Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(03-03-2020, 10:16 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Phillips MOTM for me. Always a threat and didn't deserve to be on the losing side.
I think Brunt or Barry can still play a bit part this season, but certainly not together. Bloody Hell, that alone cost us the tie.
I still think Edwards gets a raw deal on here. Still way too early to judge him and he can be a proper handful to defend against.
If Edwards can get constancy with his decision making and final ball like his run and cross for Zahore goal he will be a very good player imo.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
I know we have a lot of matches to play, but with hindsight it was folly to start with Brunt, Barry and Harper at the expense of a creative spark like Krov.
I've been irritated by the constant calls for Barry and (to a lesser extent) Brunt on this 'ere bored. Tonight we've seen why they don't often get on the bench these days.
Austin should never be picked ahead of Zohore, IMO. His goal scoring record (including the odd pen, of course) belies his absolute uselessness in general play. He looks like a 35 year old. Why couldn't we sign one competent forward instead of two rubbish ones?
As I'm old enough to have seen the Baggies win the League Cup and FA Cup, I'm happy to say that it's a distraction. Promotion, and hopefully the Championship trophy, is what we need this season. But we made an effort in the second half and made the score respectable. There are positives to take from that.
Posts: 439
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
OShea. Can't believe I've watched the same game. Thought he did very well all round. Put s real shift in and if it weren't for the midfield letting him down in front marshalled his men well.
Furlong non existent for me and first half OShea had to come across numerous times to cover.
Edwards did well when Krov came on and allowed him to give and go .
Harper good in patches some nice touches but goes to sleep at times.
Phillips Motm a class above until Krov came on
Austin . Busted flush on his own .
Gibbs. A game under the belt but it was obviously feeling his way back
Bartley solid enough but the two centre backs were so exposed until Krov came on because of the lack of cover that allowed Newcastle to have time to play balls through our back line.
Bond good saves but maybe could have done better with the third that was handball but see no reason for the criticism.
Bilic. We all get it why he changed the team. But against such a pacey Newcastle front line was always asking for trouble unless we were just going to sit very deep. He owes us a big result on Saturday
Posts: 1,352
Threads: 22
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
Krovinovic was MOTM by a country mile and he only played half an hour.
Posts: 760
Threads: 71
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
6
03-03-2020, 11:15 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-03-2020, 11:16 PM by Baggeridgebaggy.)
(03-03-2020, 10:10 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I saw it a little differently
Bond 3 Barely put a foot...or glove wrong in an Albion shirt so far but struggled tonight, sloppy handling, looked short of confidence and at fault for 3rd goal
Furlong 7 Thought he played well,defended well in the air, quick across the ground, really feel he should be getting the nod at RB
Bartley 6 Thought he did OK, led by example at times and stuck close to Joelinton in the first half
OnShea 4 In his favored position he looked out of his depth to me, seemed fazed, and dare I say bullied in the first half by their front two, as per Furlong comments I’m unsure why he’s currently getting the nod
Gibbs 5 Much better 2nd half, 90 will do him good, looked rusty as an old gate in the first half
Barry 3 Old Father Time has caught up with him I’m afraid, a yard too slow all over the park
Brunt 3 See Barry, a shame to see but likely his last game in an Albion shirt
Harper 7* Tired towards the end. And a couple of sloppy passes but don’t overlook his other work, some great control, better tempo than before and rove is forward at times
Edwards 6 Excellent 2nd half and great play for Kens goal,too tepid first half, must back his ability more
Phillips 7 Thought he did well tonight, always a threat, popping up in the box and running in behind
Austin 5 Can’t fruit his effort and at times his movement was good tonight but hopeless as a lone striker, which unfortunately for him is how we set up
Subs
Krovinovic 7 Turned the game, good to see him back to his recent best
Zahore 6 Showed why I’ve championed him getting the nod on the bench over Austin, just brings a different dynamic to our play
Tulloch Too little time
Cuzer Agree with this completely
It’s there for everyone to see that OShea isn’t good enough or athletic enough to be a CB at that level
He’s not a bad FB, but should not be getting picked ahead of Furlong
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(03-03-2020, 10:10 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I saw it a little differently
Bond 3 Barely put a foot...or glove wrong in an Albion shirt so far but struggled tonight, sloppy handling, looked short of confidence and at fault for 3rd goal
Furlong 7 Thought he played well,defended well in the air, quick across the ground, really feel he should be getting the nod at RB
Bartley 6 Thought he did OK, led by example at times and stuck close to Joelinton in the first half
OnShea 4 In his favored position he looked out of his depth to me, seemed fazed, and dare I say bullied in the first half by their front two, as per Furlong comments I’m unsure why he’s currently getting the nod
Gibbs 5 Much better 2nd half, 90 will do him good, looked rusty as an old gate in the first half
Barry 3 Old Father Time has caught up with him I’m afraid, a yard too slow all over the park
Brunt 3 See Barry, a shame to see but likely his last game in an Albion shirt
Harper 7* Tired towards the end. And a couple of sloppy passes but don’t overlook his other work, some great control, better tempo than before and rove is forward at times
Edwards 6 Excellent 2nd half and great play for Kens goal,too tepid first half, must back his ability more
Phillips 7 Thought he did well tonight, always a threat, popping up in the box and running in behind
Austin 5 Can’t fruit his effort and at times his movement was good tonight but hopeless as a lone striker, which unfortunately for him is how we set up
Subs
Krovinovic 7 Turned the game, good to see him back to his recent best
Zahore 6 Showed why I’ve championed him getting the nod on the bench over Austin, just brings a different dynamic to our play
Tulloch Too little time
Cuzer
Think the only thing we disagree on is Furlong, and maybe I was a little harsh with his score.
He's a better fullback than O'Shea, but his defending leaves us exposed without Phillips ahead of him, who definitely does the most defensive work of all our wingers.... without Phillips ahead of him Furlong leaves too much space, whereas O'Shea enables us to leave another man further forward knowing he has the security of someone behind.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(03-03-2020, 11:21 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (03-03-2020, 10:10 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I saw it a little differently
Bond 3 Barely put a foot...or glove wrong in an Albion shirt so far but struggled tonight, sloppy handling, looked short of confidence and at fault for 3rd goal
Furlong 7 Thought he played well,defended well in the air, quick across the ground, really feel he should be getting the nod at RB
Bartley 6 Thought he did OK, led by example at times and stuck close to Joelinton in the first half
OnShea 4 In his favored position he looked out of his depth to me, seemed fazed, and dare I say bullied in the first half by their front two, as per Furlong comments I’m unsure why he’s currently getting the nod
Gibbs 5 Much better 2nd half, 90 will do him good, looked rusty as an old gate in the first half
Barry 3 Old Father Time has caught up with him I’m afraid, a yard too slow all over the park
Brunt 3 See Barry, a shame to see but likely his last game in an Albion shirt
Harper 7* Tired towards the end. And a couple of sloppy passes but don’t overlook his other work, some great control, better tempo than before and rove is forward at times
Edwards 6 Excellent 2nd half and great play for Kens goal,too tepid first half, must back his ability more
Phillips 7 Thought he did well tonight, always a threat, popping up in the box and running in behind
Austin 5 Can’t fruit his effort and at times his movement was good tonight but hopeless as a lone striker, which unfortunately for him is how we set up
Subs
Krovinovic 7 Turned the game, good to see him back to his recent best
Zahore 6 Showed why I’ve championed him getting the nod on the bench over Austin, just brings a different dynamic to our play
Tulloch Too little time
Cuzer
Think the only thing we disagree on is Furlong, and maybe I was a little harsh with his score.
He's a better fullback than O'Shea, but his defending leaves us exposed without Phillips ahead of him, who definitely does the most defensive work of all our wingers.... without Phillips ahead of him Furlong leaves too much space, whereas O'Shea enables us to leave another man further forward knowing he has the security of someone behind.
Slav has said it’s all about balance and I totally get that
I just feel with Furlongs pace he often gets back quicker when he does venture forward, he’s very good in the air for a full back, just as good as O Shea for me and he’s quicker, a better crosser of the ball and reads the game better
I’m not knocking O Shea as he’s a had a breakthrough season but Furlong is the better option as I see it
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(03-03-2020, 10:14 PM)Sliced Wrote: Pretty much agree with all that. For his no rating I thought Tulloch was lively
Given he had just a few minutes and the circumstances thought he looked really sharp.
Must tie this kid down a future star.
Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(03-04-2020, 01:33 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (03-03-2020, 10:14 PM)Sliced Wrote: Pretty much agree with all that. For his no rating I thought Tulloch was lively
Given he had just a few minutes and the circumstances thought he looked really sharp.
Must tie this kid down a future star.
Didn't the E&D say he was being released in the summer?
|