which would improve us. I didn't believe they would score".

I remember thinking it was about the lamest excuse for a 1-0 defeat I had ever heard. I'd rather have Meggo's increasingly hollow "Some managers would say they were disappointed. But disappointed isn't a big enough word".

Roy made us respectable and functional. His time with us laid the foundations for a long stay in the Premier League and it would probably have been much better for us if he had stayed longer. But he didn't inspire or excite at all, not one little bit. It would be a massive backwards step to appoint him again.
Reply
#27
(05-15-2021, 08:27 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Strangely enough, one of the things I remember about Roy's tenure is the 1-0 home defeat by Everton on New Years Day 2012. We conceded a Victor Anichebe goal after 87 minutes. Roy made one substitution (Dorrans for Brunt) at 90+2 minutes.

In the after match interview he was asked why he didn't make any substitutions to try and win the match. He replied "I didn't think there was any change I could make which would improve us. I didn't believe they would score".

I remember thinking it was about the lamest excuse for a 1-0 defeat I had ever heard. I'd rather have Meggo's increasingly hollow "Some managers would say they were disappointed. But disappointed isn't a big enough word".

Roy made us respectable and functional. His time with us laid the foundations for a long stay in the Premier League and it would probably have been much better for us if he had stayed longer. But he didn't inspire or excite at all, not one little bit. It would be a massive backwards step to appoint him again.

Seems to just be an honest response to the question. Completely valid IMO. I would much rather this than being bullshitted.

My issue with Roy coming back is that he's now 73. He's losing a little bit of his spark but more to the point, how long would he be able to give us? 2 seasons maybe? Then we're back to trying to find another manager again.
Reply
#28
(05-15-2021, 08:33 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-15-2021, 08:27 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Strangely enough, one of the things I remember about Roy's tenure is the 1-0 home defeat by Everton on New Years Day 2012. We conceded a Victor Anichebe goal after 87 minutes. Roy made one substitution (Dorrans for Brunt) at 90+2 minutes.

In the after match interview he was asked why he didn't make any substitutions to try and win the match. He replied "I didn't think there was any change I could make which would improve us. I didn't believe they would score".

I remember thinking it was about the lamest excuse for a 1-0 defeat I had ever heard. I'd rather have Meggo's increasingly hollow "Some managers would say they were disappointed. But disappointed isn't a big enough word".

Roy made us respectable and functional. His time with us laid the foundations for a long stay in the Premier League and it would probably have been much better for us if he had stayed longer. But he didn't inspire or excite at all, not one little bit. It would be a massive backwards step to appoint him again.

Seems to just be an honest response to the question. Completely valid IMO. I would much rather this than being bullshitted.

My issue with Roy coming back is that he's now 73. He's losing a little bit of his spark but more to the point, how long would he be able to give us? 2 seasons maybe? Then we're back to trying to find another manager again.

Whoever the next manager is, they probably won’t last 2 seasons.
Reply
#29
There seems to be a touch of revisionism creeping in about Roy. Yes we weren’t great to watch at times, especially in the first few months of his reign, but he also gave us some of our best moments in all of our time in the PL. The 5-1 at Wolves, wins over the Seals, going toe to toe with some of the big boys, establishing us as a proper top flight outfit for the first time. He laid the foundation for the good times that followed. I’d have loved to have seen him stay for another season or two and see what he could have done with Lukaku in his side.

For the record I’m not advocating bringing him back for a second. Sadly I think his time is up.
Reply
#30
(05-15-2021, 08:42 AM)Duffers Wrote: There seems to be a touch of revisionism creeping in about Roy. Yes we weren’t great to watch at times, especially in the first few months of his reign, but he also gave us some of our best moments in all of our time in the PL. The 5-1 at Wolves, wins over the Seals, going toe to toe with some of the big boys, establishing us as a proper top flight outfit for the first time. He laid the foundation for the good times that followed. I’d have loved to have seen him stay for another season or two and see what he could have done with Lukaku in his side.

For the record I’m not advocating bringing him back for a second. Sadly I think his time is up.

Agree with this Duffers... there’s this latent feeling amongst the Sam and Pulis apologists that you can’t like Roy but then not like Sam and TTITC. 

Roy turned an ailing and disorganised side in free fall under RDM into a cohesive and competitive unit that finished comfortably mid table. He did effectively the job Sam has failed to do, and then continued to evolve us with very little money comparatively.

The football was often poor in home games, but particularly in his full season was fantastic away. We also showed up in the big games and took some fantastic wins in derby matches and upset a few big boys.

Much for the same reasons as I don’t want Sam next season, I don’t think Roy’s approach is conducive to a season where we need to win more often than not, and I have doubts about his ability to keep up with the rigours of a Championship season however if given a choice between Roy or Sam in the dugout next year, I’d take Roy every time.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: