Citeh Guilty
(10-20-2026, 12:02 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Let them keep their titles, it’ll be a meaningless punishment by taking their names out of the record books. Transfer in ban for 10 years or the length of time this has been going on for. £10m donation to all clubs in the 92

I can't agree, mon. Whatever happens, stripping them of their unfair titles should be the very starting point.
Reply
It's so complex as they are a big club by any standards- for instance even without the past sheikh sheckles years they were certainly one of the biggest 12 or so clubs in the country.

Relegate them 3 divisions and they'll be back in 3 years.

They have to go low down the pyramid and a punishment allowing for at least 5 years out of the top flight.

Although I'm not surprised I find the defiance of many of their fans classless. I think all clubs would feel the same- I guess many of their older fans will be sickened by it all.
Reply
Arsenal Wenger has now weighed in. Taking the tough approach. Whatever happens I'm expecting a disappointment.
Reply
Can UEFA get involved as well, banned from European competitions for 5 years maybe.
Reply
(10-20-2026, 01:20 PM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote: It's so complex as they are a big club by any standards- for instance even without the past sheikh sheckles years they were certainly one of the biggest 12 or so clubs in the country.

Relegate them 3 divisions and they'll be back in 3 years.

They have to go low down the pyramid and a punishment allowing for at least 5 years out of the top flight.

Although I'm not surprised I find the defiance of many of their fans classless. I think all clubs would feel the same- I guess many of their older fans will be sickened by it all.

I think they should suffer the same fate as Rangers and be bounced out of the league to whatever is the equivalent of the National Conference these days and be forced to make their way back through the leagues, while being subject to the most onerous PSR we can devise.  
But "the defiance" of their fans is IMO 100% both understandable and excellent.  Don't forget the absolute shite their "older fans" had to put up with from United and Liverpool while hoardes of glory hunting wankers who knew fuck all about either Manchester or Liverpool swelled their attendances and financed their success.  Read "Manchester United ruined my life" by Colin Schindler an excellent book by a Citeh fan, written when they were shit, who lives with "his nose pressed up against the sweet shop window watching the United supporters take all the wine gums"  If I was a City fan I'd be absolutely loving this and thinking the fact the Red cartel feels swindled makes it even better and fuck 'em all.
Reply
(10-20-2026, 03:00 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote:
(10-20-2026, 01:20 PM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote: It's so complex as they are a big club by any standards- for instance even without the past sheikh sheckles years they were certainly one of the biggest 12 or so clubs in the country.

Relegate them 3 divisions and they'll be back in 3 years.

They have to go low down the pyramid and a punishment allowing for at least 5 years out of the top flight.

Although I'm not surprised I find the defiance of many of their fans classless. I think all clubs would feel the same- I guess many of their older fans will be sickened by it all.

I think they should suffer the same fate as Rangers and be bounced out of the league to whatever is the equivalent of the National Conference these days and be forced to make their way back through the leagues, while being subject to the most onerous PSR we can devise.  
But "the defiance" of their fans is IMO 100% both understandable and excellent.  Don't forget the absolute shite their "older fans" had to put up with from United and Liverpool while hoardes of glory hunting wankers who knew fuck all about either Manchester or Liverpool swelled their attendances and financed their success.  Read "Manchester United ruined my life" by Colin Schindler an excellent book by a Citeh fan, written when they were shit, who lives with "his nose pressed up against the sweet shop window watching the United supporters take all the wine gums"  If I was a City fan I'd be absolutely loving this and thinking the fact the Red cartel feels swindled makes it even better and fuck 'em all.
Two wrongs dont make a right. The defiance is delusion and self-deception since they had morphed into the same arrogant and entitled shits they decried regarding the mythical Red Cartel (which includes Arsenal in their paranoia). I loatged the last game I went to at their ground Feb 2018. Shits. Fuck them.

And relax.
Reply
This ‘red cartel’ is ironic given that UAE is a member of OPEC
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
If City were moved down the leagues. I wouldn't expect an immediate return like some folks are assuming (it is possible, BTW, I'm not saying that), I just think it'll be tougher than people think.
Reply
(10-20-2026, 03:21 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: If City were moved down the leagues. I wouldn't expect an immediate return like some folks are assuming (it is possible, BTW, I'm not saying that), I just think it'll be tougher than people think.

Unless they get Ryan Mason in? Will piss through the divisions then...
Reply
It needs a multi purpose punishment
100 points deduction and 5 years transfer ban before the transfer window to ensure they are relegated and get no rewards 
Then a fine equivalent to the impact of their cheating had on all clubs in the premiership since the cheating started 
The Football ball league should then relegate them to the 3rd division to start again c/f Rangers FC

This heavy punishment will make sure others never break the rules again 

On top of this the rules should be be very clear and properly monitored by the governing bodies, this applies to any purchase or transfer of ownership so that they ensure that ownership is fit for purpose
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)