Place your theory here...
#21
(11-03-2020, 11:17 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 07:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Hospitalisations up, excess deaths up, following the same pattern as March. What possible reason could there be?

Total mortality since June the same as ever. No story.
No need for lockdown. Just killing others

29 hospitals out of 482 were struggling as per Whittys slides. So 463 weren't ..

Admissions rise the same as this time last year for the same period. Didn't see you clamouring for lockdown last year in an exactly similar flu season..

Wakey wakey

All of these figures are for England and Wales.

Total mortality 2020 since June: 159,369
Total mortality 2019 for the same weeks (27 to 43): 159,269
Total mortality 5YA for the same weeks: 157,318

Absolutely spot on Billy, but a strange date choice when we are looking at the point in time since the hospitalisations started to increase which was mid-september.

Total mortality since 5th September 2020 (week 37): 70,140
Total mortality 2019 for same weeks (37 to 43): 68,419
Total mortality 5YA for the same weeks: 66,937

Added to that, as I explained on the other thread, the next week reported (next Tuesday reporting of week 44) is the worrying one. That is the one that, if we are following the same pattern as March / April, will be the one where it starts to ramp up. I genuinely hope not. But saying that we are normal compared to last year a) doesn't look at a 5 year average and b) means that we miss the upwards trend that we are seeing currently. You criticise the scientists for using old data and then you use it yourself to make a point.

On your other points, we shouldn't have to wait for a hospital to start struggling before we do something about it. Being proactive to prevent hospitals getting to being overrun is the right thing to do.

And this isn't flu, we know this is more deadly than flu simply by the fact that we have 62,555 excess deaths in 2020 compared to 2019, and 56,102 against the 5 year average. Locking down last year would have prevented hospitals getting over run for a period, locking down this year is to prevent hospitals getting over run and also to reduce the spread of a virus that kills more people.

And FFS, stop using 'wakey wakey', as if you are the only person that sees the truth. If you want to debate points without the condescending tone then I am happy to do that, if you want to start slinging insults then I'm also happy to do that. This is the second time in a few days I've had to ask for that courtesy, I'll just go straight to calling you a looney toon conspiracy theorist next time.
Reply
#22
(11-04-2020, 12:08 AM)Ossian Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 07:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still waiting for an answer to the original question. Lots of skirting around the issue, soapboxing, trying to move the the story on but no answers.

An administration - not for the first time - overtaken by events and responding too late is what I see, Derek. No conspiracy on this occasion (although this shower are well capable of it); no direction either, just prevarication to the point where doing nothing is no longer an option and culminating in a half-baked response. A two-week breaker utilising one of the school half-term weeks would probably have had more impact.

One thing I would have done is test everyone who has an appointment for their annual flu jab; if not a test for current infection, since test kits appear even now to be in limited supply, at the very least an antibody test to establish the extent of past penetration of the elderly and vulnerable demographic. I doubt anybody in government, or elsewhere, has any real idea how many of us have already been infected over the past 12 months.

Boris only ever really wanted the job title; he never much fancied the work.

Thank you Oss for an actual answer and great to have you back. I tend to agree with your theory that it’s incompetence rather than conspiracy on this occasion. “Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.” Hanlon’s Razor

If I was a conspiracy nutjob (which I’m not) I may argue that by continually claiming the NHS isn’t going to or isn’t coping and framing test and trace and accompanying app as the ‘NHS’ they can then erode public trust in it. This will soften up the gullible base to believe they would be better off with a reformed NHS a euphemism for privatising the service further with the ultimate and long term goal of a health insurance system. A managed process with short term pain for the Tory popularity for long term gain. This is hypothetical musing without facts to back it up but at least it’s a theory. 

Over to the ‘Let go back to normal’ bods to give an answer rather than slogans and identikit answers you see all over social media.
Reply
#23
(11-03-2020, 07:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still waiting for an answer to the original question. Lots of skirting around the issue, soapboxing, trying to move the the story on but no answers.

The original question is flawed, as has been pointed out to you.
Reply
#24
(11-04-2020, 09:05 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 11:17 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 07:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Hospitalisations up, excess deaths up, following the same pattern as March. What possible reason could there be?

Total mortality since June the same as ever. No story.
No need for lockdown. Just killing others

29 hospitals out of 482 were struggling as per Whittys slides. So 463 weren't ..

Admissions rise the same as this time last year for the same period. Didn't see you clamouring for lockdown last year in an exactly similar flu season..

Wakey wakey

All of these figures are for England and Wales.

Total mortality 2020 since June: 159,369
Total mortality 2019 for the same weeks (27 to 43): 159,269
Total mortality 5YA for the same weeks: 157,318

Absolutely spot on Billy, but a strange date choice when we are looking at the point in time since the hospitalisations started to increase which was mid-september.

Total mortality since 5th September 2020 (week 37): 70,140
Total mortality 2019 for same weeks (37 to 43): 68,419
Total mortality 5YA for the same weeks: 66,937

Added to that, as I explained on the other thread, the next week reported (next Tuesday reporting of week 44) is the worrying one. That is the one that, if we are following the same pattern as March / April, will be the one where it starts to ramp up. I genuinely hope not. But saying that we are normal compared to last year a) doesn't look at a 5 year average and b) means that we miss the upwards trend that we are seeing currently. You criticise the scientists for using old data and then you use it yourself to make a point.

On your other points, we shouldn't have to wait for a hospital to start struggling before we do something about it. Being proactive to prevent hospitals getting to being overrun is the right thing to do.

And this isn't flu, we know this is more deadly than flu simply by the fact that we have 62,555 excess deaths in 2020 compared to 2019, and 56,102 against the 5 year average. Locking down last year would have prevented hospitals getting over run for a period, locking down this year is to prevent hospitals getting over run and also to reduce the spread of a virus that kills more people.

And FFS, stop using 'wakey wakey', as if you are the only person that sees the truth. If you want to debate points without the condescending tone then I am happy to do that, if you want to start slinging insults then I'm also happy to do that. This is the second time in a few days I've had to ask for that courtesy, I'll just go straight to calling you a looney toon conspiracy theorist next time.

I use the same date period as Whitty and Vallance. Thus to come to their conclusion they must be looking at a different virus. That's the point of my post. The evidence for a second lockdown. The have predicted deaths at a much bigger rate than in the Spring. It's downright corruption. You literally have to rescale the graph from the spring down by many factors.

It's not more deadly than flu. I again point you to 0.12-2% Iannidis. And with every revision it is coming down. I could go into further detail but it's too late anyway.

I'll tell you something that may well be more deadly than flu and that's the 2 lockdowns. Way more deadly on all counts.

Some hospitals are near capacity the other 420 are not. In fact many are seeing fewer patients than this time last year.

If doesn't matter like I say anymore. For some reason the people of this country and the morons who manage it are hell bent on killing more people over a longer time period alongside businesses and the economy. I'll just go and lock myself away on my Xbox for a month and hope my family comes through it.
Reply
#25
Simple facts and you keep disputing them - 62k (or 56k dependant on the measure) excess deaths in England and Wales in 2020 so far, when have we ever had that number before? Flu has never caused that many excess deaths but you say it is the same - forget about the tests, cases, measuring and whatever that you yourself say are so flawed, what has caused those excess deaths and why hasn't flu caused that many in the past if it is equally as deadly?
Reply
#26
(11-04-2020, 10:01 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 07:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still waiting for an answer to the original question. Lots of skirting around the issue, soapboxing, trying to move the the story on but no answers.

The original question is flawed, as has been pointed out to you.

No it’s not. I think you’re confusing not being able to answer the question with it being flawed. 

The idea that normal is fixed is flawed given circumstances change but the usual suspects keep using it.
Reply
#27
I'm not disputing the number of deaths in spring. As I've said many times I'm disputing they were all covid. They clearly weren't given many died at home and were branded covid but never tested, that the test used is flawed and those that did go into hospital many were definitely nosocomial.

Also the 2019 winter flu was a much lower epidemic than in previous years. Also our country has a certain demographic. You can't say something is virulent or not based on a single county of a certain demographic. Hence why that WHO report across 61 countries is being done.

I'm not denying there was an impact though.

I'm.amazed to see today that the BBC is running some stories regarding Heath Service Journal.reports that beds are 80% occupied lower than last year. I also see them reporting upto 37% sick rates for hospital staff because of isolation requirements affecting bed numbers not admissions. The madness of track and trace a complete waste of time see WHO November 2019.

Perhaps there's starting to be a shift...too late but maybe some people's braincells are starting to fire
Reply
#28
And here is the crux of the matter, if the 62k/56k excess deaths weren't all due to covid what were they then? And it is a bit of a coincidence that the whole world seems to be having a lot of excess deaths at the time that covid arrives, but by your theory they are all having something else going on.
Reply
#29
Maybe I'm missing something as I don't read every post on each thread that inevitably degenerates into the same thing but Billy - you consistently use phrases like 'wake up' etc but I'm not really sure what we're supposed to be waking up to? Have you made that clear somewhere and could you link it? That the govt is conspiring to keep us in lockdown unnecessarily? To what end?
Reply
#30
Tick tock
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: