James Tomkins
#21
He's better than what we've got although the bar is low.
Reply
#22
(12-17-2020, 06:52 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote:
(12-17-2020, 06:05 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(12-17-2020, 05:41 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Tomkins a tidy player for this level - though it does smack of a reversion to the tried and tested 30 somethings on big wages approach to recruitment which ultimately fucked us a few seasons ago.

I know our defence has been poor, but I don't think CB is an area we need to focus on, we need someone in midfield and someone up top first!

My take on this is that signing Tomkins will set O’Shea’s career back a number of years.

I can see what we are doing but we have spent last season building a younger squad to replace a much older squad. The younger squad could then progress and develop with a sprinkling of older heads.

I really like Slav for his honesty and enthusiasm. As has been debated to death there were issues but after Tuesday I was full of hope.

I get why we now have fat Sam and look at it as a means to an end so we can bring in new owners with a proper plan.

This is my fear, he spends 18 months filling the squad with has beens on high wages which we're then stuck with for 3 years, whilst at the same time blocking younger players development.

This is where Dowling needs to reign him in. I hope he was told as part of the process we're in the process of lowering the age of the squad.

I agree, we really don't want to go down that route again. A couple of experienced older heads is ok but we'll end up with massive problems again in a couple of years if we just sign players on the way down
Reply
#23
(12-17-2020, 06:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-17-2020, 06:38 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(12-17-2020, 04:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-17-2020, 03:59 PM)Olympic Wrote:
(12-17-2020, 03:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It seems some are still lobbing their toys out the pram at his arrival Wink

Perhaps because we see our rivals all with logical long term plans with shrewd managers and we are short term mugs who have just hired a dinosaur who’s signings will consist of likes of Tomkins.

Let’s not be melodramatic. Until four years ago Villa were falling to pieces and Wolves were going nowhere. Enjoy the ups and down because who knows where we will be if that ‘dinosaur’ keeps us up and the clubs ownership changes. Or we could act like petulant children and say it’s not fair!?! 

I think I would rather be in our position than Blues and Stoke for example given the state of football currently outside the Prem.

Yes re Stoke/blues but at the moment it's difficult to see when the ding/seals money is going to dry up.

All the more reason to try everything and anything to stay up and hope we sell the club to a similar owner.

I hope so Derek but both Villa and Wolves current owners brought them when in the Championship.

The issue with those buyers looking is that we are overpriced.
Reply
#24
albion_pigeon Wrote:
Jack Halford Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:Tomkins a tidy player for this level - though it does smack of a reversion to the tried and tested 30 somethings on big wages approach to recruitment which ultimately fucked us a few seasons ago.

I know our defence has been poor, but I don't think CB is an area we need to focus on, we need someone in midfield and someone up top first!

My take on this is that signing Tomkins will set O’Shea’s career back a number of years.

I can see what we are doing but we have spent last season building a younger squad to replace a much older squad. The younger squad could then progress and develop with a sprinkling of older heads.

I really like Slav for his honesty and enthusiasm. As has been debated to death there were issues but after Tuesday I was full of hope.

I get why we now have fat Sam and look at it as a means to an end so we can bring in new owners with a proper plan.

This is my fear, he spends 18 months filling the squad with has beens on high wages which we're then stuck with for 3 years, whilst at the same time blocking younger players development.

This is where Dowling needs to reign him in. I hope he was told as part of the process we're in the process of lowering the age of the squad.
Very much my fears too. Plus, Dowling has considerably more minuses than pluses against his name.
Reply
#25
(12-17-2020, 07:56 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
albion_pigeon Wrote:
Jack Halford Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:Tomkins a tidy player for this level - though it does smack of a reversion to the tried and tested 30 somethings on big wages approach to recruitment which ultimately fucked us a few seasons ago.

I know our defence has been poor, but I don't think CB is an area we need to focus on, we need someone in midfield and someone up top first!

My take on this is that signing Tomkins will set O’Shea’s career back a number of years.

I can see what we are doing but we have spent last season building a younger squad to replace a much older squad. The younger squad could then progress and develop with a sprinkling of older heads.

I really like Slav for his honesty and enthusiasm. As has been debated to death there were issues but after Tuesday I was full of hope.

I get why we now have fat Sam and look at it as a means to an end so we can bring in new owners with a proper plan.

This is my fear, he spends 18 months filling the squad with has beens on high wages which we're then stuck with for 3 years, whilst at the same time blocking younger players development.

This is where Dowling needs to reign him in. I hope he was told as part of the process we're in the process of lowering the age of the squad.
Very much my fears too. Plus, Dowling has considerably more minuses than pluses against his name.

Not very bright is young Luke, fancy admitting that Sam is the man we've wanted for some time    Rolleyes.  Always looks like his shirt collar  is 2 sizes too small and is about to explode.
Reply
#26
Based on the teams he had at Palace & Everton there is nothing to suggest he will overload the team with past it / old players.

People seriously think he is very similar to Pulis which couldn’t be further from the truth
Reply
#27
Very much doubt he'll be here in 18 months or even last the season.
Reply
#28
(12-17-2020, 09:19 PM)Hopalong Wrote: Very much doubt he'll be here in 18 months or even last the season.

He will last the season. Put the toys back in the pram. Whether you like him or not his record speaks for itself. Cannot think of a better manager for a battle which is exactly what we are in.

(12-17-2020, 07:56 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
albion_pigeon Wrote:
Jack Halford Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:Tomkins a tidy player for this level - though it does smack of a reversion to the tried and tested 30 somethings on big wages approach to recruitment which ultimately fucked us a few seasons ago.

I know our defence has been poor, but I don't think CB is an area we need to focus on, we need someone in midfield and someone up top first!

My take on this is that signing Tomkins will set O’Shea’s career back a number of years.

I can see what we are doing but we have spent last season building a younger squad to replace a much older squad. The younger squad could then progress and develop with a sprinkling of older heads.

I really like Slav for his honesty and enthusiasm. As has been debated to death there were issues but after Tuesday I was full of hope.

I get why we now have fat Sam and look at it as a means to an end so we can bring in new owners with a proper plan.

This is my fear, he spends 18 months filling the squad with has beens on high wages which we're then stuck with for 3 years, whilst at the same time blocking younger players development.

This is where Dowling needs to reign him in. I hope he was told as part of the process we're in the process of lowering the age of the squad.
Very much my fears too. Plus, Dowling has considerably more minuses than pluses against his name.

Here’s the three choices we have as a club...

Take chances with young players from the Chanpionship and hope it pays off
Bring young players through and hope they don’t get nicked along the way
Bring in proven older Prem players on free transfers.

On our current budget we shall not be bringing in Prem quality young players that are proven
Reply
#29
I really don't get this bollox about his record speaking for itself, his record at West Ham was worse than Slav's.... His overall Premiership record is not dissimilar to Slav's. FFS, why replace one with the other whose record is not substantially better?

I don't care anymore, and call me petulant or whatever, this is Pulis mk2, and the club will be worse for it again.
Reply
#30
(12-17-2020, 05:41 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Tomkins a tidy player for this level - though it does smack of a reversion to the tried and tested 30 somethings on big wages approach to recruitment which ultimately fucked us a few seasons ago.

I know our defence has been poor, but I don't think CB is an area we need to focus on, we need someone in midfield and someone up top first!

We probably need to strengthen all three areas. 

Centre half, a real snotter and target man.  Cam Zohore come back from the dead?  

It depends what formation too that LARD feels our squad is best suited to.  Could be 3-5-2.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)