Ratings
#21
I thought everyone in midfield or upfront was pretty poor frankly. Sure HRK and Harper scored, but outside of that they stunk. All midfielders were basically useless. The defenders and goalie were ok.
Reply
#22
My take on things

Button 8 Shocked nobody has scored him higher. Did everything SJ doesn't & looked supremely confident which is half the battle.

Peltier 6 - Steady, one paced.
Townsend 6 - Ditto
Kipre 7 - Fairly good first showing & has potential to improve
o'Shea 7 -Captain material in years to come

Harper 6 - As others have said it's sublime to ridiculous. Needs a loan
Field 7 - Good player & I hope we see more of him. Want him to stay.
Grosicki 5 - Not his night but always a danger with his pace &* dead ball ability.
Edwards 8 - MOTM for his 2nd half. Hope he can kick on now.

HRK 5 - Cracking goal but can't pass Ten yards. Typical Kanu really.
Austin 4 - Bar a couple of decent balls through he looks finished. Great if we can find a taker to free up the wage.

Robinson 6
Phillips 5
Sawyers 5
Reply
#23
(09-17-2020, 05:38 AM)B36baggie Wrote: My take on things

Button 8 Shocked nobody has scored him higher. Did everything SJ doesn't & looked supremely confident which is half the battle.

Peltier 6 - Steady, one paced.
Townsend 6 - Ditto
Kipre 7 - Fairly good first showing & has potential to improve
o'Shea 7 -Captain material in years to come

Harper 6 - As others have said it's sublime to ridiculous. Needs a loan
Field 7 - Good player & I hope we see more of him. Want him to stay.
Grosicki 5 - Not his night but always a danger with his pace &* dead ball ability.
Edwards 8 - MOTM for his 2nd half. Hope he can kick on now.

HRK 5 - Cracking goal but can't pass Ten yards. Typical Kanu really.
Austin 4  - Bar a couple of decent balls through he looks finished. Great if we can find a taker to free up the wage.

Robinson 6
Phillips 5
Sawyers 5

Pretty much my view too. I thought Benjamin had an excellent debut, and I was pleasantly surprised at how he dominated his area, and his kicking set up a few attacks too.

I think both Harper and Edwards drift in and out of games and need to impose themselves more. Field has a fine game defensively, and I'd like to see more of him in match squads this year. He could help us close games off.

HRK and Austin were just generally poor. If you add Zohore into the mix, we've currently got the worse strikeforce in the Prem by some way. Definitely need a couple of additions before deadline.
Reply
#24
albion_pigeon Wrote:
Sliced Wrote:Honestly I thought prior to the goal HRK was absolutely shocking, and not much better after. Austin will be remembered for the misses but his overall contribution was fine. A couple of cracking final balls. The problem is I don't see how he can fit in the team if he's now struggling to score and has lost his pace.

What was clear is that Robinson is head and shoulders above both.

Also thought the defence were a bit shaky initially but got better as the game progressed. Would go with:

Button 7

Peltier.  7.
Kipre. 7.
O'Shea. 7.
Townsend. 6.

Grosicki 4
Harper. 7
Field. 6
Edwards. 9

Austin. 6
HRK. 6

Subs:

Sawyers. 5.
Phillips. 6. 
Robinson. 7.

Thought Austin was awful

Button 7

Peltier.  7
Kipre. 7
O'Shea. 7
Townsend. 6 

Grosicki 4
Harper. 7
Field. 7
Edwards. 8

Austin. 3
HRK. 6 

Subs:

Sawyers. 6
Phillips. 5 
Robinson. 7

This
Reply
#25
Due to parental duties I managed to see only about one hour of the game and missed all the goals (I'm cursed). My thoughts, FWIW.

Too many long balls being played in the first half.

I agree with comments about Button.

Grosicki always looks better on the left.

Field looks to have beefed up. Needs to look up and try to see the forward pass a bit more, but if his brief was to break up attacks and keep possession, then he more than met his target. Would like to see him on the subs bench in the PL.

Harper needs a season on loan in the championship.

I think Austin can do a job for us from the bench this season if we need a goal late on. I saw 2 chances, one where he did everything right but the defender was on the line and another where Field most likely obscured his view of the ball. He was at least in the right places. Definitely not got the legs to start games.
Reply
#26
Slav has told Field he's not going anywhere as he is the sort of Holding midfielder that we don't. So no point calling for loans etc...
Reply
#27
(09-17-2020, 05:38 AM)B36baggie Wrote: My take on things

Button 8 Shocked nobody has scored him higher. Did everything SJ doesn't & looked supremely confident which is half the battle.

Peltier 6 - Steady, one paced.
Townsend 6 - Ditto
Kipre 7 - Fairly good first showing & has potential to improve
o'Shea 7 -Captain material in years to come

Harper 6 - As others have said it's sublime to ridiculous. Needs a loan
Field 7 - Good player & I hope we see more of him. Want him to stay.
Grosicki 5 - Not his night but always a danger with his pace &* dead ball ability.
Edwards 8 - MOTM for his 2nd half. Hope he can kick on now.

HRK 5 - Cracking goal but can't pass Ten yards. Typical Kanu really.
Austin 4  - Bar a couple of decent balls through he looks finished. Great if we can find a taker to free up the wage.

Robinson 6
Phillips 5
Sawyers 5

Just a thought, if we were interested in Morelos from Rangers, could HRK, Austin or Zohore be a part ex?
Reply
#28
(09-17-2020, 09:14 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Slav has told Field he's not going anywhere as he is the sort of Holding midfielder that we don't. So no point calling for loans etc...

Where’s this from?

Slav was more than happy to move Field on a few weeks ago. 

Whilst Harper has probably more natural assets, Field is far more of the player we need than Rak at present.
Reply
#29
Apparantly, and pinch of salt etc, Field played himself into Slavs plans in pre season. He'll be staying, I hope with plenty of game time, I rate him personally, one we'll regret losing if we do.
Reply
#30
(09-17-2020, 09:57 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 09:14 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Slav has told Field he's not going anywhere as he is the sort of Holding midfielder that we don't. So no point calling for loans etc...

Where’s this from?

Slav was more than happy to move Field on a few weeks ago. 

https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/f...i-18947640

Good to hear IMO.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: