Citeh Guilty
They should not be allowed into the EFL, it completely skews the league and in reality it’ll just be a couple of years and a slap on the wrist.
Reply
I really don't envy the FA or the Premier League in this situation - it will be impossible to please everyone, and I doubt anybody when writing the various laws and regulations could have imagined cheating on this scale over such a long period would even be considered, let alone possible.

Fans of other PL sides rightly want City kicked out, but as DH says, relegating them only penalises Championship clubs as it takes away a promotion place in an already uneven league - you only have to look at West Ham's budget versus the rest of the division - even W*lves signed two players this summer on c.100k/wk in Jimenez and Trippier. Man City would be a whole other level of uncompetitiveness. No matter how far down the leagues you go, it's the same issue, why should League One or League Two clubs suffer for it? Admittedly they'd probably all vote for the revenue boost a 2 games per season against City would bring mind.

Fines at this point are meaningless, and even if shared out with other PL sides, it'll just be spent on another player, or giving existing ones even higher salaries and hefty points deductions are unlikely to mean anything other than a couple of seasons without Europe - but as United have shown, clubs with their levels of revenue can continue to spend cash even without regular CL football, and within a couple of years I imagine City will be back in the title race again.

I really don't know what the FA do here - I'm not even sure what punishment I'd like to see them given, it's just such a crazy situation. The one thing I hope is that the IFR, FA and EFL review their processes and understand how this situation has even been allowed to happen. Governance has truly failed if a club can cheat so brazenly for a decade and only now be facing consequences after fans of other clubs have missed out memories and moments of joy due to a consistent and deliberate act of cheating.
Reply
As I've seen others write (elsewhere), if they get relegated, then surely Seals / Newcastle will just go, fuck it, 8 years at the top is worth a single season Champ relegation, where you'll break all the records.

League expulsion really is the only answer. Along with a buying ban. They being in the non-league level would bring fans into the lower level grounds, but again would guarantee a lost promotion place.

The only way a Champ relegation would harm them is if all their stars have relegation release clauses, which you'd think they never even considered.

Champ relegation is no punishment, except for the rest of us.
Reply
(10-20-2026, 07:47 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I really don't envy the FA or the Premier League in this situation - it will be impossible to please everyone, and I doubt anybody when writing the various laws and regulations could have imagined cheating on this scale over such a long period would even be considered, let alone possible.

Fans of other PL sides rightly want City kicked out, but as DH says, relegating them only penalises Championship clubs as it takes away a promotion place in an already uneven league - you only have to look at West Ham's budget versus the rest of the division - even W*lves signed two players this summer on c.100k/wk in Jimenez and Trippier. Man City would be a whole other level of uncompetitiveness. No matter how far down the leagues you go, it's the same issue, why should League One or League Two clubs suffer for it? Admittedly they'd probably all vote for the revenue boost a 2 games per season against City would bring mind.

Fines at this point are meaningless, and even if shared out with other PL sides, it'll just be spent on another player, or giving existing ones even higher salaries and hefty points deductions are unlikely to mean anything other than a couple of seasons without Europe - but as United have shown, clubs with their levels of revenue can continue to spend cash even without regular CL football, and within a couple of years I imagine City will be back in the title race again.

I really don't know what the FA do here - I'm not even sure what punishment I'd like to see them given, it's just such a crazy situation. The one thing I hope is that the IFR, FA and EFL review their processes and understand how this situation has even been allowed to happen. Governance has truly failed if a club can cheat so brazenly for a decade and only now be facing consequences after fans of other clubs have missed out memories and moments of joy due to a consistent and deliberate act of cheating.
Well put. I've sat around contemplating what punishment actually both fits the crime and compensates those that have missed out and I really can't think of anything satisfactory.
Reply
Owners not fit and proper- remove. Club to be sold. Expelled from Premier League. Not allowed into EFL. Start again at the very bottom. Supporters have buckets of cold puke thrown over them for being arseholes over this. Or Budweiser.
Reply
(10-20-2026, 08:52 AM)Hudds2 Wrote: Owners not fit and proper- remove. Club to be sold. Expelled from Premier League. Not allowed into EFL. Start again at the very bottom. Supporters have buckets of cold puke thrown over them for being arseholes over this. Or Budweiser.

This, totally this. Apart from the puke or Bud. Make them share a bed with FF and ist.
Reply
It has to be a deterrent, whatever it is. It also has to recompense the rest of us - even if we'd just kept Fellows where would we have finished last season? Then you've got your Newcastles and Vilers being held down by the rules City don't bother with. Wind them up.
Reply
(10-20-2026, 08:52 AM)Hudds2 Wrote: Owners not fit and proper- remove. Club to be sold. Expelled from Premier League. Not allowed into EFL. Start again at the very bottom. Supporters have buckets of cold puke thrown over them for being arseholes over this. Or Budweiser.

This, but remove all their titles too
Reply
They've had 7 years to come up with a suitable punishment and you can bet your bottom dollar it will not be doing us any favours!
Reply
(10-20-2026, 08:52 AM)Hudds2 Wrote: Owners not fit and proper- remove.  Club to be sold. Expelled from Premier League.  Not allowed into EFL.  Start again at the very bottom.  Supporters have buckets of cold puke thrown over them for being arseholes over this.  Or Budweiser.

Dousing their supporters in Budweiser might be going a little over the top in fairness.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)